Live data from Hacker News

A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

theatlantic.com

101–110 of 438 posts

Re: A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

#101

Whenever you see someone who you believe to be an idiot succeeding, it usually means they're really good at the game and you don't even understand what the game is .

or, the people playing the game and the rules of the game are so utterly moronic and worthless that it defies belief, e.g., celebrity culture.

Re: A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

#102
I've many times tried to people make money but they get pretty defensive with their ideas and dreams and their plans, so I've decided different way, I drop them hints if I care for them enough and move on.

A lot of people just look at cause Vs effect in a wrong w

Re: A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

#103

Whenever you see someone who you believe to be an idiot succeeding, it usually means they're really good at the game and you don't even understand what the game is .

Or their family donated enough money to an Ivy to have a building named after them.

Passing on wealth to your children is part of the game. Or did you think the game ends after 1 generation?

Re: A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

#104
post #27

Whenever you see someone who you believe to be an idiot succeeding, it usually means they're really good at the game and you don't even understand what the game is .

Or maybe you just don't want to play the game anymore.

I think Buddhism comes close to this.

Re: A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

#106
post #39

Whenever you see someone who you believe to be an idiot succeeding, it usually means they're really good at the game and you don't even understand what the game is .

So Trump is really good at the political game, for instance?

Trump is a world-class salesman. And this skill is more about instinct than cerebral/deep thinking, which is why nerds “just don’t get it”.

Check Scott Adams’ writing on Trump’s persuasion abilities.

Re: A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

#107
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this is sadly very true - trying to actually be a kind person really limits how well you can play "the game". There's no good solution to this either - if there was more kindness in the world, then that would just create even more opportunities for the people playing the game to get ahead, because they would have more victims to exploit.

One key thing about the game is the definition of "being ahead", and in a way, the meaning you want your life to have. If the definition of being ahead is to work in upper management, or at trendy FAANG making a large amount of money then you are kind-of forced to play the game in order to "get ahead". However, if your version of getting ahead is to have a loving family, or to spend time on the hobbies you like or tr…

> I'm still working on finding my balance, but I've learned that I enjoy life much more when I'm doing something where I can spend less time playing the game, even if that comes with a large decrease in income and "prestige".

Unfortunately in the US, if you don’t play the game, you have greatly reduced access to healthcare, which is a huge incentive to play the game especially if you have kids.

Re: A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

#109
post #84

I don’t really understand the point of the article. It seems to be challenging an assumption that being “smart” has something to do with being financially successful. But why would we start with that assumption? Why would we conflate being “intelligent” with being good at making money? To me, this seems as preposterous as asking “if you’re so smart, why are you so bad at playing the violin, or why aren’t you a Hollyw…

Nah it just means too many people think they are "smart" while not applying their supposed edge to get any practical thing done better.

Money is just one example. The baseline is "if you are so smart why how come you don't have a better life", this can be more money, a better job, more time for your children, a hotter wife for some.

If you don't like the materialistic versions, My personal version of it is "if you are so smart why are you complaining so much instead of fixing your problems"..

Re: A lot of “idiotic” things have reasonable explanations (2011)

#110

I love the way people who consider themselves smart rationalize their lack of success/wealth, including here. - I don't want to be wealthy anyway - To be wealthy you have to be ruthless and I prefer to be nice - smart people are so busy with issues much more important than money - wealthy people are just lucky idiots - wealthy people are just idiots who are better at exploiting other idiots - people who are wealthy s…

This is so true i don't understand the downvotes
Post reply on HN