Live data from Hacker News

Asking Questions

aaronkharris.com

11–20 of 22 posts

Re: Asking Questions

#11
One thing to add on top of this, adults have time limits.

I have no problem asking questions, but if there are only a couple minutes left in a meeting, I'm probably not going to ask if it's ultimately not a big deal.

Related to this, meetings can also have "wrong" questions. If it's not pertinent to the majority of the audience, it might be the wrong time to ask the question, making it a wrong question.

Re: Asking Questions

#12
I've realized that sometimes when I ask a question I'm worried about seeming dumb. Maybe in that moment it's true, maybe not. Often you appear more thoughtful and engaged. Either way, for the rest of the conversation you'll probably seem smarter than you otherwise would. Continuing without understanding, you're way more likely to say something stupid because you didn't understand that thing two minutes ago. But if you retain mastery throughout, even though it may take some questioning to keep on top of things, you end up able to keep up and contribute better. Recognizing that, and that people just like engaged listeners, has helped me ask "dumb" questions more easily.

Re: Asking Questions

#13
The problem is we live in an "RTFM" culture, where people find it necessary to present all the things they've considered and tried prior to asking the question, so that they can be taken seriously and not just get an "RTFM" as the first response to their question. Yes, it would be easier if they could just ask their question without their motives being questioned, but that's not how our system works.

Re: Asking Questions

#14

Interesting. Albert Einstein famously said his child-like curiosity is what led him to theorise about space-time continuum [0]. He thought, a child-like inquisitiveness was key to what he did [1]. On asking questions, he said: " Most teachers waste their time by asking questions that are intended to discover what a pupil does not know, whereas the true art of questioning is to discover what the pupil does know or is…

I've often thought about Einstein's thought experiments for this very reason.

Why not think about rays of light as if you were traveling next to them in a train? It seems so simple, but no one else had asked that question before.

Re: Asking Questions

#15

The problem is we live in an "RTFM" culture, where people find it necessary to present all the things they've considered and tried prior to asking the question, so that they can be taken seriously and not just get an "RTFM" as the first response to their question. Yes, it would be easier if they could just ask their question without their motives being questioned, but that's not how our system works.

Before reading TFA, I was expecting more anti-RTFM advice. So I was surprised by the focus on asking childlike questions.

I tend to ask childlike questions, but I follow up with explanation of what I've tried, and RTFM evidence.

Re: Asking Questions

#16

Interesting. Albert Einstein famously said his child-like curiosity is what led him to theorise about space-time continuum [0]. He thought, a child-like inquisitiveness was key to what he did [1]. On asking questions, he said: " Most teachers waste their time by asking questions that are intended to discover what a pupil does not know, whereas the true art of questioning is to discover what the pupil does know or is…

There's a dark side to childlike questions. I've seen presenters at seminars destroyed by seemingly innocent questions. Also deponents, for that matter.

Re: Asking Questions

#17
> At the same time, adult questions get longer and longer. Most of this length isn’t important for the question, it is meant to prevent the audience from thinking the questioner is stupid.

On the contrary, I do it to prevent people from wasting the first 5 minutes of their explanation with basics that I already know, or simplistic models that don't fully explain my observations.

My dad once told me "Education is the process of lying less and less". Kids are OK with a kid-level model because it explains everything they see. I need to preempt answers with 3 or 4 observations I have which aren't explained by the kid-level model.

Re: Asking Questions

#18
"The questions are meant to prove points, not produce knowledge" = so true.

"I noticed, as well, that conversations in which I ask simpler questions are more enjoyable and more interesting. These conversations lead to new ideas and better plans." :)

"The way I’m working on this is to stop myself each time I’m about to ask a question and figure out what I actually want to know, and then see if I can just ask that specific question in no more than a single simple sentence."= great technique!

Re: Asking Questions

#19

The problem is we live in an "RTFM" culture, where people find it necessary to present all the things they've considered and tried prior to asking the question, so that they can be taken seriously and not just get an "RTFM" as the first response to their question. Yes, it would be easier if they could just ask their question without their motives being questioned, but that's not how our system works.

RTFM is necessary because asking a question is cheaper than answering it. People ask a lot of questions they could trivially answer themselves, at the detriment of the community.

I moderate a community for a European capital. Without an RTFM policy, we'd spend our days retyping the same answers you could find with a Google search: what to do on a trip there, where to print documents, how to pay a public transit fine etc.

Re: Asking Questions

#20
I love it! Thanks for sharing, what are some of the questions that triggered that article?

I've personally found it helpful to build a circle of friends/founders who I can ask those questions openly - truth is in most investors or even customers meeting asking the basic questions often does more harm than good.

Post reply on HN