Live data from Hacker News

Oumuamua may be a hydrogen iceberg

news.yale.edu

1–10 of 96 posts

Re: Oumuamua may be a hydrogen iceberg

#5

Is there an element or compound in the universe that will remain a gas at 0K? Does everything become solid at that temp?

Intuitively I would think so since 0K is a motionless state. By definition everything would be solid because nothing would be capable of e.g. filling a given volume, or for that matter, doing any action at all.

But this isn't my field of expertise.

Re: Oumuamua may be a hydrogen iceberg

#7
post #2

Makes me wonder if you could slingshot around the sun towards relativistic speeds with thermal power. At the very least it could save fuel on the egress, if not the second half. Can you aerobrake around a star?

> Can you aerobrake around a star?

Not a physicist, but it seems like you should be able to do something similar to aerobraking (not one-to-one since the Sun's "atmosphere" is different from a planet's). Maybe using a solar sail of some sort directed at the right angle?

Re: Oumuamua may be a hydrogen iceberg

#8
post #7
post #2

Makes me wonder if you could slingshot around the sun towards relativistic speeds with thermal power. At the very least it could save fuel on the egress, if not the second half. Can you aerobrake around a star?

> Can you aerobrake around a star? Not a physicist, but it seems like you should be able to do something similar to aerobraking (not one-to-one since the Sun's "atmosphere" is different from a planet's). Maybe using a solar sail of some sort directed at the right angle?

I went on a wiki-binge on this topic a few days ago and so I recognize this as a magsail[0]. It would be an attractive addition to an interstellar craft since it obviates the need to carry propellant for deceleration.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_sail

Re: Oumuamua may be a hydrogen iceberg

#9
post #8
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Can you aerobrake around a star? Not a physicist, but it seems like you should be able to do something similar to aerobraking (not one-to-one since the Sun's "atmosphere" is different from a planet's). Maybe using a solar sail of some sort directed at the right angle?

I went on a wiki-binge on this topic a few days ago and so I recognize this as a magsail[0]. It would be an attractive addition to an interstellar craft since it obviates the need to carry propellant for deceleration. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_sail

That's really cool. Definitely helpful in order to drop deceleration fuel requirements if we ever manage to put together a relativistic interstellar spacecraft.

Re: Oumuamua may be a hydrogen iceberg

#10
post #5

Is there an element or compound in the universe that will remain a gas at 0K? Does everything become solid at that temp?

Intuitively I would think so since 0K is a motionless state. By definition everything would be solid because nothing would be capable of e.g. filling a given volume, or for that matter, doing any action at all. But this isn't my field of expertise.

Complete lack of motion would violate Heisenberg uncertainty principle ("no motion" == "I know both momentum and location with zero uncertainty" and that's not allowed)
Post reply on HN