Live data from Hacker News

Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

decrypt.co

21–30 of 41 posts

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#21
post #4

Viral Research Firm? I thought F@H was run out of Stanford University. Edit: it's run out of Washington University (St. Louis School of Medicine) so it's definitely neither a firm nor viral. Mods should change the title.

It was run out of Stanford until 2019 according to Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folding@home

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#22

There was a recent HN discussion on whether this kind of approach has ever produced an effective treatment for anything. I believe the answer was Never, but lots of papers have been published . Assuming that's the case, I don't put much stock in this giving us a means of fighting the pandemic.

Well science goes frutstratingly slowly, especially in these fields. According to wikipedia the project has helped in 118 papers.

The idea of the single scientist singlehandedly solving everything is mostly a myth. Most of the time, people rely on hundreds of previous papers before making their own contribution. Taken together, all the minimal steps make a significant leap.

Folding@home can very well be part of this effort.

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#23

There was a recent HN discussion on whether this kind of approach has ever produced an effective treatment for anything. I believe the answer was Never, but lots of papers have been published . Assuming that's the case, I don't put much stock in this giving us a means of fighting the pandemic.

No, its unlikely to help produce an effective treatment, at least not in a useful timeframe.

If you're considering spending a dollar or two a day on electricity to contribute to the F@H project, consider donating that amount instead. Charity Navigator has a good list of well regarded charities that are working on covid-19 response: https://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=content.view&...

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#24
post #8

Does this project have enough promise compared to its external cost? I imagine that’s a lot of energy usage.

Better than bitcoin!

and you can still earn crypto from folding: https://curecoin.net/

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#26
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This can be also because they're having trouble creating GPU workloads fast enough

Or because they don’t tell you how to troubleshoot when the GPU is not enabled.

I have my gpus enabled and they're often sitting idle but also sometimes doing work.

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#27
post #19
post #11

I wish they would spend five minutes documenting how to use the GPU on Ubuntu. My 1080ti is just sitting idle while my CPU is busy folding. Any instructions I came across said something like “make sure you have the libraries” but then failed to describe even at a high level how to locate and install those libraries. Last time I installed any CUDA libraries it involved adding an Nvidia repo or something. Edit: I’d be…

I followed every instruction to configure ROCM and OpenCL in Ubuntu 18 with my Vega 56 card. All the samples and such work but Folding@Home refuses to believe its there. It might be nice if someone at FAH actually tried using it on Linux. I would also like a FAQ.

Useful documentation would also be good.

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#28

There was a recent HN discussion on whether this kind of approach has ever produced an effective treatment for anything. I believe the answer was Never, but lots of papers have been published . Assuming that's the case, I don't put much stock in this giving us a means of fighting the pandemic.

This is a rather cynical take. It's hard to know the results of basic research on future therapies. Is it likely that this one project is going to find the smoking gun cure when there's hundreds of teams around the world trying all sorts of alternative approaches for medication and vaccines? No. But is this contributing to the sum of human knowledge about the virus? Yes.

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#29
post #4

Viral Research Firm? I thought F@H was run out of Stanford University. Edit: it's run out of Washington University (St. Louis School of Medicine) so it's definitely neither a firm nor viral. Mods should change the title.

Yeah, the title is pretty terrible. CPU power? GPUs contribute far more to the project.

Re: Folding@home now has 400k users fighting coronavirus

#30
So is someone sitting there, monitoring the results of this C19 folding operation as they come in and then when they see exactly the right result they shout eureka! and dance around the room? Then they shout "Get this to the lab, stat!" After which the lab starts churning out thousands of vials of antidote and everyone gets cured?
Post reply on HN