Live data from Hacker News

Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

wsj.com

141–150 of 191 posts

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#141
post #110

I had Covid-19 (confirmed antibodies test, wife had confirmed PCR) in early March. Lost my sense of smell and taste _completely_, almost immediately. I've lost some smell before with bad allergies or a congested nose. This was otherworldly: no smell, at all. Not solvents. Not strong fragrances. Nothing. And this, with a perfectly clear nose. It freaked me out. It lasted for about 2.5 weeks. Around week 3, it started…

Same here. Recovered approx 6 weeks ago and coffee only just tastes reasonable again. My eating habits have changed in the recovery time. Probably for the better!

How bad was the typical symptoms (fever etc) compared to the smell issue?

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#142

I had Covid-19 (confirmed antibodies test, wife had confirmed PCR) in early March. Lost my sense of smell and taste _completely_, almost immediately. I've lost some smell before with bad allergies or a congested nose. This was otherworldly: no smell, at all. Not solvents. Not strong fragrances. Nothing. And this, with a perfectly clear nose. It freaked me out. It lasted for about 2.5 weeks. Around week 3, it started…

Suspected case here with similar symptoms a few months ago. Eating felt so weird . It's really just sad and bizarre, like your brain is almost reflexively telling you you're eating something inedible because you're not getting the taste and smell feedback of "this is food". I was so relieved when both senses started gradually coming back.

Might be really good for weight loss.

Would be real sad when I drink some paint thinner and eat a stale load of bread though.

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#143

I lost my sense of taste a few years ago, from a combination of extreme stress and the flu. Lasted about a week, and it was utterly terrifying. I first noticed it when I tried to eat, iirc scrambled eggs, and couldn't stop gagging on the texture. Once I figured out what was going on, it took a couple days to figure out what I could eat without retching. I ended up being entirely vegetarian - meat without taste is a h…

I lost my sense of taste a couple of years ago too - after eating a load of pine nuts!

It was the strangest thing - everything tasted of nothing. Thankfully it had fully come back within 48 hours.

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#144
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is the same middle ground that exists for every other cold and flu, every single year. Anosmia is a common side effect of a variety of illnesses, and in the vast majority of cases, it resolves on its own. But this fact doesn’t make good headlines.

Indeed, but there is no shortage of evidence that this disease is more damaging than the flu. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-12/covid-19-... > “These data demonstrated that the recovered SARS patients had a poor quality of life 12 years following recovery, and were susceptible to inflammation, tumors, and glucose and lipid metabolic disorders,” researchers wrote.

I wasn’t making a broad comparison to the flu. But if I were, I’d cite the most recent CDC numbers, which put the overall fatality rates somewhere around 3-4x worse than the flu, in the expected case:

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena...

Yes, this virus is worse than the flu. But not nearly to the extent being portrayed by the OP. All illnesses have long-term sequelae.

(Also, since you’re right that we have ample data on this virus, it seems an odd choice to cite data for SARS, when discussing Covid-19.)

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#145
post #3

So much emphasis is placed on the fatality rate, but there’s a lot of middle ground between asymptomatic and dead.

”So much emphasis is placed on the fatality rate, but there’s a lot of middle ground between asymptomatic and dead.“

...and this is the same middle ground that exists for every other cold and flu, every single year.

Anosmia is a common side effect of a variety of illnesses, and in the vast majority of cases, it resolves on its own. But this fact doesn’t make good headlines

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I lost most of my sense of smell a few years ago. I've lost much of my ability to differentiate tastes as well. As a former supertaster, lover of bourbon (I used to be able to tell my bourbons apart by smell), serious cook, and total foodie this has been the most depressing experience in my life. Think about the experience that you have when you walk from one room to another, or into a field of flowers. I can't smell…

> Smell is memory. Yes, definitely! It also tends to jog other memories from long ago, things that you had otherwise forgotten can suddenly be brought forward by the right smell.

Yes! there are a few very specific smells that reliably trigger very vivid memories (well, sensations mostly) from my early childhood.

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#147
post #72
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This. I had it. Literally every symptom except loss of taste and smell (but had some other rarer symptoms like the pink eye thing). Also had a cough for like a month, and loss of energy and breath for about a month and a half. Only just recently feel 100%. While it was shitty and lingered a while the worst of it wasn't actually that much worse than a flu for me. Somewhere between the flu and bronchitis on the scale o…

I had the worst cold I've experienced in a decade or more. Absolute loss of energy. Terrible aches; temperature all over the place. This was followed by two months of bronchitis that is still ongoing and failed to respond to two different kinds of antibiotics (the implication being that it's not bacterial). I never got tested because testing was not easy to get in early March; serologies aren't being done yet where I…

I had it (confirmed by a high-quality test), and never had a symptom beyond a mild cough.

Somewhere between 20-50% of infections are believed to be completely asymptomatic:

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena...

(my anecdote isn’t as valid as a severity-biased anecdote?)

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#148
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Indeed, but there is no shortage of evidence that this disease is more damaging than the flu. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-12/covid-19-... > “These data demonstrated that the recovered SARS patients had a poor quality of life 12 years following recovery, and were susceptible to inflammation, tumors, and glucose and lipid metabolic disorders,” researchers wrote.

I wasn’t making a broad comparison to the flu. But if I were, I’d cite the most recent CDC numbers, which put the overall fatality rates somewhere around 3-4x worse than the flu, in the expected case: https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena... Yes, this virus is worse than the flu. But not nearly to the extent being portrayed by the OP. All illnesses have long-term sequelae. (Also, since you’re r…

Where are you getting the numbers for flu? As far as I'm aware the best guess for flu IFR is 0.04% compared to COVID-19s 0.4% IFR

Note that CDC data on the flu is not on the IFR, they only have an estimate for the symptomatic fatality rate which doesn't include asymptomatic flu cases, while their COVID-19 IFR is including asymptomatic cases too.

(This seems to be because really caring about the true IFR of a virus is a recent development spurred on by this pandemic)

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#149

I had Covid-19 (confirmed antibodies test, wife had confirmed PCR) in early March. Lost my sense of smell and taste _completely_, almost immediately. I've lost some smell before with bad allergies or a congested nose. This was otherworldly: no smell, at all. Not solvents. Not strong fragrances. Nothing. And this, with a perfectly clear nose. It freaked me out. It lasted for about 2.5 weeks. Around week 3, it started…

Zinc deficiency also results in loss of smell. I heard the theory that your immune system consumes your Zinc reserves to fight the Virus.

Re: Some coronavirus patients haven't gotten their senses of smell or taste back yet

#150

Interestingly, not exactly COVID-19 related, people that lose their sense of taste return to eating normally, but people that lose a sense of feel in their mouth never seem to fully recover their appetite. I mean, not to say I want to lose my sense of taste, just that losing feel in your mouth seems probably worse.

I lost half of my tongue senses on a wisdom tooth extraction, it came back slowly during 3 month (its almost 100% back now) but it was terrifying the first week, I just kept thinking If I could live with that, a feeling of depression hit hard
Post reply on HN