Live data from Hacker News

Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

sixcolors.com

21–30 of 65 posts

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#21
post #13

Is it just me, or do these iPad reviews really seem strained? Like the author is trying really hard to love their new toy, despite the functional setbacks. Don't get me wrong, I love my iPad Pro 11 too and look forward to using it as a writing/notes device, but you'll never take my Mac away except out of my cold, dead, hands.

I believe Jason Snell is a happy iMac Pro user.

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#22
post #5
post #2

> It’s a clever design, one that pushes the center of gravity of the combined unit forward, making it more stable (and requiring less weight to counterbalance it). But the result isn’t some new, weird floating-screen category of computer. The result is a laptop. > This is a good thing. But it's a laptop that runs iOS instead of MacOS. This is not a good thing.

I think a lot of iOS developers would switch to this setup if Apple would just port Xcode.

Why do you think that?

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#23

Well up until now I was flying 100K a year and bringing my MacBook Air and my 11 iPad Pro. The laptop was for working on presentations, docs, doing demos and SSH. The iPad was for the airplane and the hotel room bed. If I can really be productive on the iPad+keyboard setup then that changes what I will be packing. After the Apple store open again I am looking forward to trying this out. One downside, no Steam games f…

When is the iPad Pro Civ6 port coming? You mean this? https://apps.apple.com/us/app/sid-meiers-civilization-vi/id1...

Maybe a specific iPad Pro version that’s not running at sub-native resolution and with lower graphic settings than the Nintendo Switch port. Civ6 on iPad was a very impressive port when released, but it hasn’t improved to take advantage of recent hardware.

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#24

Well up until now I was flying 100K a year and bringing my MacBook Air and my 11 iPad Pro. The laptop was for working on presentations, docs, doing demos and SSH. The iPad was for the airplane and the hotel room bed. If I can really be productive on the iPad+keyboard setup then that changes what I will be packing. After the Apple store open again I am looking forward to trying this out. One downside, no Steam games f…

I've got to ask - why were you carrying both?

What does one do, that the other couldn't?

Is it something basic like touch? or something slightly more complex (but evidently do-able) like a detachable keyboard?

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#25
post #13

Is it just me, or do these iPad reviews really seem strained? Like the author is trying really hard to love their new toy, despite the functional setbacks. Don't get me wrong, I love my iPad Pro 11 too and look forward to using it as a writing/notes device, but you'll never take my Mac away except out of my cold, dead, hands.

I believe Jason Snell is a happy iMac Pro user.

IMO the iMac Pro exists because they got caught with their pants down on not having a Mac Pro ready to go in time.

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#26
post #2

> It’s a clever design, one that pushes the center of gravity of the combined unit forward, making it more stable (and requiring less weight to counterbalance it). But the result isn’t some new, weird floating-screen category of computer. The result is a laptop. > This is a good thing. But it's a laptop that runs iOS instead of MacOS. This is not a good thing.

MacOS is not optimized for touchscreen. In that sense, iOS is more advanced.

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#27
post #2

> It’s a clever design, one that pushes the center of gravity of the combined unit forward, making it more stable (and requiring less weight to counterbalance it). But the result isn’t some new, weird floating-screen category of computer. The result is a laptop. > This is a good thing. But it's a laptop that runs iOS instead of MacOS. This is not a good thing.

FWIW, I hate having to wait a minute or two for email and messages to sync when I open my laptop. I also hate that app developers can roll their own software update. And I hate that apps can run in the background. If Excel on iPad worked well with the kinds of spreadsheets I use, this would be compelling for me.

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#28
post #18
post #13

Is it just me, or do these iPad reviews really seem strained? Like the author is trying really hard to love their new toy, despite the functional setbacks. Don't get me wrong, I love my iPad Pro 11 too and look forward to using it as a writing/notes device, but you'll never take my Mac away except out of my cold, dead, hands.

The iPad is great in its own right (what "functional setbacks"?), and if it's also possible to get a laptop-like experience from it, it's even better.

I know I'm not the target user for the product but not being able to write code on it is a pretty significant functional setback.

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#29
post #24

Well up until now I was flying 100K a year and bringing my MacBook Air and my 11 iPad Pro. The laptop was for working on presentations, docs, doing demos and SSH. The iPad was for the airplane and the hotel room bed. If I can really be productive on the iPad+keyboard setup then that changes what I will be packing. After the Apple store open again I am looking forward to trying this out. One downside, no Steam games f…

I've got to ask - why were you carrying both? What does one do, that the other couldn't? Is it something basic like touch? or something slightly more complex (but evidently do-able) like a detachable keyboard?

I wouldn't touch the screen on a laptop. But with the iPad the touch interface is so good that you only need a keyboard if you write a long text (or code, for which a laptop would be a better fit anyway).

Re: Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro review: Living the dream

#30
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The iPad is great in its own right (what "functional setbacks"?), and if it's also possible to get a laptop-like experience from it, it's even better.

I know I'm not the target user for the product but not being able to write code on it is a pretty significant functional setback.

The bigger issue isn’t writing code (that’s feasible, as is using git), it’s building code. You need a server to load it to or a build pipeline setup for the repository.
Post reply on HN