Live data from Hacker News

New York City Weighs Turning Hotels into Hospitals

wsj.com

11–20 of 111 posts

Re: New York City Weighs Turning Hotels into Hospitals

#11
post #5

Hospitals rely on 100% outside. Meaning they don't recycle existing air already circulated. Pretty sure hotels don't have that kind of HVAC.

Pretty sure we're not going to find perfect solutions, only usable ones.

Perhaps filters can be jury-rigged on the vents. Maybe you only staff them with people who've already survived. Maybe you turn off the HVAC and open up the windows. Maybe it's the last resort option.

Re: New York City Weighs Turning Hotels into Hospitals

#12
post #4

Cruise ships aren't bad options either. I hear they're a bit underutilized

I like the spirit of the idea (keeping them away from others), but other than that, it's not a wise idea:

>Keeping all the passengers on board instead of letting them disembark on land is a strategy that can backfire, however, according to experts, because the ventilation systems and close quarters of cruise ships make them ideal places for illness to jump from one person to the next.

>“They’re not designed as quarantine facilities, to put it mildly,” said Don Milton, an epidemiologist with the University of Maryland.

>Milton, who studies the spread of virus particles in the air, said recirculating air on a cruise ship’s ventilation system, along with people living in close quarters and in communal settings, make the vessels vulnerable to the spread of infection.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/cruises/2020/03/07/cor...

Re: New York City Weighs Turning Hotels into Hospitals

#13
That sounds like a good idea.

I hope one thing comes out of this pandemic: that our governments, local and federal, stockpile portable tent hospitals and equipment that can be put in place quickly for future problems. I doubt this will happen in the USA, but that is what I hope happens. I think health infrastructure is part of national security and should receive appropriate resources.

Re: New York City Weighs Turning Hotels into Hospitals

#14
post #5

Hospitals rely on 100% outside. Meaning they don't recycle existing air already circulated. Pretty sure hotels don't have that kind of HVAC.

I wonder if NYC hotels can do this but a lot newer HVAC system allow changing the percentage of outside air. Its advantageous for varies reasons (energy consumption, etc) to use partial recycle air but I wouldn't be surprised if certain builds have 100% outside air capabilities.

Re: New York City Weighs Turning Hotels into Hospitals

#15
post #10

All preparing us for the asteroid hit next month... Hotels are now hospitals, Walmart parking lots are make-shift triage centers, military and national guard in every corner, people at home, kids out of school, no flights, empty air fields, workplaces are fully distributed with no central offices... I would do exactly that if I knew an asteroid was coming. People can relate to a "flu", not a direct hit... https://www…

Interesting daydream, but why would any of that matter with an asteroid hitting the earth? It doesn't make sense.

Re: New York City Weighs Turning Hotels into Hospitals

#18
post #12
post #4

Cruise ships aren't bad options either. I hear they're a bit underutilized

I like the spirit of the idea (keeping them away from others), but other than that, it's not a wise idea: >Keeping all the passengers on board instead of letting them disembark on land is a strategy that can backfire, however, according to experts, because the ventilation systems and close quarters of cruise ships make them ideal places for illness to jump from one person to the next. >“They’re not designed as quaran…

I think the parent meant using them as mobile quarantine/treatment centers for confirmed cases.
Post reply on HN