Live data from Hacker News

California bans private prisons and immigration detention centers (2019)

reuters.com

1–10 of 130 posts

Re: California bans private prisons and immigration detention centers (2019)

#5
post #2

I can understand private prisons (which make up a small percentage of overall prisons). However, what will be the solution for people that come into the US illegally, if not temporary detainment?

From reading the article, which is slightly unclear, I think they mean that the federal immigration detention centers in California that are privately run - probably by someone like G4S https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G4S_Secure_Solutions

Re: California bans private prisons and immigration detention centers (2019)

#6
post #2

I can understand private prisons (which make up a small percentage of overall prisons). However, what will be the solution for people that come into the US illegally, if not temporary detainment?

They're not banning detention centers, they're banning private detention centers. I was confused at first too.

Re: California bans private prisons and immigration detention centers (2019)

#8
post #2

I can understand private prisons (which make up a small percentage of overall prisons). However, what will be the solution for people that come into the US illegally, if not temporary detainment?

From the article: "California moved to end the use of private, for-profit lockups in America’s largest state prison system as well as in federal immigration detention centers in the state"

If you wanted a super-duper clear title then an alternate title for the entry here on HackerNews could be "California bans private prisons and _private_ immigration detention centers"

Re: California bans private prisons and immigration detention centers (2019)

#9
post #2

I can understand private prisons (which make up a small percentage of overall prisons). However, what will be the solution for people that come into the US illegally, if not temporary detainment?

Releasing people on bond or electronic monitoring?

Re: California bans private prisons and immigration detention centers (2019)

#10
post #4
post #2

I can understand private prisons (which make up a small percentage of overall prisons). However, what will be the solution for people that come into the US illegally, if not temporary detainment?

hospitality

If we're going to have free movement it should probably be via a proper agreement, like in the EU. Not a mishmash of contradictory state and federal policies. And it should be mutual - if Mexicans and Canadians can live in the US, Americans should be freely allowed to live in Mexico and Canada.
Post reply on HN