Live data from Hacker News

Jewish Problems (2011) [pdf]

arxiv.org

11–20 of 36 posts

Re: Jewish Problems (2011) [pdf]

#11

The reason I submitted this was, incidentally, that I discovered I am Jewish. My father was the first to marry outside of the faith, so it’s apparently a long lineage. I’m not sure how to feel. Reactions range from “So what?” to “I have a culture?” I’ve been at least trying to study some history. It’s still kind of amazing it never came up once. It was almost accidental that I found out at all. (Random census questio…

I don't mean to attack your recent revelation, but my understanding was that Judaism is matrilineal, so if your mother isn't Jewish and you don't practice then you're not Jewish (unless this has made you want to convert). It's also certainly possible I don't fully understand the situation or the custom.

Re: Jewish Problems (2011) [pdf]

#12

Does anyone think this happens nowadays in interviews? I am not in favor of any kind of “standardized test” for software engineer interviews, but it seems like the practice of picking just 1 or 2 problems could easily be used to reject an undesirable candidate, under the veneer of meritocracy.

One of my colleagues loathes competitive programmers and picks much harder problems for them. His grumpy rationale is that they shouldn't have it any easier just because they do interview problems as a sport. Usually the ICPC world finalist types will still ace it since he's too dunning-kruger to judge beyond his own skill level.

Re: Jewish Problems (2011) [pdf]

#13

The reason I submitted this was, incidentally, that I discovered I am Jewish. My father was the first to marry outside of the faith, so it’s apparently a long lineage. I’m not sure how to feel. Reactions range from “So what?” to “I have a culture?” I’ve been at least trying to study some history. It’s still kind of amazing it never came up once. It was almost accidental that I found out at all. (Random census questio…

I don't mean to attack your recent revelation, but my understanding was that Judaism is matrilineal, so if your mother isn't Jewish and you don't practice then you're not Jewish (unless this has made you want to convert). It's also certainly possible I don't fully understand the situation or the custom.

That is true among the orthodox and some hardline conservatives, not reform or reconstructionists

Re: Jewish Problems (2011) [pdf]

#14
I love Tanya Khovanova! She saved my ass when I was taking and failing linear Algebra in my freshman year. Amazing TA with a kind heart, great sense of humor, and lovely Eastern European accent.

Re: Jewish Problems (2011) [pdf]

#17

The reason I submitted this was, incidentally, that I discovered I am Jewish. My father was the first to marry outside of the faith, so it’s apparently a long lineage. I’m not sure how to feel. Reactions range from “So what?” to “I have a culture?” I’ve been at least trying to study some history. It’s still kind of amazing it never came up once. It was almost accidental that I found out at all. (Random census questio…

You had a culture all along. You are American.

Re: Jewish Problems (2011) [pdf]

#19
The US instituted similar measures in the form of "literacy tests"[0] to disenfranchise non-white voters during the Jim Crow era. The questions are intentionally confusing and ambiguous, such that anyone taking them is likely to fail no matter what[1][2]. Whites were exempted from taking the test thanks to a grandfather clause (the origin of the term, incidentally, though now it usually applies to cellphone contracts) that meant you were exempt from the test if your grandfather could vote which of course was only true for well-off white citizens, or other workarounds with similar end results.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy_test

[1] https://allthatsinteresting.com/voting-literacy-test

[2] https://www.crmvet.org/info/lithome.htm

Post reply on HN