Live data from Hacker News

Hardest captcha ever?

random.irb.hr

21–30 of 125 posts

Re: Hardest captcha ever?

#21
post #7

Ha, by this logic, a large majority of the current world population aren't humans :)

Well, to be fair the easiest captcha's are easy high school level equations and (as someone else already pointed out) if you can't solve these you have no business obtaining an account for extremely high quality quantum random numbers. (I believe they provide about 7.8 or 7.9 bits of entropy per byte)

I buy my random numbers from a guy in the alley behind my building. He says they fell off a truck.

Re: Hardest captcha ever?

#23
post #11

I don't think it would be hard to do, in fact, they reverse the whole point of a CAPTCHA. A CAPTCHA is supposed to be a task that is easy for humans, but difficult for computers. High-level mathematics is difficult for humans but easy for computers. They do have some success of telling computers and humans apart, though.

Precisely the reason I wrote the very useful "human.txt" captcha: http://www.mrspeaker.net/2010/07/15/humans-txt/

Stops those pesky humans wasting precious robot bandwidth and is quite a bit harder than the Quantum Random Bit Generator captcha ;)

Re: Hardest captcha ever?

#24

Ha, by this logic, a large majority of the current world population aren't humans :)

It's just a little more targeted than the average captcha. It should weed out both bots and people you wouldn't want using the website in the first place.

Unless they become popular and the answers are too easy. Then you can guess the answer without even understanding the problem.

Re: Hardest captcha ever?

#25
As a side question, why are captchas using alphanumerics? Any reason why you can say, what is 1+1?

And flip the terms and answers for each captcha.

Is it because a person can't solve 3+8?

Re: Hardest captcha ever?

#26
post #25

As a side question, why are captchas using alphanumerics? Any reason why you can say, what is 1+1? And flip the terms and answers for each captcha. Is it because a person can't solve 3+8?

Because a computer is very good at solving basic maths questions?

All this does is simplify the captcha for machines to solve, whilst complicating it for humans (basic maths is easy for most but it's still one more logical step then 'type out the 5 letters you see'). Instead of 26 upper and lower-case characters, and often just a random string (so we can't make a best guess vs a dictionary), we now just have ten characters and maybe 2-4 mathematical operators and it must make sense (it can't be "42+-" for example).

Re: Hardest captcha ever?

#27
post #25

As a side question, why are captchas using alphanumerics? Any reason why you can say, what is 1+1? And flip the terms and answers for each captcha. Is it because a person can't solve 3+8?

Because a computer is very good at solving basic maths questions? All this does is simplify the captcha for machines to solve, whilst complicating it for humans (basic maths is easy for most but it's still one more logical step then 'type out the 5 letters you see'). Instead of 26 upper and lower-case characters, and often just a random string (so we can't make a best guess vs a dictionary), we now just have ten char…

As you stated: If computer wanted to hack it - sure it is easy enough. But I was looking for a easy way to do some verification.

I asked this because I was creating a reddit clone and wanted a captcha system. I detest the ones that exist right now.

Re: Hardest captcha ever?

#30
... at least they don't think it's secure because I used drag and drop?

People who don't understand security: stop pretending you understand security.

The reason captchas look stupid is so OCR can't run on them.

The reason captcha's aren't math is because computers are far better at math than humans.

Post reply on HN