Live data from Hacker News

Google Pixel Buds

blog.google

281–290 of 375 posts

Re: Google Pixel Buds

#281

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The entire product is a copy of the AirPods. But you know what? I'm fine with that. That's how competition works, and competition is what brings down prices. And I personally find the scrolling page design (both Apple's and Google's) pretty cool. It would drive me nuts if a site I used daily implemented something like that, like if it became a trend for news sites. But to show off a new product where I'll scroll thro…

That's how competition works No. Competition is you inventing a better mousetrap, not copying someone else's mousetrap.

A mousetrap is still a mousetrap, though. They didn't copy the Air Pods, you should be able to see the differences for yourself if you just look at the product pages. Can you honestly not?

Re: Google Pixel Buds

#283

Does anyone else really struggle with comfort when using headphones which go into the ear canal (IEMs)? I know there is better sound isolation, but for some reason I cannot stand the minor pressure of them in my ears.

Have you actually tried the AirPods Pro? I've always used in-ear headphones but also always felt fatigue from the pressure. But the AirPods just don't have it. It's more like they sit at the edge of your ear instead of burrowing inside it, and they explicitly use some kind of vent to equalize pressure as well. Visually, these look like they operate in roughly the same way.

I've tried them, it's definitely an issue still. If I place them at the edge of my ear they just fall out. Tried the different sizes too. I never used in-ear prior in my life, so I assume I'm just not used to it.

Re: Google Pixel Buds

#284

They look bad. What is up with the prominently carved "G"? They feel like they were designed by a truck manufacturer.

Is it that prominent? You can't even see it in many of the images since it's always the same color as its background.

Re: Google Pixel Buds

#287

Please Google, just because my browser is in Berlin, that doesn't mean I speak German. I'd like to look at your product. I might even be interested. But I can't understand what you're telling me. I have language preferences in my account, and you definitely know who I am because you're showing my picture in the top right corner. So why does where I am take precedence over who I am?

(This comment was posted when the URL was https://store.google.com/product/pixel_buds. Since changed.)

Re: Google Pixel Buds

#288

Please Google, just because my browser is in Berlin, that doesn't mean I speak German. I'd like to look at your product. I might even be interested. But I can't understand what you're telling me. I have language preferences in my account, and you definitely know who I am because you're showing my picture in the top right corner. So why does where I am take precedence over who I am?

I always wondered wtf the browsers language setting is for. Can a website not query this for the preferred language rather than make a language decision based on an IP address geo lookup? I am English, my browsers language order is to set English (UK) then English (generic). No foreign languages. However I live in [redacted] and if I visit a site it will give me a [redacted] version due to my location rather than the…

Even worse, GeoIP doesn't even have high enough resolution.

I'm currently in Switzerland. Different regions speak German, French and Italian (among others).

If you just use "this IP is in Switzerland" to try and guess the best language, you will definitely get it wrong. 25% of .ch pages I have never visited before start out in French, most others in German.

No rhyme or reason.

Re: Google Pixel Buds

#289

Off-topic but this website is such a blatant rip-off of the AirPods Pro landing page[1] (EDIT: Discussed at the time [2]), and I _hate_ the UX. I'm not sure what device this is optimised for, but it requires a tonn of scrolling, it's janky, you end up scrolling past the info you want, it breaks basic functionality like Ctrl+F. Why not just make a video instead of a webpage, since that's clearly the effect they're goi…

This is a good reminder that if you want good design, don't just rip off another site, implement it, and ship. Build a prototype, user test it, and when they say this sucks, try something else. I'd love to see some more tech companies go the Berkshire Hathaway route: https://berkshirehathaway.com/ Metrics for load time, readability, usability, are great. :)

This is probably a case of survivor bias. As in, the ones who have tried it have not survived.

Designs like this persist for a simple reason - it’s that people who like spending a lot of money on high end tech products like them.

Post reply on HN