Live data from Hacker News

The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

public.flourish.studio

41–50 of 148 posts

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#41

I don't understand how to deal with deniers anymore. I've tried sharing a lot of explanations/articles/videos to the "tis just a flu, bro" crowd from my friends and this convinced nobody. I guess showing even this fact/statistic would do nothing too. Is there a cure or a method to convert such dense crowd? (well, besides bashing their heads with something heavy)

There are still people denying it? Everyone I knew in that camp has been convinced.

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#42

I don't understand how to deal with deniers anymore. I've tried sharing a lot of explanations/articles/videos to the "tis just a flu, bro" crowd from my friends and this convinced nobody. I guess showing even this fact/statistic would do nothing too. Is there a cure or a method to convert such dense crowd? (well, besides bashing their heads with something heavy)

I have no opinion on this but I have read multiple times now that currently if someone dies, say on Heart Disease, and has positively tested on Covid-19, that the death cause is counted as Covid-19. So depending on how many people are really already infected it would be currently kind of impossible to die of anything but Covid-19. Maybe that's all wrong but at least that's how the deniers argue I guess. Can someone r…

There's nothing to refute. COVID-19 may cause additional heart damage: https://khn.org/news/mysterious-heart-damage-not-just-lung-t...

> “Someone who’s dying from a bad pneumonia will ultimately die because the heart stops,” said Dr. Robert Bonow, a professor of cardiology at the Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine and editor of the medical journal JAMA Cardiology. “You can’t get enough oxygen into your system and things go haywire.”

> But Bonow and many other cardiac specialists believe a COVID-19 infection could lead to damage to the heart in four or five ways. Some patients, they say, might be affected by more than one of those pathways at once.

> ...But Bonow said the damage observed in COVID-19 patients could be from the virus directly infecting the heart muscle. Initial research suggests the coronavirus attaches to certain receptors in the lungs, and those same receptors are found in heart muscle as well.

> In March, doctors from China published two studies that gave the first glimpse at how prevalent cardiac problems were among patients with COVID-19 illness. The larger of the two studies looked at 416 hospitalized patients. The researchers found that 19% showed signs of heart damage. And those who did were significantly more likely to die: 51% of those with heart damage died versus 4.5% who did not have it.

> ...That work has already resulted in changes in the way hospitals deal with the cardiac implications of COVID-19. Doctors have found that the infection can mimic a heart attack. They have taken patients to the cardiac catheterization lab to clear a suspected blockage, only to find the patient wasn’t really experiencing a heart attack but had COVID-19.

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think some of the denial is because of the lockdown, the lockdown is affecting their financials, money is more valuable for them then life or medics and some other guys so the lockdown is a mistake, the rest is a lot of number manipulating to prove why we need to remove the lockdown and make money again. I mean if you see the situation in Italy and Spain and you still say "it is just flu, nothing different then usu…

People were denying things long before the lockdown, though. I do agree there's a component of "the alternative is more convenient, so I'll believe that instead" in many people, but those should be easier to convince.

Sure, I am not saying that all denials are from people with financial interest, some just think they are expert statisticians or maybe they are part of some political group and when his favorite politicians says is just the flu then he will put all his skills to prove that is tribe is right.

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#44

I don't understand how to deal with deniers anymore. I've tried sharing a lot of explanations/articles/videos to the "tis just a flu, bro" crowd from my friends and this convinced nobody. I guess showing even this fact/statistic would do nothing too. Is there a cure or a method to convert such dense crowd? (well, besides bashing their heads with something heavy)

Actually the “flu bro” crowd has some really good points. For me, it’s impossible to ignore the inconsistency. Imagine tens of thousands of people standing before you before they perish gruesomely. These people who died of preventable things other than covid 19, are ignored by society — nobody cares. You aren’t considered a murderer for going to work with the flu (but you technically are) and you aren’t considered irresponsible for taking your kids on unnecessary car rides. When you look at the amount of death caused by unremarkable things and the amount of death caused by covid 19, they are the same. Compared to 7 billion, they are basically the same in that they are a drop in the bucket. After covid 19, will we care about all the people dying from other preventable things? No. Because this is hysteria. It’s not logic.

I think hospitals should maintain enough capacity to handle influx. I think that people should wear masks and wash their hands. But none of that changes what I wrote above. And it doesn’t change the fact that many, many people have a fetish for doom. It’s the same with global warming or the second coming of Christ — a kernel of truth or good intention becomes a mass fetish for doom and no reasonable discourse can survive.

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have no opinion on this but I have read multiple times now that currently if someone dies, say on Heart Disease, and has positively tested on Covid-19, that the death cause is counted as Covid-19. So depending on how many people are really already infected it would be currently kind of impossible to die of anything but Covid-19. Maybe that's all wrong but at least that's how the deniers argue I guess. Can someone r…

First of all, I'm not a medical professional! I think it's impossible (with the current state of technology) to determine the actual cause in patients with comorbidities. The patients died _with_ coronavirus in these statistics rather than _from_ coronavirus. Anyway, it's hard to argue with those people. But if you look at the average deaths a country has per month, and see the increase because of Covid, you should b…

Not a medical professional as well, but I can imagine a picture of a patient dying from coronavirus - say, due to the lung failure - should be quite different from the one dying from the heart disease. Shouldn't it?

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#46

I don't understand how to deal with deniers anymore. I've tried sharing a lot of explanations/articles/videos to the "tis just a flu, bro" crowd from my friends and this convinced nobody. I guess showing even this fact/statistic would do nothing too. Is there a cure or a method to convert such dense crowd? (well, besides bashing their heads with something heavy)

I have no opinion on this but I have read multiple times now that currently if someone dies, say on Heart Disease, and has positively tested on Covid-19, that the death cause is counted as Covid-19. So depending on how many people are really already infected it would be currently kind of impossible to die of anything but Covid-19. Maybe that's all wrong but at least that's how the deniers argue I guess. Can someone r…

> I have no opinion on this but I have read multiple times now that currently if someone dies, say on Heart Disease, and has positively tested on Covid-19, that the death cause is counted as Covid-19.

You have read incorrect information. Only deaths "where the disease caused or is assumed to have caused or contributed to death" [1].

Of course, there will be errors. As with any number, especially one reported daily.

BTW: there are also reasons for COVID deaths being underreported, so the bias in the number isn't really one way.

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvss/coronavirus/Alert-2-New-I...

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#47
the link to the data for the CDC does not seem to match the graph...perhaps im reading this wrong?

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm

if we're mapping based on the 2018 numbers the CDC provide then 49925 per month or ~12k per week is the cancer rate...

Diabetes is around 1700, not 200.

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#48
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have no opinion on this but I have read multiple times now that currently if someone dies, say on Heart Disease, and has positively tested on Covid-19, that the death cause is counted as Covid-19. So depending on how many people are really already infected it would be currently kind of impossible to die of anything but Covid-19. Maybe that's all wrong but at least that's how the deniers argue I guess. Can someone r…

It’d be helpful if they broke the stats down to Covid deaths in healthy people and Covid-related with comorbidity deaths.

I don't think such a distinction can usefully be made? And we don't do it for other things. "Road traffic accident with diabetes"?

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#49

I don't understand how to deal with deniers anymore. I've tried sharing a lot of explanations/articles/videos to the "tis just a flu, bro" crowd from my friends and this convinced nobody. I guess showing even this fact/statistic would do nothing too. Is there a cure or a method to convert such dense crowd? (well, besides bashing their heads with something heavy)

I think people will deny reality as long as possible. And then tiny bit more.

If you throw a rock on a dude he will deny the existance of the rock until right after the broken nose stage.

Re: The leading cause of death in the US on Apr 6 was Covid-19

#50

I don't understand how to deal with deniers anymore. I've tried sharing a lot of explanations/articles/videos to the "tis just a flu, bro" crowd from my friends and this convinced nobody. I guess showing even this fact/statistic would do nothing too. Is there a cure or a method to convert such dense crowd? (well, besides bashing their heads with something heavy)

"tis just a flu" is probably the least harmful of the lot.

There are fairly influential figures out there pushing far more dangerous stories. The virus was manufactured by Bill Gates in order to push a vaccine that contains a tracking microchip. The virus being caused by 5g is another one.

For those, I just don't have a clue how to deal with.

Post reply on HN