Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

github.com

51–60 of 109 posts

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#51
post #26

> If you Google "Piratebay", the first search result is a fake "thepirate-bay.org" (with a dash) but the Wikipedia article lists the right one. — shpx How interesting. Bing doesn't do this, which leads me to believe it's not a matter of legality. Is Google simply electing to self-censor results that it'd prefer it's used not to know about? Strange move, especially given the alternative Google does index is almost def…

Google does list proper pirating sites! At the bottom of the page click on the DMCA complaint, you'll find all the URLs you shouldn't ever, never ever, click on~

Whats funny and ironic is that this actually makes finding pirated content much easier since only actual sites that contain pirated content are the ones that will be listed on DMCA complaint list

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#53

There's a risk of phishing by editing Wikipedia articles if the plugin gets popular. Perhaps it's useful to crosscheck the current URL against the 24-hour earlier and 48-hour earlier versions of the same article. Crosscheck back in time, not back in revision, since one can spam the history by making a lot of edits.

Nice idea! Maybe should involve some randomised offsets so it can't just be planned ahead of time

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google does list proper pirating sites! At the bottom of the page click on the DMCA complaint, you'll find all the URLs you shouldn't ever, never ever, click on~

Whats funny and ironic is that this actually makes finding pirated content much easier since only actual sites that contain pirated content are the ones that will be listed on DMCA complaint list

Yes I wonder if these URLs have to be made public by law in DMCA notices.

I assume that, if they legally could, they wouldn't show you anything

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google does list proper pirating sites! At the bottom of the page click on the DMCA complaint, you'll find all the URLs you shouldn't ever, never ever, click on~

Whats funny and ironic is that this actually makes finding pirated content much easier since only actual sites that contain pirated content are the ones that will be listed on DMCA complaint list

In recent years it is less easy, as content owners are now reporting huge batches of URLs in one complaint, so finding what you are looking for in this mass is much harder. They also often report fake downloads and scam websites in DCMA complaints.

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#56

There's a risk of phishing by editing Wikipedia articles if the plugin gets popular. Perhaps it's useful to crosscheck the current URL against the 24-hour earlier and 48-hour earlier versions of the same article. Crosscheck back in time, not back in revision, since one can spam the history by making a lot of edits.

And what would you do if there was a difference?

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#57

There's a risk of phishing by editing Wikipedia articles if the plugin gets popular. Perhaps it's useful to crosscheck the current URL against the 24-hour earlier and 48-hour earlier versions of the same article. Crosscheck back in time, not back in revision, since one can spam the history by making a lot of edits.

And what would you do if there was a difference?

Return an error code. Also, since the DNS protocol allows ancillary informations, perhaps return additional informations in fields that would seem fit, else in comments.

Edit: this is not DNS over wikipedia. As other pointed out, there is no DNS involved in the linked artifact. One option would be to show alternatives with dates and let user choose.

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google does list proper pirating sites! At the bottom of the page click on the DMCA complaint, you'll find all the URLs you shouldn't ever, never ever, click on~

Whats funny and ironic is that this actually makes finding pirated content much easier since only actual sites that contain pirated content are the ones that will be listed on DMCA complaint list

Barbara again. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#59
post #18

Pretty neat! Similarly, I often use Wikipedia to find translations for specific technical terms that aren't in bilingual dictionaries or Google Translate. If you go to a wiki page about a term, there are usually many links on the sidebar to versions in other languages, which are usually titled with the canonical term in that language.

I found this to be a great method too. Especially for topics which I have been educated on in my mother tongue in high school. I know the term in Czech but I'd be unsure about the direct translation.

Re: Show HN: DNS over Wikipedia

#60
I created whereisscihub.now.sh a while ago for exactly this purpose (but limited to the subset of Sci-Hub, of course, and it used Wikidata as its data source). It has since been taken down by Now.sh.

Just as a heads-up of what you could expect to see happening :)

Post reply on HN