Live data from Hacker News

The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

pcworld.com

61–70 of 92 posts

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#61
post #43

Show me Motion 5 and FCPX for Windows and I'll gladly switch.

You should try davinci resolve. It has a free version, and even runs on linux.

Tried both - Resolve is slower and, most importantly, TONS less intuitive than FCPX (even than Motion 5). Also, last I checked, the free version of Resolve is non-commercial

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#62
post #6

Show me Motion 5 and FCPX for Windows and I'll gladly switch.

So we all know that can't happen; whats keeping you away from the adobe suite? From my research as a begining youtuber, the biggest hurdle seems to be price

- paying the extortion every month, - speed (no real time in AE/Premiere)

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#63
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I upgraded from a 2015 MacBook Pro to a 2019 16”. I heard there were tons of keyboard issues in the years in between. Aside from that, I stick with MacBooks because of the solid quality and macOS. I can’t work on Windows. I’ve tried again and again. I do have a windows machine for gaming, but programming and design work, the short cuts, fluidity, and general experience working in iTerm2 with multiple desktops is top…

WSL2 is fast, rock-solid and outperforms a Mac with iterm2 by far. I don't know which fluidity you mean on a multi montior setup you lack on Windows. Re short-cuts Windows has more (just think of win+number or built in window management) or autohotkey which owns karabiner. MacOs is good if you need Xcode but other than that? Idk

> WSL2 is fast, rock-solid and outperforms a Mac with iterm2 by far.

You have benchmarks for this? I’m running a Windows Pro installation with a Core i7 4790K and 16GB memory. My 2015 MacBook is much faster. I honestly thought the WSL thing was just a gimmick and some online searching told me that there are IO performance issues.

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#64
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not only are they better built, they also run macOS.

> Not only are they better built In this case, but there are plenty of examples of a sub-par performance from Apple. Broken keyboards, display cable issues, shipping with overheating CPU profiles, removing buttons, useless touch bar display, removal of ports - to name a few. As Rossman says: "the only part on a MacBook that doesn't blow are the fuses". > they also run macOS Again, not been a fan of their recent work.…

> I can get a very macOS-esque experience in Linux.

The problem is the “can get.” If you value your time at, say, $200/hr, how long can you spend learning about Linux distros, repos, software, and troubleshooting issues etc before you’ve spent the savings from buying a non-Mac-native laptop?

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#65
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I upgraded from a 2015 MacBook Pro to a 2019 16”. I heard there were tons of keyboard issues in the years in between. Aside from that, I stick with MacBooks because of the solid quality and macOS. I can’t work on Windows. I’ve tried again and again. I do have a windows machine for gaming, but programming and design work, the short cuts, fluidity, and general experience working in iTerm2 with multiple desktops is top…

WSL2 is fast, rock-solid and outperforms a Mac with iterm2 by far. I don't know which fluidity you mean on a multi montior setup you lack on Windows. Re short-cuts Windows has more (just think of win+number or built in window management) or autohotkey which owns karabiner. MacOs is good if you need Xcode but other than that? Idk

I was curious if I was using an older version that led to my problems with WSL2, but I just did a search right now for “WSL 2 slow” on Google. I see threads and discussions in the past couple months with people still calling out how slow it is and other issues.

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#66

“X laptop which is cheaper than a MacBook benches higher” This is not news, this has always been true. People keep buying MacBooks, it’s been one of the best selling laptops for a decade. There must be some other reason why people like them.... Maybe benchmarks don’t matter to most people? Really makes you think

Or, rather, "X laptop which is cheaper than premium laptop Y benches higher".

Which also isn't news. It's trivial to find a laptop that outperforms a premium laptop at half the price. That's equally true of any non-Apple vendor that has premium business laptop models.

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not only are they better built, they also run macOS.

I upgraded from a 2015 MacBook Pro to a 2019 16”. I heard there were tons of keyboard issues in the years in between. Aside from that, I stick with MacBooks because of the solid quality and macOS. I can’t work on Windows. I’ve tried again and again. I do have a windows machine for gaming, but programming and design work, the short cuts, fluidity, and general experience working in iTerm2 with multiple desktops is top…

Omni focus web app seems to work just fine for me. I love the ios version - never tried Mac

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#68
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

WSL2 is fast, rock-solid and outperforms a Mac with iterm2 by far. I don't know which fluidity you mean on a multi montior setup you lack on Windows. Re short-cuts Windows has more (just think of win+number or built in window management) or autohotkey which owns karabiner. MacOs is good if you need Xcode but other than that? Idk

I was curious if I was using an older version that led to my problems with WSL2, but I just did a search right now for “WSL 2 slow” on Google. I see threads and discussions in the past couple months with people still calling out how slow it is and other issues.

Seems to be around how some people are using filesystem heavily. For iterm2 style use its great

Re: The $1,799 MacBook Pro 13 vs. the $650 Acer Swift 3

#70
post #64
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Not only are they better built In this case, but there are plenty of examples of a sub-par performance from Apple. Broken keyboards, display cable issues, shipping with overheating CPU profiles, removing buttons, useless touch bar display, removal of ports - to name a few. As Rossman says: "the only part on a MacBook that doesn't blow are the fuses". > they also run macOS Again, not been a fan of their recent work.…

> I can get a very macOS-esque experience in Linux. The problem is the “can get.” If you value your time at, say, $200/hr, how long can you spend learning about Linux distros, repos, software, and troubleshooting issues etc before you’ve spent the savings from buying a non-Mac-native laptop?

If you value your time like that you might as well sleep 2h less and earn 400$ every night.

This is not a fair comparison because there are a lot of benefits of troubleshooting, most of them intangible. If you don't like it fine, just get a Linux "certified" laptop or a Mac.

Post reply on HN