Live data from Hacker News

“Out of the Crisis” Podcast

startuplessonslearned.com

71–80 of 92 posts

Re: “Out of the Crisis” Podcast

#71
post #2

Produced this emergency podcast in short order with my friends at Breaker and LTSE. Happy to answer any questions or hear any feedback. Will have more episodes up soon

Hi Eric, what is an emergency podcast? And without knowing anything about the guests - what is say, Sam Altman, doing right now that is qualifies him in your view? In other words, why should someone listen to him?

What is an emergency podcast?

A podcast made to monetize an emergency, clearly.

Re: “Out of the Crisis” Podcast

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hi Eric, what is an emergency podcast? And without knowing anything about the guests - what is say, Sam Altman, doing right now that is qualifies him in your view? In other words, why should someone listen to him?

What is an emergency podcast? A podcast made to monetize an emergency, clearly.

[deleted]

Re: “Out of the Crisis” Podcast

#74
post #68
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let's be a bit careful here. That quote doesn't imply that anyone has heard of SA, only that he has been helping. Sometimes people help behind the scenes. Similarly, the claim about the industry is simply that it has pivoted. I have zero idea if either claim is true, but let's at least not replace them with claims that no one made. This is in the HN guidelines btw: " Please respond to the strongest plausible interpre…

The quote clearly claims he's helping the entire biotech industry, which is overstated to say the least. Also no idea why you aren't responding to the GP instead. My post is within the the guidelines, even if you choose to disagree with its point.

I totally agree with you, and I'll add that the quote also implies that the entire industry is "pivoting" to work on this effort when, no it isn't. People who have built the ability to work on viruses or with technology that is applicable are all pitching in to do their part. And they're doing it on their own prerogative, not by the "leadership" of some silicon valley tech types. Altman and all is doing good work by funding some covid responses etc, as is YC and are other tech VCs, and talk about that to whatever extent you want. But dont take credit for what the industry is doing.

Re: “Out of the Crisis” Podcast

#75
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, he's cool and his efforts admirable, but you can talk about people's accomplishments without essentially downplaying the role of others. Yes hes helping with covid, but he didn't go single handedly convince J&J to develop their vaccine platform that they developed years ago. He didn't convince gilead to develop remdesivir, something they developed years ago for hep c. He didn't convince moderna to work on rna v…

It is hurtful to say the least. Some of the real heroes are the scientists doing lab work here. And they're not being paid millions to do it. Altman has zero training in immunology and is riding the coattails of their work with this kind of phony PR.

Yeah. Take credit for the work you do (and altman isn't doing nothing, he's helping in the effort). But don't take credit for leading the entire industry. Dont take credit for things you didn't earn the credit for. And to another commenters point, attempting to qualify it with the word "helped" doesn't make it better if you're saying he "helped" with leading an entire industry pivot. He didn't. There was no silicon valley led biotech pivot. Biotech did its job and is foing its job. He's helping with covid, but not with leading the biotech industry. And hes not leading those amazing homegrown efforts like the one in smartereveryday's latest video detailing his effort to 3d print PPE in huntsville.

Leading the tech industry to pivot to work on covid though? Maybe - I could buy that. If hes been working with tech companies to join the effort.

Re: “Out of the Crisis” Podcast

#77

Since it’s not 100% obvious - the poster “eries” is a popular author and popularized the idea of lean startups, which currently has (4,636) reviews on Amazon and a 4.5 star rating: https://www.amazon.com/Lean-Startup-Entrepreneurs-Continuous...

An odd way to summarize a career, especially because amazon reviews are notoriously low quality and almost everything has 4-4.5 stars. It definitely under-sells his achievements.

Thank you, that's very kind to say.

Re: “Out of the Crisis” Podcast

#78
post #2

Produced this emergency podcast in short order with my friends at Breaker and LTSE. Happy to answer any questions or hear any feedback. Will have more episodes up soon

Hi Eric, what is an emergency podcast? And without knowing anything about the guests - what is say, Sam Altman, doing right now that is qualifies him in your view? In other words, why should someone listen to him?

I only meant we rushed it out as fast as we could in light of the emergency. It's not very produced or "professional" sounding or anything like that.

Sam has invested in a metric ton of COVID relief efforts and startups. I think we'd all be better off if more people followed his example in this respect.

Re: “Out of the Crisis” Podcast

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hi Eric, what is an emergency podcast? And without knowing anything about the guests - what is say, Sam Altman, doing right now that is qualifies him in your view? In other words, why should someone listen to him?

What is an emergency podcast? A podcast made to monetize an emergency, clearly.

Your cynicism is probably well-earned but in this case misplaced. OOTC doesn't make any money.

Re: “Out of the Crisis” Podcast

#80
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect Same reason we ask Peter Thiel or Elon Musk their thoughts on AI or politics.

Thiel and Musk have a track record of success though. Yes, they're lucky, but they also seem to be smart and capable. Cuban is a one-hit-wonder that sold a domain (and a dream) to Yahoo at the height of the dot com bubble. They don't seem particularly comparable. Edit: to respond to the comments below, no I'm not saying he's not successful, or that he's not smart. I'm only saying in tech and startup circles, he's no…

> Thiel and Musk have a track record of success though. Yes, they're lucky, but they also seem to be smart and capable.

Thinking someone has expertise in X therefore they are good source for analysis on Y is the logical fallacy I linked to above.

Contrary to what silicon valley believes, there is no such thing as being "smart" in a general sense. You can be capable in certain things, maybe you are faster to learn in others.

That doesn't mean any founder with a billion $ exit should be asked about public policy.

Post reply on HN