Live data from Hacker News

Zuckerberg: I just shared the following note with our employees

facebook.com

11–20 of 174 posts

Re: Zuckerberg: I just shared the following note with our employees

#11
As someone who doesn't use facebook at all, this reads as so hilarious. Zuck knows, in this "difficult moment", his internal employee memo would leak, so he makes it public outside the walled garden.

Hey Mark, let us know when you have something concrete to say to us peons.

Re: Zuckerberg: I just shared the following note with our employees

#13
post #8

Nothing is really being announced. He said they will discuss a few things but what will come out of these discussions is not guaranteed. Great way to say you're doing something without doing anything.

The most-used verb in the numbered list is 'review'. I hope some action comes of this, but, I dunno, it's Facebook.

I think you have your answer.

Re: Zuckerberg: I just shared the following note with our employees

#15
almost every paragraph in that post starts with "we will" or "we have". I'm sure Mark actually meant to say "I will" given that he more or less has unilateral control over the entire community of 2.5 billion people. The world's largest autocracy if you will.

Wild propopsal, if the community and in this case the voices of African-American members matter so much, why not give up some of that decision making power

Re: Zuckerberg: I just shared the following note with our employees

#17
He is clearly viewing this as another technical problem to solve. He's a highly technical person; this follows.

But the issues he's being confronted with aren't technical issues of permissions and algorithm tuning; they're societal problems of power dynamics and information manipulation. These are human traits. They aren't problems that are "solved." They're issues that you have to take a stance on. Do you believe in letting people lie on your platform? What about advertisers? What if the advertiser is a political party?

Further, this feels like it's worth precisely nothing, given what he says right up top:

>I want to be clear that while we are looking at all of these areas, we may not come up with changes we want to make in all of them.

Zuck has shown himself unwilling to accept the responsibility of controlling his platform. He is failing every user and employee of Facebook.

Re: Zuckerberg: I just shared the following note with our employees

#18

You can unilaterally make critical decisions that favor conservative supporters, but to make common sense decisions that protect democracy you need to set up review boards? If you still participate in this pestilential quagmire of a social network, delete your account today.

As a non-user of Facebook (and a non-American), I'm curious to hear what kind of critical decisions favored conservative supporters? It seems like giving any voice to conservatives is considered a PR suicide right now. I'd be surprised if FB did that.

(whether this is only within the tech world or a broader point of view in America will soon be discovered come elections time)

Re: Zuckerberg: I just shared the following note with our employees

#20
This reddit comment was addressed to the CEO of reddit, but it feels just as pertinent for Facebook and mark Zuckerberg.

https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/gw5dj5/remember_th...

There's nothing in this announcement, it's toothless. "We'll think about it! We'll try to come up with something!"

The man is useless.

------

This other, short comment from the same thread encapsulates it well, too: https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/gw5dj5/-/fstgtta

Post reply on HN