Live data from Hacker News

Google Is Not God of the Web

bilge.world

21–30 of 306 posts

Re: Google Is Not God of the Web

#21
post #14

Google Search is in a horrendous state right now. Search results have been getting worse each year, with interesting information being buried 20 pages down. I really hope they have plans to improve this or find an approach that works as a middle ground for generic SEO content.

I would agree search seems to have gotten worse.

I wonder how much of the search abuse / manipulation they are dealing with given the current situations and upcoming elections?

Re: Google Is Not God of the Web

#23
post #8
post #3

Google has largely made the internet a safer and more efficient system by pushing standards through their market dominance. Is this a bad thing?

What did Google ever do for us?

The same type of question would be what have the Romans ever done for us in Europe and abroad except building all roads, aqueducts and Roman law legal system.

Here you have Monty Python asking that https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7tvauOJMHo

Re: Google Is Not God of the Web

#24
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What did Google ever do for us?

mhh___ types this while using chrome (open source) on android (open source), after reading their email in gmail and searching for the latest cat dancing videos on youtube. The sad reality most of the folks who claim never to use google or google never makes something available - almost always hot air. I do remember hotmail and MSN and AOL which preceded gmail, gmail was really pretty great when it came out. I think m…

You’re only considering the (debatable) positives (chrome sucks ass, folks). If you can’t engage in a good faith discussion why bother posting?

Re: Google Is Not God of the Web

#26
post #14

Google Search is in a horrendous state right now. Search results have been getting worse each year, with interesting information being buried 20 pages down. I really hope they have plans to improve this or find an approach that works as a middle ground for generic SEO content.

I would agree search seems to have gotten worse. I wonder how much of the search abuse / manipulation they are dealing with given the current situations and upcoming elections?

[deleted]

Re: Google Is Not God of the Web

#27
God, how? Like, in the monotheistic sense or the polytheistic sense? If we're going poly, then Google is definitely one of the Gods of the web. Maybe even the top God, but there may be some competition there.

Re: Google Is Not God of the Web

#28

It's funny that Google is so large, that one way to grow their business is to improve the user experience of the internet as a whole.

If this were true chrome would ship with ad block and they would accept cold hard cash for their services.

I tried this, I used it, no big adoption, product got killed.

Largely people prefer the free perception of the internet and wouldn't pay the prices it would cost if direct payments were made.

I believe its in the $x00s per year

Re: Google Is Not God of the Web

#29
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What did Google ever do for us?

mhh___ types this while using chrome (open source) on android (open source), after reading their email in gmail and searching for the latest cat dancing videos on youtube. The sad reality most of the folks who claim never to use google or google never makes something available - almost always hot air. I do remember hotmail and MSN and AOL which preceded gmail, gmail was really pretty great when it came out. I think m…

Chrome isn't open source, and a large part of android isn't either (google play services). Gmail is quickly becoming a walled garden itself (anyone who runs their own email service can tell you that). And YouTube is a hot mess.

Re: Google Is Not God of the Web

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

mhh___ types this while using chrome (open source) on android (open source), after reading their email in gmail and searching for the latest cat dancing videos on youtube. The sad reality most of the folks who claim never to use google or google never makes something available - almost always hot air. I do remember hotmail and MSN and AOL which preceded gmail, gmail was really pretty great when it came out. I think m…

You’re only considering the (debatable) positives (chrome sucks ass, folks). If you can’t engage in a good faith discussion why bother posting?

You must not remember the web before google and google funded firefox!! This whole "google has never done anything" meme just seems ridiculous on its face.

Google took on and basically CRUSHED some major market players and powers (Microsoft basically lost the entire web and handset markets from a monopoly position) as a result of google service offerings.

Check out how much money they pumped into firefox as well - that used to be a major part of their push vis a vis IE.

Regardless of how much google "sucks" - they seem to have at least some things that folks like.

Post reply on HN