Live data from Hacker News

Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

dw.com

161–169 of 169 posts

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#161
post #98

A total of around $2B has simply "disappeared" -- as in, no one yet has been able to figure out what happened to it. I keep imagining a Monty Python-esque skit: "Was it stolen? We don't know." "Was it spent? We don't know." "Was it lent? We don't know." "Was it transferred? We don't know." "Was it burned? We don't know." Coincidentally, or maybe not, the company's last fictitious balance sheet, which was published in…

They never had the money in the first place.

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#162

I wonder how many companies in the world are basially built on warm words without any real value behind. I made the experience that a lot of people don't really care if a company has positive revenue streams anymore, they don't even know what a balance sheet is. They simply invest because other people do. And those other people invested because people before them did. This new style "invest billions now in a lossy st…

Auditors work on assumptions, they assume that the document presented to then are correct and not falsified. If they cannot see that the document is falsified and didn’t see any indications that might raise questions either, how can they be held liable?

OTOH, why does a German company keep 2 billion euros in a Philippine account, that’s strange.

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#163
post #153
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm wondering why the CEO called in KPMG for an independent audit. Was he expecting a different result? Or he just picked them to break the news?

At some point you start believing your own lies so he probably thought everything would be fine and the markets would be calmed with another auditor confirming the results.

This exactly. Allegations of fraud had also bubbled up several times in the past and he was able to take care of them. I would imagine he didn't expect this time to be any different.

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#164
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What other exchanges are they listed on? It is pretty uncommon for a company to ever list on more than one exchange.

Depends. Very common for non-US Shares (Germany, China, UK etc.)

Maybe we just disagree about what "common" and "uncommon" mean in this context.

What actual percentage of the 100,000+ public companies around the world trade on another exchange?

Most of the DAX 30 in Germany don't even trade on another exchange. Adidas doesn't. BMW doesn't. Siemens doesn't (they were delisted by the NYSE in 2014.) Does any of the DAX 30 trade on an exchange outside of Germany?

As far as I can tell, only 8 companies in Germany trade on another exchange but maybe my source is wrong.

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What other exchanges are they listed on? It is pretty uncommon for a company to ever list on more than one exchange.

Shell is dual listed and plenty of foreign companies have ADR's on the US exchanges

Almost no ADRs trade on US exchanges. There are over 100,000 public companies in the world and the NYSE has only 506 non-US issuers. I'd call that pretty uncommon.

I said it was pretty uncommon, not that people couldn't name individual, rare examples.

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#166

I wonder how many companies in the world are basially built on warm words without any real value behind. I made the experience that a lot of people don't really care if a company has positive revenue streams anymore, they don't even know what a balance sheet is. They simply invest because other people do. And those other people invested because people before them did. This new style "invest billions now in a lossy st…

If you audit basically the entire global economy every year and you're going up against people willing to forge & collude something is going to slip through each year. Sure you may catch 99% of the cases. But that one that does make it through has people asking stuff like:

>For how many companies EY did the same? How superficially do they check their customers?

Public perception of audits is basically a giant example of survivorship bias. All the stuff that auditor do catch generally gets fixed without it making the news. Cause you know confidentiality.

It's not a widget factory where six sigma is possible. It's a messy imperfect process, because well the global economy & most businesses are. 100% is about is plausible as demanding that all programmers globally write bug free code. It's just not happening.

That said...2 billion is like 1/3rd of the company assets. That's one hell of an oversight even in light of the above.

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#167
post #43

Invisibilia just released a great podcast about trust, based on the experience of a trader who was harassed by Wirecard. The trader, who was shorting Wirecard, was subject to surveillance, and a constant stream of phishing attacks. https://www.npr.org/2020/06/02/868001948/trust-fall

How would wirecard learn who is actually shorting them?

Because the trader was public that he was shorting and why, and filed complaints with the German regulators.

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#168
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How can you find out about who is auditing a company?

For public U.S. companies, the annual shareholders' report (available on the company's web site) usually includes a letter signed by the auditors certifying that the reported financial results are accurate.

Same in France

Re: Wirecard files for insolvency after financial hole laid bare

#169
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess instead of saying "a billion dollars" we should say "1 Gigadollar"

Mmm, I'd like to spend no more than half a kilorupeee on dinner.

I was surprised the first time I read about crore and lakh, they take some time to get used to.
Post reply on HN