Live data from Hacker News

Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

github.com

41–50 of 97 posts

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#41
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I made the mistake of copying a node project I was working on.... holy cow does Backup and Sync choke on all those tiny JavaScript files. It started syncing and just couldn't stop. I had to delete or move all the Backup and Sync contents across my devices to get to 0 before it quit endlessly thrashing.

Dropbox still has the best sync tech and is the only one that can handle deep and numerous file hierarchies. The rest have better pricing and integrations like email/productivity apps.

Thanks for the tip!

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#43

Yet another way that Google's branding creates confusion. I read "Google drive desktop app" and my mind jumped to storage / files, not word processor. In my mind, "Google drive" is storage, "Google docs" is word processing / spreadsheets etc. I have no idea why they brought docs into drive.

They didn't. It isn't. This isn't a Google project. The author named it confusingly, not Google.

In your mind is correct. Docs isn't part of Drive. The umbrella term is G Suite (previously Google Apps), not Drive.

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#44
What's the difference between using this and clicking on the new "Install" button in the URL bar? I have all of my Google apps available as system apps either using that button or using "More tools -> Create shortcut", which is probably one of the best hidden gems of Chrome (yes, even Gmail can run as a separate app and supports offline mode).

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#45

It's a cool concept in theory -- I'd always thought I'd like using it. But in practice, I realize I'm addicted to tabs. When working on 3 documents at once, I want them in separate tabs in the same window -- not 3 different windows. Maybe I'm in the minority, but I'm actually at the point where I want things to go in the opposite direction -- just turn all my apps into tabs. (Like Chromebooks, I guess.) Finder? VLC?…

PWAs are neat, but have no multi-tab feature that I know of. I put in a feature request trying to inspire the Brave dev team to make some really neat PWA stuff. They can literally do anything they want as long as the future spec doesn't conflict. Super jealous of how fun it would be able to reinvent the web with total freedom.

View/modify PWA manifest on web-app/shortcut export

https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/7729

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#46
This is a cool project, and the code does really stand out in terms of quality.

I wanted to do something like this for years, but never got the time to make it, so I'm glad to see someone did it.

However now I think this is not really relevant, thanks to PWA there's a better way to make Google docs apps feel native.

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#47

It's a cool concept in theory -- I'd always thought I'd like using it. But in practice, I realize I'm addicted to tabs. When working on 3 documents at once, I want them in separate tabs in the same window -- not 3 different windows. Maybe I'm in the minority, but I'm actually at the point where I want things to go in the opposite direction -- just turn all my apps into tabs. (Like Chromebooks, I guess.) Finder? VLC?…

Full screen tab-only was ChromeOS in 2009-2011: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KRPjkiw0dYU

Then they put a fairly conventional window manager and taskbar/dock around those in 2012, https://www.theverge.com/2012/4/26/2978163/aura-chrome-os-ha...

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#48
post #39

This not being an official release from Google, using this is potentially worse than giving someone your Google password without fully vetting it. There are some existing safeguards in place to make a password alone difficult to use, but the app itself would have signed in access to your account and the contents of files. You may think it's simple to watch the app for bad behavior and decide it's safe, but you wouldn…

Does it ask for your password? I'd expect it to use OAuth.

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#49
post #16

What is the deal with Google's syncing apps? "Backup and Sync" still misses features like Files On-Demand/Smart Sync available in OneDrive/Dropbox and deleting files online pollutes the local trash/recycle bin on macOS/Window computers. "Drive File Stream" actually has these lazily loaded file placeholders, but it is treated like an additionally mounted volume instead of a local folder somewhere on my local disks. It…

I switched to Google Drive a while back because I really wanted better photo storage and Dropbox killed that off a while back, plus the Google One account is pretty nice. But I had no idea that Google would be so horrible at syncing files. It's really amazing how poor it is compared to Dropbox.

Dropbox has spent a decade on solving a single problem and that shows in the product experience, even though it's more costly and has less extra features like email and productivity apps.

Their blog posts explain why they're so much better:

https://dropbox.tech/infrastructure/rewriting-the-heart-of-o...

https://dropbox.tech/infrastructure/-testing-our-new-sync-en...

Re: Google Drive Desktop – A cross-platform Google Drive desktop app made w Electron

#50

Yet another way that Google's branding creates confusion. I read "Google drive desktop app" and my mind jumped to storage / files, not word processor. In my mind, "Google drive" is storage, "Google docs" is word processing / spreadsheets etc. I have no idea why they brought docs into drive.

Isn't it just the author of this app (it doesn't look affiliated to Google to me)? Probably should call it Google Docs Desktop instead. I don't find Google's official use of Drive and Docs confusing (there are some overlaps, but in a natural way).

As it isn't affiliated with Google it shouldn't (and can't) use the name Google like this at all (it could say like "for Google Docs" or something after some clear first party branding).
Post reply on HN