Live data from Hacker News

List of oldest continuously inhabited cities

en.wikipedia.org

1–10 of 224 posts

Re: List of oldest continuously inhabited cities

#4

I like how Rome is listed as 753 BCE. A lot of guess work on these dates

The age claims listed are generally disputed. Differences in opinion can result from different definitions of "city" as well as "continuous habitation" and historical evidence is often disputed. Caveats (and sources) to the validity of each claim are discussed in the "Notes" column.

Literally the introduction.

Re: List of oldest continuously inhabited cities

#6
This leaves out nomadic populations that have had continuous populations for thousands of years. E.g. in Canada, 14,000 years. Because they can't put a pin in a map. So some really old, continuously inhabited areas in the world. Blows away the named ones.

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/one-oldest-north-a...

{edit} wow who knew there were so many militant amateur archaeologists, or that the mere mention of nomads would create such a passionate backlash! Folks are getting really owly in their isolation I guess.

Re: List of oldest continuously inhabited cities

#7

This leaves out nomadic populations that have had continuous populations for thousands of years. E.g. in Canada, 14,000 years. Because they can't put a pin in a map. So some really old, continuously inhabited areas in the world. Blows away the named ones. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/one-oldest-north-a... {edit} wow who knew there were so many militant amateur archaeologists, or that the mere mention of…

Nomads, practically by definition, do not continuously inhabit cities for long periods.

Re: List of oldest continuously inhabited cities

#9
post #3

I like how Rome is listed as 753 BCE. A lot of guess work on these dates

Best estimate, until the next archaeological discovery. As long as we don't equate estimates with facts, we're good.

If you're suggesting that the 753 BC date is archaeological, you're incorrect. 753 BC is the legendary date. There's archaeological evidence of habitation on the hills of Rome earlier than that.
Post reply on HN