Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: Call Mom

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 243 posts

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#21

Is it a cultural thing Americans are so detached? Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

Yes. We’ve done some weird things to the culture we don’t really understand. And on top of that we mock those parts of society that still have a culture and claim things like “white people have no culture”. But then what are rednecks and Southern Baptists or Mormons if not distinct sub-cultures.

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#22

Is it a cultural thing Americans are so detached? Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

I'm 38 and in the US and I talk to my parents almost every day. I call them on the way to work or randomly on the weekends. We also have a big get-together for mother's day, but of course this year is a little different. I don't think it's that unusual here in the US.

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#23

If your mother is a kind person whom you love, then by all means reach out and tell her. To others like me who may have a gaslighting c* * * of a mother, don't be bullied by societal norms into feeling like a bad person just because you don't want to connect with an abuser. It's perfectly fine to not call your mother on mother's day if you don't have the kind of relationship that will benefit from it.

Mine died a few years ago and my life is better for it.

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#24

Is it a cultural thing Americans are so detached? Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

My parents are east European immigrants to the US. They’ve had a hard life, never adjusted well. Calls to mom last about 20 seconds before she hands the phone off to my father, who will recount the mistakes and sufferings of his life.

They’re broken. I call every other week but sometimes if I call more they’ll not answer the phone. I call, either way. There won’t be anything more, previous efforts to repair or resolve or lift any of this have always returned things to the current condition. It always rests here.

So I’ll call, but yes, this is how it is. I wish they had considered going back decades ago. Or hadn’t crumpled under the strain of their efforts.

These holidays are a reminder of what we can’t have.

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#25

Is it a cultural thing Americans are so detached? Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

> Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

Yes like many things it varies culturally.

Calling family 2-4 times a week seems extraordinarily excessive to me. What possibly changes that often that you have anything to tell them about on a call that frequent?

I don't think I call my wife that often when I'm working away.

And I'm British so it's not just Americans.

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#26

Is it a cultural thing Americans are so detached? Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

It’s highly dependent on the family. I call/FaceTime family weekly while friends, who have good relationships with their family, call maybe once a quarter. Anecdotally, my international friends on average put family calls in a higher regard than my American friends.

3—5 calls per year seems great. I don’t feel detached. Or maybe I am and that’s how I like it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Still love my mom though. Will call her in a bit.

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#27

Is it a cultural thing Americans are so detached? Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

Your question is whether this correlates with nationality. Sincere question: why did you focus on that attribute instead of some other? Is calling your mother several times per week typical on your country?

Even if you think it’s more cultural there’s no denying that immigrating to a new country at least partially conforms you to new cultural norms specific to that country.

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#28

If your mother is a kind person whom you love, then by all means reach out and tell her. To others like me who may have a gaslighting c* * * of a mother, don't be bullied by societal norms into feeling like a bad person just because you don't want to connect with an abuser. It's perfectly fine to not call your mother on mother's day if you don't have the kind of relationship that will benefit from it.

> It's especially important to call important people in your life today

Right - boggles my mind that people think they should be telling anyone to call anyone on a site like this.

(Not a comment on my mother - just the idea that everyone has the same relationships as you do and should do things the way you do them.)

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#29

Is it a cultural thing Americans are so detached? Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

Same. I call her almost everyday. Sometimes we even talk for hours. Btw I'm in abroad. She doesn't believe/like in celebration/days like this, same applies for me.

Re: Tell HN: Call Mom

#30

Is it a cultural thing Americans are so detached? Its usual here to call your family 2 to 4 times a week

Your question is whether this correlates with nationality. Sincere question: why did you focus on that attribute instead of some other? Is calling your mother several times per week typical on your country?

> Is calling your mother several times per week typical on your country?

Yes :-)

My family is half European half South American. I call them almost every other day. On a busy week, perhaps I'll only call during the weekend.

My Taiwanese wife calls her mom every day.

Post reply on HN