Live data from Hacker News

Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

theverge.com

21–30 of 210 posts

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#21
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not every FB employee is a highly paid software engineer who has savings to weather a multi-month public health crisis.

then not everyone should get it

That’s certainly a valid opinion. Nonetheless, giving the bonus to everyone does no harm, looks better in terms of PR, doesn’t foster an “us and them” mentality, and is probably easier to administer than just giving it to select employees. The difference on the bottom line is a rounding error.

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#22

Damn, say what you will about FB, that's a gesture and a half.

Why? It's a fraction of a percent of most employees' annual pay, which presumably they are still receiving. If anything, it's like giving everyone a tiny bonus for some PR. At least that's how I read it. If they gave that money to contractors, that would actually be a gesture of good will. Honestly I feel like they'd be better off only giving it to contractors and ignoring their employees, who are already extremely w…

If you read the article you will see they are also giving every essentially a full bonus irrespective of performance. Depending on individual agreements that could be a significant sum so it's definitely not a fraction of a percent of anybody's annual pay.

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#23
post #19
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, but in the Bay Area it's not uncommon to have household workers – cleaners, nannies, etc. Something like this would allow people to continue to pay those folks who are not working now, and have no other form of income or assistance. It would help the FB workers, because they're going to be doing that work on top of their normal jobs. Not saying that's what people will use the money for, but it ups the odds at le…

So the classic argument of 'trickle down economics'. I"d wager that that $1k will just go into their bank account, like their bonus would.

Facebook is not the government.

They are doing something positive in their locus of control. And of course people are upset about it because... reasons.

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#24
post #3

> It’s not clear if Facebook will also give a bonus to contractors who are content moderators. Let me guess: it doesn't. Have Facebook contractors been given the right to work from home yet?

By definition, don't all contractors have to generally not work from an office? Otherwise it's very easy to deem them full-time employees and they are entitled to benefits. Not sure of Facebook's specific situation or what roles they are contracting, but I'd imagine most of them aren't at HQ.

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#26

Damn, say what you will about FB, that's a gesture and a half.

Why? It's a fraction of a percent of most employees' annual pay, which presumably they are still receiving. If anything, it's like giving everyone a tiny bonus for some PR. At least that's how I read it. If they gave that money to contractors, that would actually be a gesture of good will. Honestly I feel like they'd be better off only giving it to contractors and ignoring their employees, who are already extremely w…

pleasing cynics is like pissing outside on a windy day when you have to go - damned if you do and damned if you don't.

read the article - they're giving out 1k to each of the 45k employees. i'm sorry for the contractors (i don't know if it includes them) but that's still a small city's worth of people. they're also guaranteeing bonuses for the next two quarters for all of those people. i don't care about fb but the move definitely clears the bar for nice gesture even if it's not nobel peace prize worthy.

like how about we just rejoice in one small nice thing instead of taking meaningless cynical potshots?

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#27
post #7

> It’s not clear if Facebook will also give a bonus to contractors who are content moderators. It seems like they are the most at-risk, considering they are not paid as much as all the developers.

I work with some of them in Greece. They have monthly contract extensions and are paid by day, no sick leave. Most offices have skeleton crew now. Technically it is not fb, but agency who employs them.

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#28
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe they think all their employees will spend an extra $1000 they wouldn't have otherwise. Some of it might be spent keeping local business running for a week? I don't know.

arent local businesses closing?

Not sure about the Bay Area but a lot of restaurants are switching to delivery only (inc. the kind of places that never did delivery in the first place) so this money could go to them. Money can also be spent buying things in advance - for example concert tickets for late in the year. This will help performers/venues remain afloat in the meantime. Also - for local businesses that weather the storm, these people now have an extra $1k + extra bonus that they can spend to help get them back to black sooner.

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#29
post #20

Not sure why there are so many negative comments. This is a win and sets a great example that hopefully other companies can follow. Yes, software engineers at FB have probably no (or very little) problem working from home and get their $200k salary, but this is a win regardless.

> Not sure why there are so many negative comments

It’s seen as rearranging deck chairs on the titanic. the median compensation for a Facebook employee is $228,651 That’s not a group facing huge financial issues which 1k is going to do much about.

I am not saying it is a poor use of 45 million dollars, but I can see people viewing this as meaningless.

Re: Facebook is giving $1k to every employee

#30
post #19
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, but in the Bay Area it's not uncommon to have household workers – cleaners, nannies, etc. Something like this would allow people to continue to pay those folks who are not working now, and have no other form of income or assistance. It would help the FB workers, because they're going to be doing that work on top of their normal jobs. Not saying that's what people will use the money for, but it ups the odds at le…

So the classic argument of 'trickle down economics'. I"d wager that that $1k will just go into their bank account, like their bonus would.

(fb employee here) fwiw I've heard of a ton of people continuing to pay housekeepers, nannies, etc. - I was going to pay our house cleaner to stay home anyway, but this removes any hesitation/excuse not to. I agree it's unnecessary, but it's a nice gesture and these FANG companies have the cash in the bank to help the Bay Area weather the storm safely.
Post reply on HN