Live data from Hacker News

Pulling apart a £339 anti-5G USB stick

bbc.co.uk

11–20 of 110 posts

Re: Pulling apart a £339 anti-5G USB stick

#11
post #2

Ethical dilemma of placebos. If they give relief...?

I know what you mean - and the relief side of it is OK, but the downside is that people then think that this is a real thing, and 5G really is the issue, and they're right to do this, etc...

When I try to think about it in terms of the effect on people, it's much more complex than my initial "you muppets deserve to be relieved of £300 for believing total rubbish" reaction. You then think 'well, these people just need to be educated about this and then they'll see what's actually happening', but those kinds of strategies don't have the success rate you'd hope for in a rational world.

I wonder how many they've sold?

Re: Pulling apart a £339 anti-5G USB stick

#15
If you see "quantum" in a general public health product, you know it's going to be a scam, but probably a successful one.

My mother loves those kind of things and no amount of discussion with her will create any doubt in her mind.

I can't blame people falling for this though. They have been disrespected by the traditional health institutions for so long any escape seems good to them.

You can see the same effect in politics. To an extend, the current authorities have a lot of responsability in people listening to crooks.

Re: Pulling apart a £339 anti-5G USB stick

#17

This item is based on no science and horribly overpriced, but cosmetically attractive and sneakily marketed. Shocking. They should diversify into premium Hifi. Edit.

Where is the pseudoscience? It seems like an outright scam from the author's post, without any science pretense.

Re: Pulling apart a £339 anti-5G USB stick

#18
post #12

Things like this go to show how much money can be made with low effort if you don't have a conscience.

If the cost of progress is having the opponents of progress waste their money to allay their fictional fears, I could come to terms with the ethics of that.

Re: Pulling apart a £339 anti-5G USB stick

#19
If you think this is just bunk, and you'd like a laugh, read the FAQs on the website [1]...

My favourite:

>Does the device remove the EMF from the environment? If so can I use a meter to measure EMF?

>>The 'electro magnetic meter' can only measure the intensity of radiation which is not changed by our technology nor does it change the quality of connection and speed of data transfer.

Well, that's convenient, isn't it?

>>Our device harmonises all harmful frequencies into life affirming frequencies - it doesn't block - it transmutes.

I note there is no mention of which frequencies are 'harmful' and which are 'life affirming' - which would be even more useful given the frequency range of a WiFi or Cellular device, so you'd know which is which...

>> The only methods that we know can measure the difference between imbalanced radiation (without protection) and balanced radiation (with protection) These positive test results can be found on our website - please look for 'Case Study ' under Science and Research tab.

The Case Study starts with this paragraph:

>>In our civilization is emerging new science based on knowledge, whereas the official (old) science is based on information. We get information through our senses which are dual and deliver us an inverted picture of the truth and consequently, information is the opposite of knowledge so that all the old scientific concepts are therefore the upside down of the true concepts.

Do people actually believe this nonsense? It sounds like the kind of thing that Russell Brand was wittering about a couple of years ago - that your senses are the only way to interface with reality, and if you can't sense it it's not there, etc... Which can be disproved in seconds, even by a 10-year old child. I find it profoundly depressing when this kind of bamboozlement of the gullible is done in the form of sciency language. And it always seems to be done with a big price tag at the end of it.

[1] https://5gbioshield.com/frequently-asked-questions/

Post reply on HN