Live data from Hacker News

Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

tuaw.com

21–30 of 83 posts

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#21
post #12

Only thing they didn't show was whether the hinge snaps on/off as easily as the Smart Cover.

the part around the 41 second mark where he flips open the cover concerns me a little, notice him placing his left hand on the hinge area for support. i wonder if maybe it comes off too easily.

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#22
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Someone have drunk too much Kool-Aid ... What's so uncool about AAPL is the closed platform, that killed so many innovations.

I do like apple products but really what innovation did they kill? Do you know how unthinkable an app store model was 5 years ago? Sure there are innovative things happening on android but would it even exist without iPhone?

>>I do like apple products but really what innovation did they kill?

All kind of products that would've competed with Apple bundled apps, or could've been seen as illegal in some state, or had some erotic content ...

>>Do you know how unthinkable an app store model was 5 years ago?

Microsoft had a store 5 years ago. What does it have to do with Apple closing their platforms, to make higher profits, while stopping a lot of innovation?

>>Sure there are innovative things happening on android but would it even exist without iPhone?

Symbian, Windows CE and many more existed before the iPhone. As the price of hardware falls and mobile devices become more powerful/useful more and more users are getting smartphones. Android would've made perfect sense, w/o iPhone.

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#24
post #2

Do watch the video. Great design!

This is getting ridiculous. Why do we up vote something that is a given? HN, stop it! You only up vote things that make you learn something. Why on earth did pohl just get 16 points for nothing. We need to stop with the promoting of things like "thank you" or "good job" Im sorry, I just went on a little rant. The cover is awesome, but did I just learn anything from pohl? I don't care to see this comment over more inf…

No, it's useful. It means that with N upvotes, N people agree with the comment.

That gives a great indicator as to whether or not the video is worth my time. The comment could have easily said that the video is a waste of time, which would also be helpful. People won't upvote it if they disagree.

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#25
post #2

Do watch the video. Great design!

This is getting ridiculous. Why do we up vote something that is a given? HN, stop it! You only up vote things that make you learn something. Why on earth did pohl just get 16 points for nothing. We need to stop with the promoting of things like "thank you" or "good job" Im sorry, I just went on a little rant. The cover is awesome, but did I just learn anything from pohl? I don't care to see this comment over more inf…

do you think you have any credibility to teach people here what to vote for? With 1.57 avg?

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#26
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is getting ridiculous. Why do we up vote something that is a given? HN, stop it! You only up vote things that make you learn something. Why on earth did pohl just get 16 points for nothing. We need to stop with the promoting of things like "thank you" or "good job" Im sorry, I just went on a little rant. The cover is awesome, but did I just learn anything from pohl? I don't care to see this comment over more inf…

No, it's useful . It means that with N upvotes, N people agree with the comment. That gives a great indicator as to whether or not the video is worth my time. The comment could have easily said that the video is a waste of time, which would also be helpful. People won't upvote it if they disagree.

An upvote doesn't necessarily mean that you agree with the comment. They are supposed to mean that the comment is worthwhile or adds something to the discussion. IMO, the ggp comment doesn't.

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#27
post #2

Do watch the video. Great design!

This is getting ridiculous. Why do we up vote something that is a given? HN, stop it! You only up vote things that make you learn something. Why on earth did pohl just get 16 points for nothing. We need to stop with the promoting of things like "thank you" or "good job" Im sorry, I just went on a little rant. The cover is awesome, but did I just learn anything from pohl? I don't care to see this comment over more inf…

I have to say, I agree. Just think about all those starving kids in Ethopia with no upvotes and here we are on HN sitting in our comfortable Aeron chairs just pissing our upvotes away.

Proof positive we are in the karma bubble here!!

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#28
post #4

What's cool about AAPL is that it inspires such innovative designs. Beautiful.

Someone have drunk too much Kool-Aid ... What's so uncool about AAPL is the closed platform, that killed so many innovations.

Ok I must admit I am by no means an AAPL fanboy. Quite the contrary actually. I hate how Jobs and company likes to get its users drunk with the Kool-Aid. But a credit should be given where it's due. Have you seen something as innovative and clever with a PC? Microsoft brought out first commercial tablet. Did that inspire anybody to do something similar?

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#29
post #3

If that's a solid sheet of microfiber on the inside, then I'm sold. The thing that irritates me most about the Smart Cover is that it leaves streaks on the glass where the indentations are.

can't be solid. if it was tight when rolled up it would be loose when flat.

Re: Wooden iPad 2 cover outsmarts Apple's Smart Cover

#30
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is getting ridiculous. Why do we up vote something that is a given? HN, stop it! You only up vote things that make you learn something. Why on earth did pohl just get 16 points for nothing. We need to stop with the promoting of things like "thank you" or "good job" Im sorry, I just went on a little rant. The cover is awesome, but did I just learn anything from pohl? I don't care to see this comment over more inf…

No, it's useful . It means that with N upvotes, N people agree with the comment. That gives a great indicator as to whether or not the video is worth my time. The comment could have easily said that the video is a waste of time, which would also be helpful. People won't upvote it if they disagree.

But shouldn't the votes on the link itself already be enough to decide that?
Post reply on HN