Live data from Hacker News

Reddit Welcomes Michael Seibel to Board of Directors

redditblog.com

21–30 of 393 posts

Re: Reddit Welcomes Michael Seibel to Board of Directors

#21
post #4

Please don't make Hacker News more like Reddit. Please don't make Hacker News more like Reddit. Please don't make Hacker News more like Reddit.

Wouldn't the threat of change be going in the opposite direction?

That being said please make Reddit more like HN. I deleted my Reddit account years ago. In the cases where it wasn’t a doomed echo chamber vortex it was stupid framework trend of the moment, which isn’t interesting when your primary concerns are technology and programming.

Re: Reddit Welcomes Michael Seibel to Board of Directors

#24
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wouldn't the threat of change be going in the opposite direction?

That being said please make Reddit more like HN. I deleted my Reddit account years ago. In the cases where it wasn’t a doomed echo chamber vortex it was stupid framework trend of the moment, which isn’t interesting when your primary concerns are technology and programming.

[deleted]

Re: Reddit Welcomes Michael Seibel to Board of Directors

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, that would only make Reddit better, but Redit is much much bigger. The bigger risk is that Alexis sees what Reddit is doing (maybe gets a peak at their balance sheet) and thinks that what we have here is the next big social media unicorn he can overhaul and then flog off to the highest bidder.

What?? I enjoy reading Hacker News and commenting, but Reddit is a lot more open and puts a higher value on free speech and contrarian ideologies (some of it is borderline horrible, but that's OK, that's the price of free speech). I'd be more worried about him bringing HN policies to Reddit. Trying to get superficially good behavior from users by punishing contrarian views isn't going to work in this case. But it wor…

> Reddit is a lot more open and puts a higher value on free speech

I disagree in the strongest possible terms. So much of Reddit is a populist echo chamber, which is the opposite of free speech.

Re: Reddit Welcomes Michael Seibel to Board of Directors

#26
post #13

I am sorry for him. I know as a fact that he’s brilliant and fully deserves the position, but given the circumstances (Ohanian resigning and calling for someone black to replace him) he will always have to live with people having the reasonable doubt that he didn’t arrive there for merit alone.

Anyone that remotely thinks that is an idiot. Michael is a fucking force of nature and one of the most impressive people you will ever meet. Seriously, if that thought ever comes up in your presence attack it head on because the person expressing it needs a big fucking gut check.

Honestly, even you saying this is BS.

Re: Reddit Welcomes Michael Seibel to Board of Directors

#27

I really hope this doesn't mean Hacker News will start getting inspiration from Reddit, or that Alexis Ohanian doesn't get dillusions of grandeur and wants to turn this into what Reddit is (a profiteering social media company fuelled by ads and astroturfing). We really don't want that. What we have here is something quite special, and as far as I can see, unique on modern internet. It is a tiny slice of what the "old…

I mean, HN isn’t really relevant as an asset to ycombinator besides a advertising asset, right? It has a couple million monthly users, maybe 1 new feature a year, and runs on a single core. It’s more of a demonstration of Arc than anything, right?

My understanding is that the main benefit is that YC firms are able to make “...is hiring” posts and have them appear on the front page, but I could be wrong.

Re: Reddit Welcomes Michael Seibel to Board of Directors

#30

A dumb but serious question: what powers does a board of directors have? In terms of day to day operations, engineering, product, marketing and so on?

It depends on how the board is set up, but generally they don't deal with day-to-day things. They're mainly concerned with the big picture of how the company is doing, and directly deal with things like hiring/firing/compensating executives, M&A, etc.
Post reply on HN