Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

news.ycombinator.com

101–110 of 194 posts

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#102
post #55

The Road to Reality by Roger Penrose. https://www.nytimes.com/2005/02/27/books/review/the-road-to-...

This book is totally inappropriate for learning mathematics, especially for a teenager. A well-prepared layman, maybe, but not a teenager who just wants a good introduction to the subject.

I would be absolutely flabbergasted if a layman could get through Road to Reality. Even those with an engineering or computer science background would struggle considerably.

That said, it serves as a great overview of physics for mathematicians and perhaps as very casual intro to twistor theory for physicists.

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#103

Jan Gullberg - Mathematics: From the Birth of Numbers https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/039304002X Amazon.com Review What does mathematics mean? Is it numbers or arithmetic, proofs or equations? Jan Gullberg starts his massive historical overview with some insight into why human beings find it necessary to "reckon," or count, and what math means to us. From there to the last chapter, on differential equations, is a v…

I remember reading this book in 11th grade and I absolutely loved it. It made me appreciate math much more and showed me the beauty of mathematics. It helped me overcome my math anxiety.

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#104

Some of the books that you mention seem a bit too hard for a teen, so you have to be careful not to demotivate them by expecting too much of them; instead i suggest a simpler approach before tackling the big ones; * Functions and Graphs by Gelfand et al. - A small but great book to develop intuition. * Who is Fourier? A Mathematical Adventure - A great "manga type" book to build important concepts from first principl…

Just wanted to chime in regarding Concepts of modern mathematics.

Really enjoyed reading it when I was in college. It's not a textbook, just a prose book for enjoyable reading, but it's inspirational and a very interesting overview of the field of mathematics.

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#105
I remember Pi in the Sky by John Barrows very fondly. It has more of a focus on geometry and logic.

A Programmer's Introduction to Mathematics by Jeremy Kun is wide ranging and appropriate if there is also interest in programming.

Nature and Growth of Modern Mathematics by Edna Kramer is a wonderful book if history is a passion as well.

Elements of Mathematics by John Stillwell is a broad overview of subjects. It has a crisp mathematical feel to it.

Vector Calculus, Linear Algebra, and Differential Forms by John & Barbara Hubbard is a beautiful introduction to the multi-dimensional aspects, but it is a book that should happen after knowing one dimensional calculus. .

If your child hasn't been exposed to Guesstimation, then a book on that is highly recommended. The book with that title by Weinstein and Adams is a nice guide to investigating that realm.

If the child does arithmetic from right to left, as is sadly too common, the book Speed Mathematics Simplified by Edward Stoddard is a great remedy for that.

Everyday Calculus by Oscar Fernandez could also be worth a look.

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#106
The princeton companion is nice to have around, but you do not really read it end to end.

Spivak's calculus you bring to the beach and read it between swim and swim.

EDIT: Also, some books by Hilbert are breathtakingly beautiful: Geometry and the Imagination (just the chapter on synthetic differential geometry is worth more than 10 other great books), and the Methods of Mathematical Physics is also great. It begins by giving three proofs of cauchy-schwartz inequality, and then goes on to give several different definitions of the eigenvectors of a matrix. Both of those make great beach readings for this summer.

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#107
post #37

During the first year of my undergrad someone introduced me to Gödel, Escher, Bach. I thought it was mind blowing at the time and still find it to be an incredible introduction to formal systems, thinking mathematically and understanding the concept of proofs. All these concepts are central to higher level mathematics, and are not covered in high school (at least not the Danish one). I'm was very thankful for that in…

I have to disagree with you here, and strongly. I don't think Gödel, Escher, Bach is a good book. Hofstaeder is clearly very smart, curious, and open-minded, and I love all those things, but the book itself is just so pretentious and sort of pointless. It's precisely the wrong kind of book you want to give a bright teenager, because it will only encourage them to get a head-start inserting their head up their own ars…

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#108
Concrete Mathematics by Knuth and Patashnik (already mentioned for u/pmiller2) if the kid likes numbers. That's perhaps the guiding thread of the book -- it's about the beautiful (yet usually very elementary and natural) things you can do with numbers.

Geometry Revisited by Coxeter and Greitzer and/or Episodes in Nineteenth and Twentieth Century Euclidean Geometry by Honsberger if the kid is into plane geometry. It's an idyllic subject, great for independent exploration, and the books shouldn't take long to read. Not very deep, though (at least Honsberger).

Anything by Tom Körner, just because of the writing. Seriously, he can make the axiomatic construction of the real number system read like a novel; open https://web.archive.org/web/20190813160507/https://www.dpmms... on any page and you will see.

Proofs from the BOOK by Aigner and Ziegler is a cross-section of some of the nicest proofs in reasonably elementary (read: undergrad-comprehensible) maths. Might be a bit too advanced, though (the writing is terse and a lot of ground is covered).

Problems from the BOOK by Andreescu and Dospinescu (a play on the previous title, which itself is a play on an Erdös quote) is an olympiad problem book; it might be one of the best in its genre.

Oystein Ore has some nice introductory books on number theory (Number Theory and its History) and on graphs (Graphs and their uses); they should be cheap now due to their age, but haven't gotten any less readable.

Kvant Selecta by Serge Tabachnikov is a 3(?)-volume series of articles from the Kvant journal translated into English. These are short expositions of elementary mathematical topics written for talented (and experienced) high-schoolers.

I wouldn't do Princeton Companion; it's a panorama shot from high orbit, not a book you can really read and learn from.

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#109
Buy them 2 books as follows:

#1: your "The Princeton Companion.." or any of the great suggestions that you got here

AND THEN

#2: "Gödel, Escher, Bach: an Eternal Golden Braid" by Douglas Hofstadter. Best if you can get an old, old beat up paper copy at Amazon. Tell him that if he's lucky it will take him a lifetime to actually "get it". Tell him to keep the book in sight, bedroom, studio.. why not, bathroom. And to just read it not sequentially but at random. That is the best present to a mind thirsty for knowledge.

He might not appreciate it right not, he will appreciate it 30 years from today, if he's lucky.

Re: Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?

#110
>What would you have appreciated having been given at that age?

I remember getting God Created The Integers when I was a teenager and... not finishing it. I also got a copy of Brown & Churchill's Complex Variables and Applications and spent hundreds of hours on it. As a teenager, I preferred textbooks with problem sets to popularizations. (I still do.) Of course, this was [complex] analysis, so it doesn't qualify.

One book which is fully technical but also entertaining by way of the subject matter, and which was inspiring to me around 14-15, was Kenneth Falconer's Fractal Geometry:

https://www.amazon.com/Fractal-Geometry-Mathematical-Foundat...

Of course, at that age, I didn't understand what Falconer meant by describing the Cantor set as "uncountable", or what a "topological dimension" was, but I was able to grasp the gist of many of the arguments in the book because it is very well illustrated and does not rely too much on abstruse algebra techniques. Some people don't enjoy reading a book if they don't fully understand it, but I liked that kind of thing. As I got older and learned more, I started to be able to understand the technical arguments in the book as well.

Post reply on HN