Live data from Hacker News

Someone is stealing your life (1990)

lycaeum.org

161–165 of 165 posts

Re: Someone is stealing your life (1990)

#161

The real theft is that the federal, state, and local governments take about 40 percent of your earnings in an array of taxes.

In my opinion, taxing some fraction of people's income is the best solution to the problem he's mentioning. Although I am under the impression that USA is rather reluctant to tax high earners.

well, your impression is wrong. High earners get federal, state, and locally taxed.

Re: Someone is stealing your life (1990)

#162
post #103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think couchsurfing and dumpster diving would scale to the masses.

Fair enough, but the fact that their limits are not being pushed shows that most want to work for a higher standard of living. (Or at least that is their revealed preference.)

Or they don't want to be freeloaders.

Re: Someone is stealing your life (1990)

#163
post #155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"No, but I'm waiting for it." Keep waiting then, because it's not going to happen. I would never suggest anything of the sort. It's not nearly creative enough of a solution, for one thing. "...that you've earned. I don't see a problem." Just because you don't see a problem, doesn't mean that there isn't one. So, say, a CEO who is hired to run a company and assumes no financial risk on their own for doing so has "earn…

A couple of issues... First, your CEO, it's true, did not likely put financial risk on the line to take the position obtained. But the CEO's 40x salary was put in place by the elected representatives of those who did put financial risk on the line--stockholders. If they see that salary as a good investment based on their risk why should they not be allowed to make that investment? Secondly, your point on coercion. Ye…

"But the CEO's 40x salary was put in place by the elected representatives of those who did put financial risk on the line--stockholders. If they see that salary as a good investment based on their risk why should they not be allowed to make that investment?"

This does not address the argument that rewards are being disproportionately bestowed on someone who took no risks, and arguably, produces less wealth or value on the whole than the people who actually do the work of creating and building products and services.

"Similarly if a company wants to build a product it is "forced" to hire employees and thus reach an agreement on salary. This too, by your line of reasoning, is a form of coercion."

Not at all. Coercion implies a disparity of leverage. The company has money (the means of survival, in this society) at their disposal. The employees do not, or else they wouldn't be looking for a job, would they?

In the worst case scenario the company doesn't get to make a product but still retains it's money, but the would-be employees have nothing, and are either reduced to subsistence level living, the charity of others, or simply starve.

Re: Someone is stealing your life (1990)

#164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Well, it's obviously not working for the guy. He has clearly voiced his dissatisfaction with his life, which includes the jobs that he has taken." Yes, but it does not follow that he is therefore directionless or lacks ambition. Plenty of successful doctors and lawyers have the same problem. "Someone that is doing what they love, even if it isn't making that much money, will be happy." Over simplification. I have kn…

"Plenty of successful doctors and lawyers have the same problem." Taking random jobs to put yourself through medical school is much different than taking random jobs with seemingly no direction. If he does have some ambitious life goals, he doesn't make it very apparent in this article. "I have known numerous people who loved what they where doing without being very happy about the things that came along with that."…

What on earth is this? Nothing you said follows from, or was implied by, anything in the post you're responding to. The whole thing is a big non-sequiter.

Re: Someone is stealing your life (1990)

#165
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also, take a look at the jobs he's listed as doing. That's not the career path of someone who has any direction or ambition, it's the career path of someone who takes whatever job comes along because he's out of money and desperate. I know, because I used to be that guy. My early career path looks like this: work at dad's restaurant, work at mom's jewelry store, temp agency, Cutco salesman, furniture assembler, temp…

I've been out of money and desperate at various times. It sucks. But if you point the blame only outwards, you're very likely to remain broke and desperate. Own everything. Take all responsibility for everything that happens to you, even if it wasn't your fault. This leads to some instant satisfaction in terms of feeling more in control of your life. And long term, you do a hell of a lot better. I try to own everythi…

Apparently you're choosing not to answer me - which is fine - but just know that I wasn't trolling. I was honestly curious how far you take that attitude.
Post reply on HN