Live data from Hacker News

macOS Big Sur Preview

apple.com

11–20 of 391 posts

Re: macOS Big Sur Preview

#12
post #2

I cannot see any difference besides the icons in the Dock looking like those of iPhone apps.

Except that the Dock icons are significantly more 3D in their appearance than iPadOS/iOS 14 are.

This is actually an interesting change of priority. Last time there was a major redesign, iOS got it first and Mac OS X got it later. This time, MacOS gets it first and iOS gets it next year in 2021.

Re: macOS Big Sur Preview

#15
IMHO Apple's design jumped the shark a long time ago. Even apart from the aesthetics of the "flat" look, which I like about as much as fingernails on a chalkboard, Apple has completely abandoned the principles that made the original Mac great: ease of use and discoverability. Once upon a time it was easy to tell where the affordances were, what you could click on, editable vs non-editable text. Nowadays everything looks the same. The only way to tell whether something is clickable is to try to click on it. The only way you can tell whether something is editable is to try to edit it. And the UI is lousy with hidden features that only show up when you hover over them, with absolutely no indication of where they are until you happen to get lucky and move the mouse over one of them. Easter eggs lose their charm when you have to find one in order to accomplish an actual task.

Re: macOS Big Sur Preview

#17
Scrolling this site with a mouse is comically bad, this is clearly designed to be used only with a trackpad. I cant read most of the content without very carefully scrolling unnaturally. You also have to pause for the animations to play, but if you scroll one pixel too far they don't play, so its a guessing game of whether you're in the right place or whether you missed some content.

Re: macOS Big Sur Preview

#18
I usually end up turning off the motion and turning on increased contrast, reduced transparency etc. These things demo nicely but I didn't like windows with transparency effects when Windows Vista did it and I feel the same way today. I care about what's in the window not under it.

I do think the Safari updates look great, though. Webkit may have its governance issues and so forth, but Safari is really a wonderful app to use imo.

Re: macOS Big Sur Preview

#19
post #3

I still remember the Snow Leopard 'No New Features' launch. Mac OS has been as buggy as ever lately, I'd welcome another 'no new features' release with open arms.

I was going to say something similar - I really wish they'd just slow.the.hell.down with the new releases, rather than continually changing things for what feels like the sake of it (and breaking more and more stuff along the way).

Re: macOS Big Sur Preview

#20
I just love the changes they did to the menubar. Adaptive background and extra padding on the menu items are both great changes

I don't like the new dock design. Maybe they'll change it back to the old dock if the feedback is vocal?

Post reply on HN