Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 79 posts

Re: Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for the great feedback. We started with text as it seems more integrated with daily life than in-app chat, but we'd love to expand out channels in the near future. Would love to hear what method you'd prefer instead so I can pass it along to the team!

I like emails and video calls. If I need to communicate in real-time, I prefer to just have a call and do it. If not in real-time, email feels the least invasive to me, and is my preference.

Isn't part of the idea here to _be invasive_ though? If part of the intent of the service is change behavior then the coach must interject themselves into the clients' lives in order to create action.

How would you see the minimal invasiveness of email aligning with such a call to action?

(hope this doesn't come across as an attack as it is not intended to. Just trying to understand how you see these two ideas as compatible since I see them as opposing and so wanting to know what angle I'm missing)

Re: Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50

#54
Hey this is awesome. One question, can the coach(es) cater to preexisting conditions/diets? My pops has Parkinson’s and is on a pretty tight diet that my mom has put him on for weight loss, so in order to try to get him to try it, Mighty Health would probably need to work within those confines to start. Would something like that be possible? If so, I’d love to gift a subscription to see how it helps him.

Cheers and congrats on the launch! v exciting stuff.

Re: Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50

#55
Congrats on the launch.

To clarify: Are you guys specifically focused on people over 50? The website makes no mention of the 50+ age focus. I just got a gift for my mom, but the only reason is for an exercise coach who can create a specific routine for someone who is 65 years old. We don't need the nutrition coaching.

Re: Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50

#56

Hey this is awesome. One question, can the coach(es) cater to preexisting conditions/diets? My pops has Parkinson’s and is on a pretty tight diet that my mom has put him on for weight loss, so in order to try to get him to try it, Mighty Health would probably need to work within those confines to start. Would something like that be possible? If so, I’d love to gift a subscription to see how it helps him. Cheers and c…

Yes, absolutely! At the start of the program, we ask about nutritional preferences / restrictions, and the coach can also hop on a call to clarify anything.

Re: Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50

#57

Congrats on the launch. To clarify: Are you guys specifically focused on people over 50? The website makes no mention of the 50+ age focus. I just got a gift for my mom, but the only reason is for an exercise coach who can create a specific routine for someone who is 65 years old. We don't need the nutrition coaching.

Yes, we only focus on people over 50! It's in the sub-headline of our site, but we could make it a lot more prominent / repeated throughout -- thanks for the feedback. All of the exercises in our app are specifically designed for that age range. Looking forward to hearing what your mom thinks of our program!

Re: Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like emails and video calls. If I need to communicate in real-time, I prefer to just have a call and do it. If not in real-time, email feels the least invasive to me, and is my preference.

Isn't part of the idea here to _be invasive_ though? If part of the intent of the service is change behavior then the coach must interject themselves into the clients' lives in order to create action. How would you see the minimal invasiveness of email aligning with such a call to action? (hope this doesn't come across as an attack as it is not intended to. Just trying to understand how you see these two ideas as com…

I see your point, but I believe your goal is to be visible, not invasive. You are trying to help people along a path that they want to be on, not force people on a path that doesn't feel right to them.

For me, texting is a path I won't walk. Email is a path I walk multiples time a day. Talk to me there, I'll see it, it will be injected into my life.

Re: Launch HN: Mighty Health (YC S19) – Health coaching for people over 50

#59
The need for your app is overwhelming. I am 65, female, very fit, and lost 40 pounds since 2014. Daily, I do some type of class, either strength, cardio, yoga, or walking. Here are my concerns with your app as a vehicle to long-term improvement.

1. The enemy of healthy living is social interaction that is nearly always alcohol and food indulgence. Either your user has to find new friends (like an alcoholic develops a cohort of non-drinking friends,) or they have to acquire the strength of purpose to abstain while still being social. Success here is very dependent on self-esteem....a distinctly non-technical aspect not directly addressed by the app.

2. Preparing your next meal BEFORE YOU ARE HUNGRY is critical to success. This could be addressed by subscribing to a pre-packaged frozen meal service, or, by consistently doing grocery shopping and meal prep in advance. The latter takes planning, discipline, and effort. Lack of planning is frequently the reason for eating excess or unhealthy food.

3. Eating to self-soothe is prevalent. Learning other sources of pleasure or gratification is crucial to sustained success. For example, I always want second helpings even though I know I have already had enough. This because my stomach needs an extra 15 minutes to tell my brain that I am satisfied. To cope, I set a 15 minute timer and for that 15 minutes, I walk away from the food area, sit in a comfy chair and do something pleasant with my phone, such as read fashion news or text with a friend. A sine qua non of healthy eating is having a list of other pleasant things to do when you feel the urge to eat when not hungry.

4. Many overweight people will only succeed in the transition to a healthy life if they have in person contact with others that support and acknowledge their struggle. Either a 12-step meeting or a FaceTime call with their coach is vital so that your user can visualize that person's face when the user is at the moment of decision to binge or not.

5. If you take away food and drink as the emotional coping tool, you have to replace it with something that is not self-destructive. Your users have to be ready when emotional crisis comes when, then more than ever, they will feel entitled to eat or drink anything within convenient reach. For this reason, I am unable to keep ready-to-eat foods in my house.....cereal, cheese, nut butters, dessert, snacks, bread of any kind. I do keep fresh apples and oranges, but that is it. Your user must develop other methods of dealing with crisis.....journaling, phone a friend, or just giving themselves permission to withdraw, lay down and rest if possible. Since I have momentum on my side, an activity that 100% occupies the mind, like a spin class, is my helper that enables me to muddle through. Meditation is another good tool.

I have come to believe that lack of self-care has much more to do with emotional self-regulation and self esteem than it does with lack of knowledge on sleep, exercise, and nutrition.

However, for those who suddenly get motivated by a health scare, the knowledge and guidance in your app is like a welcome breath of life.

Post reply on HN