Live data from Hacker News

I bought netflix.soy

tinyprojects.dev

221–230 of 272 posts

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#221

This is the first time in a couple years that I have seen a reference to myself while reading an article. Thanks for the surprise! > No. They're welcome to have them back anytime they want. They could probably do it pretty forcibly if I refused to budge too (see Microsoft vs. MikeRoweSoft).

Do you still have that Xbox?

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#222
post #11

Strange that Netflix hasn't drunk the Registry cool-aid and bought their "all-encompassing" TLD package which registers their trademark across all TLD's for a special price. On top of that, I'm doubly surprised Google hasn't taken action and already put this domain on hold in preemption of selling Netflix one of these deals.

>their "all-encompassing" TLD package which registers their trademark across all TLD's for a special price That's a thing? What's preventing a predatory registry from being a holdout and demanding exorbitant prices?

Yeah: Domains Protected Marks List, e.g Donuts: https://donuts.domains/what-we-do/brand-protection

afaik there's nothing that requires registries to use a DPML and it doesn't really make sense unless they manage lots of TLDs, since the cost of adding your trademark to the DPML is usually a lot more than the cost of a single registration.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#223

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lots of people hand registered 3 and 4 letter .coms in the past. So because they could do it, anyone who points out it's not possible now should be downvoted and asked to explain themselves with: Why is it not possible, beside the fact that it's not possible? [Edited to remove excess frustration/annoyance/snark at people quibbling so much about a totally inconsequential and factual remark.]

Go back to reddit neckbeard

[deleted]

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#224

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about .sucks? Couldn’t one claim free speech? https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerkay/2015/06/29/saga-of-suc...

Free speech is a right issued by governments to the people. It is not a valid concept between two private parties. https://money.cnn.com/2017/08/08/technology/google-workplace...

Yes, but the argument GP responded to was that "ICANN enforces trademark rights on domains" and that "If the trademark already existed when you bought the domain, and especially if it's widely used and ambiguous, you're gonna lose that domain if the company comes after you."

He argues that the practice has its basis in trademark laws. If it is so, nominative use of a trademark to e.g. criticize a product is considered fair use and shouldn't be ruled out by ICANN on that basis. It either wouldn't be, or ICANN have some other basis than trademark law for their rulings.

So GP's point raises an interesting question. If you had registered e.g. "google.sucks" or something similar in which the FQDN arguably forms a valid nominative use in itself in good faith to use that domain to criticize Google's business decisions and products, does ICANN have some other policy outside respecting trademark law that would compel them to take the name back and give it to Google?

The answer to that question isn't "Free speech is a right issued by governments to the people". That's a pointless non sequitur at best, and I'm frankly tired of hearing it used in defense of huge monopolies that are well deserved of scrutiny in the interest of defending freedom of expression.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#225
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Companies like Mark Monitor will buy all of the .tld's for you-- and continually grab new ones (as the set of TLDs is constantly growing). At Netflix's size, I would assume they would've paid for such a service.

It's worth noting that MarkMonitor ownership has changed in recent years. Regardless, they certainly can register all the names for you, if that's what you ask them to do, but at some point, there's an awful lot of names, and it feels extortiony to pay for them all. I was working for a MarkMonitor client when the 'landrush' for all these new tlds was happening, and we'd get frequent emails about which tlds were going…

When you mention the change of ownership, I assume that there's an implication there, but would you be willing to be explicit about it?

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#226
post #206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, if your name is Mike Google, then you might have better chances at keeping your domain. Probably still not good chances to profit off of it.

Now this a valid reason to give your kid the surname of a brand. To get rich quick. Too bad that this also limits employment options in the long run (can you imagine Google to work for Amazon?)

It remember me the story of Mike Rowe who named his company Mike Rowe Soft. Here the details: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_v._MikeRoweSoft

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#227

Interestingly, I recently saw a couple a couple of google.* domains available on Google Domains, including some reasonable-sounding ones: IIRC, google.tech (edit: google.page), google.business, and google.camp. Tried to purchase them but they instantly became unavailable the moment I tried to do so. The cynic in me thinks that Google has a special check for those and renews it themselves if someone tries… More genera…

I felt the same when I wanted to pick my domain name: you're tempted to go for the traditional way of going with YourName, and then buy the .com or .org but what if you buy only one of them ? How does someone else know that YourName.io isn't your website if you don't buy it ?

My conclusion was that your domain name must not be in the form of YourName.tld; the tld must be part of your name. You can either use puns like buying yourna.me, but it's a bit weird for non-tech people, or you have to use the weirdness of tlds and go for something like lostin.space. There is less confusion at "what comes after" because there is only one.

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#229
post #205
post #149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

http://ai./ still works

What happens if I have a computer on my network named ai? Wouldn't it cause a conflict? I called my FreeNAS box freenas because I didn't feel very creative, and I can browse to it as http://freenas or http://freenas./ but if they took a domain of 'freenas' suddenly that means I have to do extra work and rename my stuff. Doesn't seem fair!

You should have used a reserved TLD like `.local'. If you set it as the local domain name `ai' and `ai.local' would work. `ai.' would not work, as the dot at the end tells it to look at the top level. (like the slash at the beginning of an absolute path)

Re: I bought netflix.soy

#230

One winter day, my wife looked down the coast and noticed that the bell buoy that marked the entrance to Plum Island Sound was lying on the beach. This thing is enormous, about 30 ft long. We drove down and walked around it with some other curious people. Took some pictures. She thought that we ought to report it. I told her that many people would already have done that. A couple of days went by and there didn’t seem…

I had a similar situation while driving through South Carolina on the freeway - we saw a small fire on the side of the road! My wife and I were wondering if anyone called about it and I thought that probably not, everyone assumes someone else did. We did end up calling 911 and they didn't seem aware if it yet and sent a fire crew out!
Post reply on HN