Live data from Hacker News

It'll soon be illegal in Europe to differentiate insurance risk by gender...

theparliament.com

1–10 of 24 posts

Re: It'll soon be illegal in Europe to differentiate insurance risk by gender...

#2
This has to be one of the most ridiculous rulings I've ever heard. Statistically, male drivers are more dangerous, so why should women now subsidise this behaviour? It's pure ideological lawmaking, designed to show how egalitarian the EU is by in fact foisting a law upon its citizens which is completely disconnected from reality.

In their attempt to achieve "equality" and "fairness," they've actually achieved neither - the two concepts are mutually exclusive in the insurance world. The whole concept of insurance, like life itself is predicated on inequality in the boolean algebraic sense of the word. It just proves how meddlesome the Eurocracy is becoming.

Besides, where does it end ? It's likely now that male pension annuities, up till now cheaper than female ones, due to the earlier death of the average male will increase too. That's not "fair," is it?

Re: It'll soon be illegal in Europe to differentiate insurance risk by gender...

#4
post #3

In the long run, I will get cheaper insurance so wont argue too much about it.

How do you figure? It's unlikely insurance companies will reduce their premiums for male drivers, they'll just increase the premiums for female customers.

Re: It'll soon be illegal in Europe to differentiate insurance risk by gender...

#5
post #2

This has to be one of the most ridiculous rulings I've ever heard. Statistically, male drivers are more dangerous, so why should women now subsidise this behaviour? It's pure ideological lawmaking, designed to show how egalitarian the EU is by in fact foisting a law upon its citizens which is completely disconnected from reality. In their attempt to achieve "equality" and "fairness," they've actually achieved neither…

Strange thing to get angry about...

Re: It'll soon be illegal in Europe to differentiate insurance risk by gender...

#6
"It is a statistical reality that young men have more accidents than women so it should be reflected in their premiums." I am so tired of seeing that line of comment thrown around. It is incorrect.

Statistically, a woman is more likely to have an accident than a man while driving. The difference lies in the severity of the accident. A woman is more likely to have a minor bump or scrape [many of which will go unclaimed via insurance as it will be cheaper than the excess], while a man will end up with far more damage which requires going through insurance.

Also, I've seen report of studies that show that while younger women are safer drivers than younger men [taking less risks]; older men are safer drivers than older women. Yet the premiums have never reflected this.

Anecdotally, I've seen more women drive badly than men too - I see vastly more women on the phone while driving than men. Then there's also the school runs, which are more likely to be women driven, where the driver will be potentially getting distracted by unruly children in the back. Again anecdotally, I've had to make a lot of dangerous manoeuvres to avoid terrible driving from women, who have then driven on oblivious to the near damage they've caused. [My dad's saying has been "women cause accidents; men have them"]

Re: It'll soon be illegal in Europe to differentiate insurance risk by gender...

#7
post #3

In the long run, I will get cheaper insurance so wont argue too much about it.

In the long run everyone's insurance premiums go up. They wont reduce male drivers premiums because they "can't" so they will increase female ones.

This ruling is terrible, I have been benefiting from having my girlfriend on my insurance for 10 years.

Re: It'll soon be illegal in Europe to differentiate insurance risk by gender...

#9
post #2

This has to be one of the most ridiculous rulings I've ever heard. Statistically, male drivers are more dangerous, so why should women now subsidise this behaviour? It's pure ideological lawmaking, designed to show how egalitarian the EU is by in fact foisting a law upon its citizens which is completely disconnected from reality. In their attempt to achieve "equality" and "fairness," they've actually achieved neither…

sorry, I don see any problem here.

If the fact that "Statistically, male drivers are more dangerous" would mean that no matter how safe am i driving, my insurance cost will be higher than my wife's insurance would prob make me feel discriminated based my gender. I want my_insurance= f(driving_experience, incident_count, my_car, my_area, etc) not my gender.

Post reply on HN