Live data from Hacker News

People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

buzzfeednews.com

141–150 of 258 posts

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you paying with cash? Is this for a delivery or pick up? I am confused as to how they are getting the money from you.

Pick up. Probably less than 5% of restaurants do delivery. If you count chains as one restaurant, then probably less than 1% of restaurants do delivery. I, um, take it you don't do this often :-)

I order food 2-3 nights a week, mostly using Grubhub and DoorDash. I occasionally order from some restaurants that aren't on those platforms, too.

They all do delivery, and I pay online.

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#142

Every article I read about restaurants just seems to reinforce that they are powered by their owners hopes and dreams rather than any financial or business literacy. It makes then ripe targets for exploitation.

Restaurants and mom and pop grocery stores/convenience stores are very low margin, super long hours, and stressful. Furthermore, it isn’t just places like Grubhub but also local governments with weird zoning laws and expectations that really exploit these businesses with random fees. (My parents had a grocery store. They lost it during the previous recession.)

> Restaurants and mom and pop grocery stores/convenience stores are very low margin, super long hours, and stressful.

Sorry to hijack off of your comment - none of what I say is meant as a negative about you or your parents.

I've seen two types of people start these:

1. People from low income backgrounds who don't have many other options and don't have the means to gain good knowledge. I sympathize with them.

2. People who are somewhat wealthier (have a good degree, work for an engineering company, etc) who complain about how poorly people are running restaurants and how poor the food is and know for certain that they can run a restaurant that makes the food really well and everyone will come to their restaurant and business will be good. Very common for this to be about ethnic restaurants but doesn't need to be.

I have little sympathy for this group. They really should know better. I've talked to them about it before they put a huge chunk of their savings into starting a restaurant. They typically do no background research. They don't ask other business owners. They have no idea about the margins (hint - the other restaurants who make food poorly do it for an economic reason - not because they can't find good chefs).

Recently one of them opened a restaurant near my home. And their food was great - I would put it in the top 2 of their category in the city. But their prices were too high. Normally I order this type of food once in a while when I don't want to cook or am busy. But the price was beyond that threshold. I went there only when special friends visited me in town and took them there.

And not many people went there. The reviews everywhere (Yelp, etc) were awesome. But people didn't go there. Partly because of prices, but partly because of the location. Why did they pick that location? Because there's a big company in the neighborhood. Surely there are plenty of well paid people there who would come for lunch? Yes there are and no they won't. Over the years living there I know this plaza well. It's a graveyard for restaurants - most of them likely relying on employees of that company eating there. All these guys had to do was spend time in the restaurants in that plaza prior to signing the lease to get an idea. "Ah, but they don't go to those restaurants because their food is crap!" Yes, the food is crap. No, that's not the reason.

And then there's the food. Great food they made. But they weren't making a profit. So did they revise their menu to focus on items that would give good margins? No. They raised the prices. Fewer people came. They raised the prices again. Even fewer people came. This spiraled out of control. Within a year they had shut down. One of the co-owners told me there wasn't a month where they made a profit. I asked "Did you talk to any restaurant owners for their advice prior to opening?" Nope. If the food is great, people will come.

These guys work (or worked) pretty good jobs prior to opening the business - sometimes in senior management roles. Is that how decisions were made at their companies?

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#144

Every article I read about restaurants just seems to reinforce that they are powered by their owners hopes and dreams rather than any financial or business literacy. It makes then ripe targets for exploitation.

No its the landowners who can hold them over the barrel for their highest overhead: rent. And those same landowners are able to do that because they have enough wealth to wait on the next person who will initially pay the high rent.

> No its the landowners who can hold them over the barrel for their highest overhead: rent. And those same landowners are able to do that because they have enough wealth to wait on the next person who will initially pay the high rent.

Yes and no. There are landowners with a lot of wealth. The majority of landowners have less wealth (and will always have less wealth) than a typical FAANG engineer.

I started looking heavily into real estate last year and got to meet many of these people. The average commercial plaza in most cities? Not owned by a wealthy person - and indeed some of the business owners on the plaza are wealthier. A lot of these owners don't make enough out of it to make a living and still have a full time job.

They do it because it's passive income - almost no effort. Plaza owners typically don't pay for any maintenance. They don't pay property taxes. All this is passed on to the businesses in exchange for relatively low rents. As long as he collects enough rent to pay the loan, and has some extra left over, he's happy. It's free money.

(And 90-99% of land owners don't own the property free and clear. The majority of them owe more than half the value to some bank or other. That should tell you who really is making the money).

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a fair distinction to point out. Edit: Removed an interpretation of the situation that was inaccurate

They can't both lack permission and charge a single business. If they're charging, they have permission (though possibly the contract was misleading). If they don't have permission, they have no ability to charge.

They may not be able to charge the restaurant directly, but they can and do increase the menu price when they don't have an agreement.

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> To be fair, I have been surprised many times how difficult it can be to find an online menu for places I like in my area. Lots of places might not even have a website, but in these cases, I actually use GrubHub and the like to read the menus only. Don't. Do. This. Grubhub menus are often incomplete (and we all know the prices are wrong). I just checked a nearby restaurant I often frequent and the items I usually bu…

Just FYI, the menu photos on Yelp are not guaranteed to be up to date, either. The only real way to see what the restaurant's actual menu is without going there is if they have it up on their own website.

> Just FYI, the menu photos on Yelp are not guaranteed to be up to date, either

That's true, but rare. If there are no recent photos of the menu, then there's a good chance not many people eat there.

In any case, Grubhub menus are probably more likely to be inaccurate than those photos.

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is an established long-standing tactic at Hotels.com as well-- you call what you think is the hotel based on a web search. The person on the line pretends to work for the hotel. They will even play along and say "oh no discounts are available this week" or "no I dont see any AAA discounts / corporate discounts" The entire time -- they are trying to book you full price. The hotel loses, because they cannot give y…

> The entire time -- they are trying to book you full price. The hotel loses, because they cannot give you discounts -- they either get the sale or lose it alltogether. How is that not considered fraud? You're falsifying your identity as an employee for services you cannot provide in order to collect a fee as a middle man. But now that you mention it, during this absurd time I actually called the number of a Thai res…

I only realized this late, but they were careful never to say they worked for the hotel. I called again, almost like I had understood the end of a movie, and replayed the conversation with a new call.

Me: "Hi I'm trying to reach Marriott at Fisherman's Wharf, do I have the right number"

Them: "I can help you with that" (note the evasive answer)

Me: "Great, I have an Accenture corporate discount and this is for work, can you use corporate code XYZ123"

Them: "I dont see that on my system" (not a lie I suppose, but definitely not the truth)

Me: "OK well i have a client engagement Tues-Thurs and I need to book ASAP, what is your best rate? Do you have a AAA rate?"

Them: "You're lucky I can lock you in at {absurdly high price} - can i have your credit card"

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pick up. Probably less than 5% of restaurants do delivery. If you count chains as one restaurant, then probably less than 1% of restaurants do delivery. I, um, take it you don't do this often :-)

I order food 2-3 nights a week, mostly using Grubhub and DoorDash. I occasionally order from some restaurants that aren't on those platforms, too. They all do delivery, and I pay online.

Most Grubhub and Doordash restaurants don't do delivery.

When I say "they don't do delivery", I mean the restaurant doesn't do delivery. DD or GH provide the service to you. But if you call the restaurant directly, they'll tell you they don't do it on their own.

Which was the context of this conversation ("Why don't people directly call the restaurants instead of using GH?").

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#149
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The due diligence is because the restaurants offer a terrible experience. Most still do not have an independent online ordering function. They want me to call. Most still haven't set up meaningful profiles on Yelp and other review sites. So I would need to root around to find contact information. That is in addition to needing to give my credit card over the phone, not knowing how long the order will take, and needin…

They also make no attempts to keep their operating hours on Google Maps or Yelp up-to-date. Especially for holidays. Is keeping this stuff up to date actually difficult. I don't run a business, so I have no idea.

> Is keeping this stuff up to date actually difficult.

They usually have a zillion things to do, and this has a very low ROI. The impact to their bottom line is negligible whether they update or not. Not many people will refuse to use their business because they can't bother to update Google/Yelp/etc.

They usually do it if there's a permanent change in hours, though.

Re: People think they're calling restaurants directly but Grubhub is getting a fee

#150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I beg to differ. None of the places I've placed orders with (and I've been doing it a lot what with quarantine) have ever asked for CC over-the-phone. Most just want my name, some a phone number. Ordering usually takes less time than it would to fiddle about with a bunch of dropdowns, even if it had my customer information already saved.

Are you paying with cash? Is this for a delivery or pick up? I am confused as to how they are getting the money from you.

Credit card, I pay when I pick the food up?
Post reply on HN