Live data from Hacker News

Top VPNs recording users, potentially leaking data when visiting their websites

vpnpro.com

11–20 of 61 posts

Re: Top VPNs recording users, potentially leaking data when visiting their websites

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

actually much easier than you'd think https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/05/how-to-build-your-ow...

Thanks for the link. let me quickly check it out

Even easier setup:

https://github.com/pivpn/pivpn

Wireguard is faster & easier to set up for mobile devices.

Re: Top VPNs recording users, potentially leaking data when visiting their websites

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sure they really care about your "privacy" -- as long as they can track you and up their profits so, in total: a regular business

Any third party will behave this way. This is the behavior of businesses that need to increase their effectiveness. of course, if you want "absolute" privacy and security, NONE of these VPN companies will fit the bill

> Any third party will behave this way. This is the behavior of businesses that need to increase their effectiveness.

It's really not the "third parties" to blame here for the most part. You can make a viable business from selling a VPN service in exchange for money with a contractual requirement that you be respecting privacy in particular ways, so that you can actually get in trouble for not doing it.

But when Shady VPN Corp. starts offering the "same" service for "free" under a different contract because they're logging everything and selling your data, and then all the customers go over there because who doesn't like a free lunch, whose fault is that really?

Re: Top VPNs recording users, potentially leaking data when visiting their websites

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any third party will behave this way. This is the behavior of businesses that need to increase their effectiveness. of course, if you want "absolute" privacy and security, NONE of these VPN companies will fit the bill

> Any third party will behave this way. This is the behavior of businesses that need to increase their effectiveness. It's really not the "third parties" to blame here for the most part. You can make a viable business from selling a VPN service in exchange for money with a contractual requirement that you be respecting privacy in particular ways, so that you can actually get in trouble for not doing it. But when Shad…

I hope that, by now, with all the research coming out about that, that people would have stopped using free VPNs by now. it's more than likely a big hustle to do something shady

Re: Top VPNs recording users, potentially leaking data when visiting their websites

#18
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for the link. let me quickly check it out

Even easier setup: https://github.com/pivpn/pivpn Wireguard is faster & easier to set up for mobile devices.

awesome resource

Re: Top VPNs recording users, potentially leaking data when visiting their websites

#19
Maybe it's just me, but it feels like this is trying to scare people into thinking that the VPNs mentioned are doing this tracking on the sites you visit while using their VPN, when it's really only about the VPN's own website (which people usually visit only when they sign up). It doesn't explicitly say the tracking is happening while using the VPNs in question, but I would bet a large portion of readers assume that's what they're saying.

It really doesn't bother me if a VPN company uses trackers and other tools to optimize their own website, other than the fact that some third parties may have good reason to believe that a visitor uses a VPN if the person visited the VPN's website. That says nothing (or very little) about how private you are when actually using the VPN.

Post reply on HN