Live data from Hacker News

GitHub is now free for teams

github.blog

11–20 of 664 posts

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#11
post #3

Seems like Github is feeling heat from GitLab/BitBucket. I guess the calculation here is that the enterprise contracts are where all the money is, and keeping smaller customers on GitHub is worth the price cut?

Personally, I have been favoring Gitlab over Github because Gitlab allows private repos on the free tier.

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#12
post #3

Seems like Github is feeling heat from GitLab/BitBucket. I guess the calculation here is that the enterprise contracts are where all the money is, and keeping smaller customers on GitHub is worth the price cut?

Yep, GitLab has had this for ages, and GitHub has gone from no private repos on free plans to private repos with only a few collaborators to this.

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#13
The pricing change appears to fall right in line with Gitlab's pricing (Free, $4/user/month, ~$20/user/month, and super expensive). I haven't managed to compare their feature matrices to see if the tiers are closely aligned, but from a glance they look similar.

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#14
post #8

Well, this is amazing! I never would have thought the Microsoft acquisition would have these kinds of results! Congrats to Nat and the GitHub team (and by extension Microsoft) for making this possible! I wonder whether this is a result of market conditions, or whether GitHub sees this is a first-to-market play of some sort, or whether it's something else. I hate to be a cynic given how much good Microsoft + GitHub ha…

> whether GitHub sees this is a first-to-market play of some sort

Could be a response to GitLab, which had a similar offering for years, including unlimited free private repos.

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#15
Very few companies can make me feel like part of their journey like Github (Cloudflare also)

They understand their target audience more than most of the companies out there. When they are making moves such as this, they explain what was behind it. I find it authentic.

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#16

This is pretty cool. Anyone have thoughts as to _why_ they’re making this move?

I suspect Microsoft wants to capture as much developer mindshare as possible and then cross-sell Azure. Reducing/eliminating entry costs for commercial grade features helps to do that.

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#17

This is pretty cool. Anyone have thoughts as to _why_ they’re making this move?

GitHub has significant vendor lock-in, so it makes sense to make it free to capture the market before a competitor gets traction.

[Speculation:]

Perhaps they've run the numbers and can figure out that they make enough money from enterprise clients and will make enough more money from the 'marketplace' being a channel for selling github integrations and addons to cover this cost of not trying to monetize through supporting teams.

It also moves a large base from 'customer' with needed support to free users which don't need the same level of support.

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#19
post #7

For those wondering "what makes it worth paying now?", GitHub briefly addresses that: Teams who need advanced features (like code owners), enterprise features (like SAML), or personalized support can upgrade to one of our paid plans.

Along with the expected limit bumps on Action execution time and package storage.

Re: GitHub is now free for teams

#20

This is pretty cool. Anyone have thoughts as to _why_ they’re making this move?

For one they have a good budget from Microsoft, secondly GitLab is good competition and thirdly I would assume they see their revenues in project.amangment and CI/CD features (tie in build workers with Azure etc.) and there is more money to make than restricting users (which can be bypassed realticely easily, while more contributors means more build hosts, means larger azure bills)
Post reply on HN