Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

blog.swipegood.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 23 posts

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#11

Post by ronnier »

light3 wrote: post #8

I wonder where all the money will go to, and whether a developed country like Japan really need help to handle the disaster in this situation, given their history with such events. Its really hard to find where the money will go to, the swipegood site doesn't even link to world vision, I had to get there through google. The world vision site says: "Your gift will help us rush emergency supplies like life-saving food,…

I know somebody who works with retirement plans for charity organizations. I was shocked after seeing the salaries and pension plans of the people in some of these organizations. They are only required to donate a very small percentage of the money collected.

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#12

Post by jaredhansen »

melling wrote: post #9
SteliE wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I completely get your point & at the same time it's really important not to be paralyzed by the need to make "the perfect choice" and act quickly in a moment of urgency. There needs to be balance between taking some time to make an informed decision and acting today rather than pushing it away for later!

That's right there needs to be balance. There currently isn't any. I'm asking the HN crowd if they have any insight into the most effective ways to donate. I found this site that seems to be reputable. http://charitywatch.org/ [update] I found a direct link on the site related to the earthquake in Japan. World Vision is listed along with others. http://charitywatch.org/hottopics/JapanTsunami2011.html This site does s…

Another useful site I've found for helping you figure out where the money goes, etc. is http://www.charitynavigator.org -- IIRC, I first heard of it in the wake of the 2004 tsunami off of Thailand, and it's been a helpful resource ever since.

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#13

Post by sthatipamala »

For full disclosure, WorldVision is a Christian evangelical organization that only hires Christians for its staff: http://www.worldvision.org/content.nsf/about/hr-requirements...

I don't mean to deter anyone from donating. I just thought people might like to know about the charity before they donate.

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#14

Post by WingForward »

SteliE wrote: post #7
melling wrote: post #6

There are so many relief organizations. I often wonder which ones are the most effective and most efficient. I also wonder which one's would be most effective in Japan at this time. I Googled and got a list. http://www.people.com/people/article/0,,20473235,00.html People like to help but I think we could all do more if we understood the problem better. Often donated money isn't used for the current disaster but is us…

I completely get your point & at the same time it's really important not to be paralyzed by the need to make "the perfect choice" and act quickly in a moment of urgency. There needs to be balance between taking some time to make an informed decision and acting today rather than pushing it away for later!

Do you know how long it takes for your donation to have the impact you expect it should?

Does a day make a difference? A week? A month?

I don't know the answer to that, but I'd like to, but not enough to do the research myself.

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#15

Post by cheez »

ronnier wrote: post #11
light3 wrote: post #8

I wonder where all the money will go to, and whether a developed country like Japan really need help to handle the disaster in this situation, given their history with such events. Its really hard to find where the money will go to, the swipegood site doesn't even link to world vision, I had to get there through google. The world vision site says: "Your gift will help us rush emergency supplies like life-saving food,…

I know somebody who works with retirement plans for charity organizations. I was shocked after seeing the salaries and pension plans of the people in some of these organizations. They are only required to donate a very small percentage of the money collected.

I've been saying this for years.

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#16

Post by Joakal »

sthatipamala wrote: post #13

For full disclosure, WorldVision is a Christian evangelical organization that only hires Christians for its staff: http://www.worldvision.org/content.nsf/about/hr-requirements... I don't mean to deter anyone from donating. I just thought people might like to know about the charity before they donate.

They're one of the efficient charities though:

http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary...

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#17

Post by lubos »

cheez wrote: post #15
ronnier wrote: post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know somebody who works with retirement plans for charity organizations. I was shocked after seeing the salaries and pension plans of the people in some of these organizations. They are only required to donate a very small percentage of the money collected.

I've been saying this for years.

they are required to donate 5% of their equity each year to retain their tax exempt status with IRS. most charities do it this way including the biggest one - bill and melinda gates foundation.

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#18

Post by edge17 »

lubos wrote: post #17
cheez wrote: post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been saying this for years.

they are required to donate 5% of their equity each year to retain their tax exempt status with IRS. most charities do it this way including the biggest one - bill and melinda gates foundation.

bill and melinda aren't asking me for money though

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#19

Post by lubos »

edge17 wrote: post #18
lubos wrote: post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

they are required to donate 5% of their equity each year to retain their tax exempt status with IRS. most charities do it this way including the biggest one - bill and melinda gates foundation.

bill and melinda aren't asking me for money though

the point is that charities are run for the benefit of people who control them.

Re: Support The Victims of Japan's Earthquake With Your Loose Change

#20

Post by mistermann »

lubos wrote: post #19
edge17 wrote: post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

bill and melinda aren't asking me for money though

the point is that charities are run for the benefit of people who control them.

I tend to agree...but would you apply that statement to the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation as well?
Post reply on HN