Live data from Hacker News

I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

secondbreakfast.co

171–180 of 217 posts

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#171
post #98
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think he's a parasite? He seems to live a modest life, and work very hard to make the economy work more efficiently. He's giving almost all of his money to philanthropic causes, and seems to campaign for all the right causes. He maintains a pretty low profile for his level of success (he doesn't even support philanthropy through his own family foundation; he went with Gates, since he thought they'd do a be…

I think his claim to be a beneficial 'allocator of capital' is bogus. He tends to invest in established exploitative companies. His investments have been made on an almost exclusive basis of growing wealth, which in the end is a very sterile end to aim for. > I'll tell you why I like the cigarette business. It costs a penny to make. Sell it for a dollar. It's addictive. And there's fantastic brand loyalty. — Buffett,…

> His investments have been made on an almost exclusive basis of growing wealth, which in the end is a very sterile end to aim for.

This is what investment is, no?

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

...and that's why he also said on Monday: "If you took someone and asked them, without them knowing whether they'd be born boy or girl, black or white, with or without any relevant talent, or to rich or poor parents, and asked them when and where they'd like to be born. They'd answer, 'The US, in modern times'. There is no place on Earth, and no time in history, that a person can make the most of their talents, as to…

I see how it could sound weird to the eyes of an American, but the only place where I think his statement would be incorrect is Western Europe. A part from that I'm confident that a majority of people around the world would very much like to either have been born in the US or give their children the opportunity to live there. At least where I'm originally from, emigration to the US is seen as an an incredibly desirab…

I'm canadian, I sure as fuck wouldn't want to emigrate to the USA. Warren Buffet has huge biases and blind spots when it comes to sociological analysis. I strongly doubt the man understands what it's like to be making 7$ an hour working at Dennys somewhere in the bible belt because the public school system left you semi-illiterate, or living in any heavily criminalized urban area, or picking fruits in california because you had to escape cartels in mexico/central america. None of the people in my examples or developing their full potential, and there's a massive proportion of americans in this bottom social class.

*And canada could be doing way better. There are glaring social inequalities here too.

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#174
post #98
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think he's a parasite? He seems to live a modest life, and work very hard to make the economy work more efficiently. He's giving almost all of his money to philanthropic causes, and seems to campaign for all the right causes. He maintains a pretty low profile for his level of success (he doesn't even support philanthropy through his own family foundation; he went with Gates, since he thought they'd do a be…

I think his claim to be a beneficial 'allocator of capital' is bogus. He tends to invest in established exploitative companies. His investments have been made on an almost exclusive basis of growing wealth, which in the end is a very sterile end to aim for. > I'll tell you why I like the cigarette business. It costs a penny to make. Sell it for a dollar. It's addictive. And there's fantastic brand loyalty. — Buffett,…

> None of this is meant as a critique of capitalism.

Lol, I was really with you up until this point. There will always be people like buffet as long as there is capitalism.

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#175

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I see how it could sound weird to the eyes of an American, but the only place where I think his statement would be incorrect is Western Europe. A part from that I'm confident that a majority of people around the world would very much like to either have been born in the US or give their children the opportunity to live there. At least where I'm originally from, emigration to the US is seen as an an incredibly desirab…

I'm canadian, I sure as fuck wouldn't want to emigrate to the USA. Warren Buffet has huge biases and blind spots when it comes to sociological analysis. I strongly doubt the man understands what it's like to be making 7$ an hour working at Dennys somewhere in the bible belt because the public school system left you semi-illiterate, or living in any heavily criminalized urban area, or picking fruits in california beca…

Not sure 'massive proportion' is right? I think its less than 50M in America, employed at labor jobs. That's around 12%?

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#176
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think his claim to be a beneficial 'allocator of capital' is bogus. He tends to invest in established exploitative companies. His investments have been made on an almost exclusive basis of growing wealth, which in the end is a very sterile end to aim for. > I'll tell you why I like the cigarette business. It costs a penny to make. Sell it for a dollar. It's addictive. And there's fantastic brand loyalty. — Buffett,…

That article starts with an incorrect premise. "America isn’t supposed to allow moats, much less reward them. Our economic system, we claim, is founded on free and fair competition." That's called a straw man. No one has ever said America "doesn't allow moats" and that there is "free and fair competition". The whole point of business is, within the law, to build a moat that makes it impossible for a late-starting com…

Funny, I thought the point of business was to exchange goods and services in mutually beneficial ways. The rest is rent seeking.

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#177
post #98
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think he's a parasite? He seems to live a modest life, and work very hard to make the economy work more efficiently. He's giving almost all of his money to philanthropic causes, and seems to campaign for all the right causes. He maintains a pretty low profile for his level of success (he doesn't even support philanthropy through his own family foundation; he went with Gates, since he thought they'd do a be…

I think his claim to be a beneficial 'allocator of capital' is bogus. He tends to invest in established exploitative companies. His investments have been made on an almost exclusive basis of growing wealth, which in the end is a very sterile end to aim for. > I'll tell you why I like the cigarette business. It costs a penny to make. Sell it for a dollar. It's addictive. And there's fantastic brand loyalty. — Buffett,…

> He tends to invest in established exploitative companies.

What about BNSF for instance?

> His investments have been made on an almost exclusive basis of growing wealth, which in the end is a very sterile end to aim for.

What is a more appropriate terminal goal for a hedge fund manager? Would you personally invest your parents' 401Ks, your alma mater's endowment, or your city/state's pensions in a fund whose goal is not "growing wealth"? Are you willing to contribute to each fund to make up the difference (or raise taxes)?

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#178

Boxer (Animal Farm) had grit. Whenever things got tough, he'd say "I will work harder!" After his death, his saying became a mantra and model for other good citizens to follow.

I revisited Animal Farm a few months ago. There are more and more mornings now where I'm reading the news, thinking about our world, and reminded of the animals on that farm.

Definitely, the people who think we’ve defeated the human issues in those books are horribly misguided. Stalinism is sufficient but not necessary to have Animal Farm.

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#179
post #58

Boxer (Animal Farm) had grit. Whenever things got tough, he'd say "I will work harder!" After his death, his saying became a mantra and model for other good citizens to follow.

I worked for a few companies whose mode of operation was exactly that. This works so long as there's a steady supply of young, talented people but falls flat on its face when the company tries to scale up its business.

[deleted]

Re: I was tricked into thinking I had “grit”

#180
post #58

Boxer (Animal Farm) had grit. Whenever things got tough, he'd say "I will work harder!" After his death, his saying became a mantra and model for other good citizens to follow.

I worked for a few companies whose mode of operation was exactly that. This works so long as there's a steady supply of young, talented people but falls flat on its face when the company tries to scale up its business.

Spoiler alert:

The horse doesn't die, its turned into glue after being sent to a "vet" having collapsing from exhaustion.

Post reply on HN