Live data from Hacker News

Tesla workers’ unemployment may be suspended if they don't return, emails show

theguardian.com

1–10 of 70 posts

Re: Tesla workers’ unemployment may be suspended if they don't return, emails show

#3
I'm a foreigner so I don't fully understand this, but here's my take:

1) Tesla is restarting the factory against local rules saying they can't, because their competition is in different localities with their local rules saying they can, and Tesla is at a disadvantage.

2) It's basically illegal for the workers to go to work, but Tesla is still insisting they do this?

3) the local council has said they won't do enforcement.

4) If the staff refuse (a potentially unsafe) order from Tesla to return to their jobs (to break the law) the govt will stop paying unemployment?

So, my understanding, the workers have to potentially risk their health and break the law or the govt won't pay them unemployment?

Have I made a mistake?

That's a messed up situation for those workers. Does Cali do anything like suspended sentences(you get sentenced to prison, but you don't have to go, but if you do another crime you have to go for both durations)? Would this impact workers in that situation?

Re: Tesla workers’ unemployment may be suspended if they don't return, emails show

#7
post #3

I'm a foreigner so I don't fully understand this, but here's my take: 1) Tesla is restarting the factory against local rules saying they can't, because their competition is in different localities with their local rules saying they can, and Tesla is at a disadvantage. 2) It's basically illegal for the workers to go to work, but Tesla is still insisting they do this? 3) the local council has said they won't do enforce…

There's no scenario in which the workers get charged with anything as they are not breaking any laws.

If a health department finds that a restaurant is too dirty to operate, they don't jail the workers or the workers but fine or shutdown the restaurant.

This is a similar kind of an order - the best county could do is to fine Tesla or shut them down.

Re: Tesla workers’ unemployment may be suspended if they don't return, emails show

#8
post #3

I'm a foreigner so I don't fully understand this, but here's my take: 1) Tesla is restarting the factory against local rules saying they can't, because their competition is in different localities with their local rules saying they can, and Tesla is at a disadvantage. 2) It's basically illegal for the workers to go to work, but Tesla is still insisting they do this? 3) the local council has said they won't do enforce…

You're not missing anything. The local county has already said they won't prosecute the workers for violating the health order since Elon Musk is making them choose between their health or their livelihoods.

It's also unlikely the local county or state will prosecute Elon Musk since it's difficult to pinpoint the actual criminal violation he could be charged with.

However, it's very likely that Musk will be sued in civil court by one or more of his (ex) employees. There are a variety of different legal claims they could make, so it's hard to say what the outcome would be.

Re: Tesla workers’ unemployment may be suspended if they don't return, emails show

#10
post #6

No judgement , but just a reminder that this is a company making expensive battery cars at a time when nobody's driving and oil prices are negative

No presumption, but demand outstrips supply for teslas so they are always atleast a few months behind, and now probably much more.
Post reply on HN