Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Do you ever click through on HN?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 22 posts

Re: Poll: Do you ever click through on HN?

#11

I never visit the HN homepage. I drink from the firehose (RSS feed) and scan topics, digging in to interesting articles based on the title only. I wish there was a way to see the score for the articles from within the feed and have it update to within a 30 minute window.

One more drinking from the firehose here... just come to the "actual" site to read whatever comments the other readers left. I normally enjoy 49% the articles linked and 51% the opinion of the fellow readers here at HN!

Re: Poll: Do you ever click through on HN?

#12
post #10

I also am subscribed to the RSS feed, and scan based on topics. Unfortunately, some titles are just not very informative or well-written. I wish titles were more descriptive. What inspired this question?

To be honest, I posted this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2364399

It never made it to the Front page, but has been close to the top of the second front page, and even after falling off the "New" page it still garnered the occasional vote. That suggested that people either were clicking through, or had marked it as "Read Later" and then did so.

I wondered how many people saw it at all, and hence the question.

Re: Poll: Do you ever click through on HN?

#15
post #10

I also am subscribed to the RSS feed, and scan based on topics. Unfortunately, some titles are just not very informative or well-written. I wish titles were more descriptive. What inspired this question?

To be honest, I posted this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2364399 It never made it to the Front page, but has been close to the top of the second front page, and even after falling off the "New" page it still garnered the occasional vote. That suggested that people either were clicking through, or had marked it as "Read Later" and then did so. I wondered how many people saw it at all, and hence the question.

Ah, if that's the case, then it never appeared in my RSS feed. I'm not sure how the RSS feed is composed (i.e. which submissions show up in it), but perhaps it's more selective than I'd thought. (I was already getting a hundred links each day!)

Interesting post though: I think there was a similar discussion in Programming Pearls by Jon Bentley (Good book).

Re: Poll: Do you ever click through on HN?

#16
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be honest, I posted this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2364399 It never made it to the Front page, but has been close to the top of the second front page, and even after falling off the "New" page it still garnered the occasional vote. That suggested that people either were clicking through, or had marked it as "Read Later" and then did so. I wondered how many people saw it at all, and hence the question.

Ah, if that's the case, then it never appeared in my RSS feed. I'm not sure how the RSS feed is composed (i.e. which submissions show up in it), but perhaps it's more selective than I'd thought. (I was already getting a hundred links each day!) Interesting post though: I think there was a similar discussion in Programming Pearls by Jon Bentley (Good book).

  > Ah, if that's the case, then it never appeared
  > in my RSS feed
Interesting, isn't it, that there are things that don't appear in the RSS feed.

  > there was a similar discussion in
  > Programming Pearls by Jon Bentley
That's where it all started, as is mentioned at the very top of the submitted item.

Re: Poll: Do you ever click through on HN?

#17
RSS subscriber here. While we're on the topic, would it be possible to include the text for text stories in the RSS feed? Currently only the title is shown. I tend to not click on things that don't immediately appear relevant to me. The title is not always descriptive of the content.

Re: Poll: Do you ever click through on HN?

#18

I never visit the HN homepage. I drink from the firehose (RSS feed) and scan topics, digging in to interesting articles based on the title only. I wish there was a way to see the score for the articles from within the feed and have it update to within a 30 minute window.

One more drinking from the firehose here... just come to the "actual" site to read whatever comments the other readers left. I normally enjoy 49% the articles linked and 51% the opinion of the fellow readers here at HN!

I've got the iGoogle hacker news widget showing top 5 to 10 stories. I've also got multiple other google RSS reader widgets running, one for each topic I have an interest in.

http://i.imgur.com/p5h7K.png

My girlfriend showed me how she was doing it once and I thought it was really quite revolutionary. She's since moved on to using a bunch of iPad RSS reader apps, but I'm stuck in the iGoogle "stone age" I just love it.

All that said, I pretty frequently click through to load the hackernews page though.

Post reply on HN