Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

IPhone Needs a New Home

teehanlax.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

31–40 of 77 posts

Re: IPhone Needs a New Home

#31

Post by jasongullickson »

Tyrannosaurs wrote: post #30

Why are people obsessed with weather widgets? In that small an amount of space you can basically get today's weather which I can see by looking out of the window which generally makes it a bit useless really. Not saying that I wouldn't like a better notification screen on the iPhone - I really would - just that all weather widgets do to my mind is add a bit of graphical sugar but with no great purpose. Or am I missin…

In Wisconsin you need all the help you can get (don't like the weather? ...wait five minutes).

Re: IPhone Needs a New Home

#32

Post by Tyrannosaurs »

jasongullickson wrote: post #31
Tyrannosaurs wrote: post #30

Why are people obsessed with weather widgets? In that small an amount of space you can basically get today's weather which I can see by looking out of the window which generally makes it a bit useless really. Not saying that I wouldn't like a better notification screen on the iPhone - I really would - just that all weather widgets do to my mind is add a bit of graphical sugar but with no great purpose. Or am I missin…

In Wisconsin you need all the help you can get (don't like the weather? ...wait five minutes).

But that's even worse. How is one icon meant to sum up somewhere that changeable?

Re: IPhone Needs a New Home

#33

Post by jasongullickson »

This is very nice, don't get me wrong, but I have to wonder if there is a good design reason that Apple didn't go this direction in the first place.

There have been several mobile devices which used the "daily agenda" format for the home screen (my old iPaq comes to mind: http://www.bestezonlinestore.com/images/T/PDA1391SL-304.jpg) and while it intrinsically seems like a good idea I wonder why they chose not to go that way?

Re: IPhone Needs a New Home

#34

Post by jasongullickson »

Tyrannosaurs wrote: post #32
jasongullickson wrote: post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In Wisconsin you need all the help you can get (don't like the weather? ...wait five minutes).

But that's even worse. How is one icon meant to sum up somewhere that changeable?

Current temp is the key one, which can vary widely throughout the day, is hard to tell by looking out the window and has the most impact on what you put on before you head out the door :)

Re: IPhone Needs a New Home

#35

Post by mbreese »

Tyrannosaurs wrote: post #30

Why are people obsessed with weather widgets? In that small an amount of space you can basically get today's weather which I can see by looking out of the window which generally makes it a bit useless really. Not saying that I wouldn't like a better notification screen on the iPhone - I really would - just that all weather widgets do to my mind is add a bit of graphical sugar but with no great purpose. Or am I missin…

> Does everyone else live in a bunker

Or work in an office without a window? Or live somewhere where it can be sunny outside, but still need to know if you need to take a jacket to lunch?

Re: IPhone Needs a New Home

#37

Post by Tyrannosaurs »

jasongullickson wrote: post #34
Tyrannosaurs wrote: post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But that's even worse. How is one icon meant to sum up somewhere that changeable?

Current temp is the key one, which can vary widely throughout the day, is hard to tell by looking out the window and has the most impact on what you put on before you head out the door :)

Which would be great if it were something resembling the current temp but on all the weather apps I've seen the best you'll get is a weather forecaster's prediction (nothing actual) and the best accuracy is three hours.

Maybe that's just the UK and the US is getting something more accurate but I'm guessing not.

Re: IPhone Needs a New Home

#39

Post by runjake »

I'd like to point out this blog post is from mid-2009.

I initially thought the screenshot was a LockInfo theme. In any case, such an app already exists, and has for quite a while. There are also plugins for RSS, Things & Appigo tasks,iOS notifications etc.It's very themeable, as well.

The only hitch? Your iOS device needs to be jailbroken, due to Apple's limitations.

The author's LockInfo home page is pretty lacking but he spends a lot of time hacking on LI and you can follow his progress via his Twitter account, @stimpy5050

Edit: Oops, the LockInfo page is: http://david.ashman.com/lockinfo/

Re: IPhone Needs a New Home

#40

Post by Tyrannosaurs »

yoda_sl wrote: post #19
tuhin wrote: post #12

On a sidenote: Sebastian (@cocoia) posted a great article on the problem of notifications the other day: http://blog.cocoia.com/2011/notify/

I believe there is a good chance that Apple will be improving the notification system in iOS since many months ago they hired the UI lead engineer from webOS that apparently came up with the notification system for Palm (now HP) webOS. I have used it a couple times and it was really elegant and not intrusive. So I will expect Apple to get something fresh for iOS 5. And who knows they may show some feature of iOS at t…

My guess is that they've hired a good designer who happened to work on the notifications feature, rather than hiring some sort of "notifications" specialist.

You hire someone with a view to them working with you for years and I don't think notifications is that big a deal that you'd bring in someone specific to do it.

At least fingers crossed that's it because it would be great to see something in iOS5.

Post reply on HN