Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

streetread.com

11–20 of 98 posts

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#11
post #7

allow people to vote up some of the news stories, and have the main page display the popular stories.

I considered having this as a feature but didn't for two reasons. Since this is geared towards the investment community, I felt most serious investors don't care about community and what others think, and last, what's popular to some may not even be relevant to others in this industry.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#12
Solid idea, but the one problem I noticed right away is that the site does not currently load news. "Error loading news. Please try again or contact support." Here are two other issues I think you should look at:

UI issue: When I click on a stock, I get the stock quote and information on the right side just fine. However, it does not say anywhere the name of the company. I think that putting the company name above the stock quote on the right frame would be useful.

External links: When linking to an external site (such as Google Finance) "Open in a new Window" does not work for me. Also, the bookmarks link is a bit confusing; it shows a few icons (like del.icio.us) and one could think that clicking on a part of that bookmarks icon would be linking to that particular service. Finally, the top bar (the Streetread part) seems to blend into the external page at times; maybe use part of the dark blue header in the design of the external top bar?

Overall, I think that this is a great service so far, good work!

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#13
post #9
post #5

Why do I have to be logged in to edit the list of stocks?

If you were to change the stocks without being logged in, once you navigate away from the site, the symbols would be lost, and I felt users might be annoyed by that. Registering literally takes seconds too.

You can temporarily store the user's list in a cookie if they're not logged in.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#14
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you were to change the stocks without being logged in, once you navigate away from the site, the symbols would be lost, and I felt users might be annoyed by that. Registering literally takes seconds too.

Yes, but that is seconds users do not want to take. I'd advice letting them edit it, but have a small notification at the top letting them know that it will be lost without an account. Cookies are unreliable but they may help.

That's a very good idea and I'll definitely consider implementing that soon. Thanks.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#16

Solid idea, but the one problem I noticed right away is that the site does not currently load news. "Error loading news. Please try again or contact support." Here are two other issues I think you should look at: UI issue: When I click on a stock, I get the stock quote and information on the right side just fine. However, it does not say anywhere the name of the company. I think that putting the company name above th…

What browser/os are you using?

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#17
post #11
post #7

allow people to vote up some of the news stories, and have the main page display the popular stories.

I considered having this as a feature but didn't for two reasons. Since this is geared towards the investment community, I felt most serious investors don't care about community and what others think, and last, what's popular to some may not even be relevant to others in this industry.

good point. but the main page looks barren, to me. SOMEthing needs to go there, imo.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#18
Good concept, but could be implemented better. Definitely make the logo sizes at the top the same size. Don't stretch or anything, but leave grayspace between them. It just looks cluttered right now.

Center the instructions vertically as to not have so much empty space. Although it will still be the same amount, it will look like less.

How about multithreading? As in when you click on one it becomes active, allowing you to have more than one news source active at a time. Weave the news entries by date and color code them (not everything, but maybe a color code a symbol at the start).

If you implement the above, how about having categories? Sports, world and business, etc? The possibility for sports from the New York Times and International Business from Reuters would be a major feature.

Like I said, great idea. Some more work would make it amazing.

*edit: I like my scrollbar. I have come to expect my scrollbar from websites. Give me my scrollbar back, it acts as a visual clue to where I am and it allows for intuitive navigation. Don't force me to use your system.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#19
post #16

Solid idea, but the one problem I noticed right away is that the site does not currently load news. "Error loading news. Please try again or contact support." Here are two other issues I think you should look at: UI issue: When I click on a stock, I get the stock quote and information on the right side just fine. However, it does not say anywhere the name of the company. I think that putting the company name above th…

What browser/os are you using?

Firefox 2 and Windows XP. I am behind a decently strict company firewall as well.

Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)

#20
Firefox 3 on an Intel Macbook running Leopard: the scrolling is completely broken. If I click on a stock, the new loaded data just scrolls wildly. Further scrolling using the scroll wheel seems to just send the page to various locations at random.

Seems like an interesting idea, but there's no way I'd use it in this state.

Post reply on HN