Live data from Hacker News

Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

bloomberg.com

511–520 of 546 posts

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#511

Note that this is for the May contract, which closes tomorrow, and anyone left with a contract then will have to actually take delivery of the physical product. Since we are in supercontango (oil storage is full, causing spot prices to be significantly lower than forward prices), I am guessing that traders who are still holding on to contracts and don’t have available storage have to unload contracts pretty quickly.…

Is delivery included in the price or is there an extra fee on top? How far can it be diverted?

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#512
post #353
post #332

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Here's June: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CLM20.NYM?p=CLM20.NYM

So tomorrow the price on say Yahoo Finance page will just show the June price of $22 or whatever it will be at opening? So it's not really a continuous price.

You can choose the see the price of the front month, or a specified month.

The former: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CL=F?p=CL=F That indeed wouldn't really be continuous because the object being priced is different.

Also I may be wrong but tomorrow on the day of expiration these contracts can still be traded.

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#513
post #295

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder if that negative int broke a bunch of code in software around the world

I work in finance. I literally ask this question of my boss today as I deal with market data. Didn't want a negative price to fuck with our systems (I've only been at the firm for 1 year, so not entirely comfortable with all our systems). Thankfully, we don't do much with futures, so we weren't too badly affected by this. Also, we don't use int's. We use proper decimal types for currency values.

Arbitrary sized decimals? How do you deal with floating point math problems?

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#514
post #306

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Son I sure hope thats not an Int. Its double, float or something else

Might be stored as an int in cents (or whatever the tick size is).

That's what I would do. Would never trust floating point numbers with something as important as currency.

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#515

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If cushing is not full, why aren't people buying at $2 a barrel now and storing for one month, selling the June contract at the same time and collecting a $20k profit per contract?

> why aren't people buying at $2 a barrel now and storing for one month, selling the June contract at the same time and collecting a $20k profit per contract? Good question. The answer is because they don't think it will be profitable. Why aren't you ?

Me, personally, because I don't even have a futures account at a broker that will let me take physical delivery, nor do I have any experience whatsoever renting tank space at the Cushing facility (which I didn't even know existed before today). But I guess the answer to my question seems to be that the cost of storing one contract worth of oil will, unbelievably, be more than $20,000 for the month.

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#517

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This was at least originally about a strange oils price war between Saudi and Russia. It just happened to coincide with the pandemic. Though I'd guess by now the pandemic adds fuel to the non-fire.

Not really , Chinese demand had dropped sharply in late January due civoid shutdowns . The original production cut discussions were influenced by that significantly. Saudi/Russia likely did not anticipate a global lockdown and decided to get into a price war to keep their absolute revenue numbers stable albeit by increasing production under reduced prices ,that has of course backfired spectacularly.

If the whole situation wasn't so serious, it would be hilarious just how badly-timed the oil price war was!

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#518

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You'll also see the economy in the fourth largest city in the US - Houston - collapse. It's not just the large energy companies here, but the entire ecosystem of companies that support the energy industry here.

you can look to calgary and alberta for a prediction of what's in store for Houston in that case!

What happened there?

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#519

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> What I don't understand is why the sudden move today? Did the longs think they had a place to put the oil on Friday but found out over the weekend they had no place to put it? Just seems like you would know what to do with the oil on Friday. Note this is not a rhetorical question, I would sincerely like an answer. Guys like myself, an ex fund manager, could be tourists in the oil market. I know I was, speculating o…

This reminds me of Brian Hunter [0] of Amaranth fame. He was on the wrong side of a huge (multi billion USD) long trade on Natural Gas. When faced with losing it all, he doubled down. Blew up Amaranth. $9B USD hedge fund blew up basically overnight. Margin calls, etc, etc. Disclaimer: I worked for the hedge fund at the time that bought Amaranth's holdings for pennies on the dollar. Was supposed to be a joint buyout w…

I recall Amaranth was recruiting on campus that week, and cancelled all interviews the very next week.

Re: Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending

#520
post #458
post #295

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder if that negative int broke a bunch of code in software around the world

Interesting math question: When we now start at a negative price tomorrow, what does a percentage change mean? Today, we have got losses >100%, unusual but obviously possible. But if price changes tomorrow from say $-10 to $10, is that again -200%? Does a change from $-10 to -$20 mean +100%? (I obviously know percentage changes are not made for this)

Hum... We can know this today with the power of Math!

But seriously, changing to -$10 to -$20 is a +100% change. It's multiplication, this is how it works. From -$10 to $10 would be a -200% change.

Obviously, only the mainstream news reports finance numbers as a percentage of change. Anybody else is only concerned about ROI.

Post reply on HN