Live data from Hacker News

Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

lwn.net

171–180 of 320 posts

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#171
Countly [1] is another open source alternative to Google Analytics - suggest you try it on Digital Ocean [2] or deploy on your own [3].

It is self hosted, has support for desktop apps, mobile apps and web apps at the same time.

[1] https://count.ly

[2] https://marketplace.digitalocean.com/apps/countly-analytics

[3] https://github.com/countly/countly-server

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#172

I still can't see any solid reasons why a site owner would not use GA. Other products: - Objectively lack features - Potentially incur extra costs in money/time - May be a small barrier in m&a - May carry additional risks/attack vectors if self hosted Trying to ween off big tech is commendable, but likely detrimental to a business. Relatively high risk, low reward. I'm happy to have my mind changed. I can see a case…

GDPR compliance. GDPR is the European privacy law. It protects European citizens so it applies not only to European companies but any company that does business in Europe (having offices or advertising/selling there). Google does not give much assurance regarding their GDPR compliance... their text on that subject is mostly CYA and then they make it your responsibility to decide how to use it in compliance (if at all…

>GDPR is the European privacy law. It protects European citizens

The GDPR does not discriminate based on citizenship.

It applies if the organisation providing the service is in the EU/EEA* OR if the user of the service is in the EU/EEA* (to the extent that the data reference their activity in the EU/EEA).

And the UK, but thanks to brexit there's a parallel UK GDPR in place so... take that in to account.

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#173
post #139

In my blog I started using Netlify's analytics which are server based and cost $9 per month (up to a number of views) and I gotta say they are extremely basic and lackluster. I paid for the subscription for one month but I don't think I will keep on paying. Edit: Also it doesn't seem to be tracking referrers correctly.

Yes, Netlify Analytics are bad. Try Fathom.

I'm sure it's a better service but at $14 per month (or $140 per year) for a low traffic blog it's too expensive. I don't need anything that fancy.

I moved to Netlify analytics from Goat counter because I liked the idea of having server side analytics, but at $9 per month these are extremely overpriced.

I think I will just go back to Goat counter.

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Server side Analytics are far from reliable. Go and try Netlify, then you’ll see how unreliable they really are. For us nerds, we can always block things using DNS level blocking but Fathom’s custom domain feature has done really well for the majority: https://usefathom.com/blog/custom-domains-embed-code

Good adblockers do DNS lookup to see if subdomain points to tracking server anyway. Only completely self-hosted (your domain, your tracking server) solutions are resilient to adblocking

Interesting, then as a workaround trackers may create an image with pseudo-random src pointing to pageXXXwebsiteYYYclientZZZ.ad.yoursite.com (yoursite.com is the site which serves the actual content), while asking the owner to point NS record for ad.yoursite.com to IP of their DNS server. So HTTP/S request or DNS request can reach them anyway. Obviously DNS caching will prevent them from knowing how many times this particular page was accessed by this particular client, but at least they will know that it was accessed at least once.

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#175

I'd like to ditch google analytics for a new small side project I'm building. I live in a small country in Europe and for me the most important feature of these alternatives is the cookieless tracking and the lightweight scripts. However, the pricing is too steep for a project that won't gain more than thousands users. Fathom analytics and simple analytics cost ~100$/year. Plausible costs ~50$ I really liked and almo…

Fathom and Plausible are both open source:

https://github.com/usefathom/fathom https://github.com/plausible/analytics

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#176
post #101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find time spent on page is a great way to measure performance of redesigns on page. There are numerous actionable points.

Unless your page is google.com, where more time spent on page means the experience is worse, not better.

Counter example: I search for information on a subject. I get many interesting and relevant results and therefore spend more time on the page.

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#177

Countly [1] is another open source alternative to Google Analytics - suggest you try it on Digital Ocean [2] or deploy on your own [3]. It is self hosted, has support for desktop apps, mobile apps and web apps at the same time. [1] https://count.ly [2] https://marketplace.digitalocean.com/apps/countly-analytics [3] https://github.com/countly/countly-server

Some of my friends switched from GA to Countly. They are very satisfied, and I am thinking of using it in my next project.

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#179
I often read posts stating a great deal of discouragement for self developed analytic solutions. I've recently developed a home rolled solution for a product I'll hopefully launch soon.

There's no UI for my signals application, but it should give me raw access to all the GA metrics people typically look for (pages, referrers, user agents, etc). Storage could be pain point. Compute might also turn out to be, but if that ever becomes a problem, then I'll probably have much more to think about...

What am I missing here?

Re: Lightweight Alternatives to Google Analytics

#180

I have my own self-hosted Matomo instance [1]. Via Docker & docker-compose it's quite easy to install and keep up to date and Matomo is open source, well maintained, very well behaved and pretty hands off. And I configured it on my websites with cookies turned off [2] and with IP anonymization [3]. In such an instance you don't need consent, or even a cookie banner, because you're not dropping cookies, or collecting…

How do you actually host this? Do I need a VPS or is more of like a Heroki thing?
Post reply on HN