Live data from Hacker News

Ask YC: A Magazine That Publishes Blogs. Startup Potential?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 30 posts

Re: Ask YC: A Magazine That Publishes Blogs. Startup Potential?

#11
Awhile back Joel Spolsky compiled Best Software Writing I, a collection of online tech writings from other people. http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/BestSoftwareWriting.h...

It seems similar to the format you're imagining and was definitely successful from a quality standpoint. The people who read it, enjoyed reading it.

That's different than saying it was a huge commercial success or that there's so much good writing that you could fill a themed magazine each month.

Re: Ask YC: A Magazine That Publishes Blogs. Startup Potential?

#14
post #12
post #7

Make it a free daily in big cities, so the content is only 24-72 hours older than when it was blogged, and it might work.

I doubt it, but it's a cool enough idea that I'd like to see someone try.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Now

Based on this sample of one, your doubts are justified: These guys went out of business in a bit less than 1 year.

Of course, there's a lot of ways to run a paper or magazine, so maybe a different approach would have worked better. I never found Boston NOW especially interesting... it was mostly wire-service filler with a sprinkling of no-name bloggers.

Re: Ask YC: A Magazine That Publishes Blogs. Startup Potential?

#16
Thanks for the input so far, guys. I do want to ad that if I were to try something like this I would probably not publish much tech content. Tech savvy readers already get the blogs they want.

I'm thinking more along the lines of businesspeople - "Blogs for the rest of us" you could say. Is there a potential demand for blogs off of the internet?

Re: Ask YC: A Magazine That Publishes Blogs. Startup Potential?

#17
Actually, despite its, uh, antiquity, I like this idea. Let me explain.

1) Why does everyone think that they'll have trouble from blogs for republishing? It's huge extra exposure - I feel that you'll get tons of people interested.

2) Go away from publishing blog posts to stories about the bloggers (egos), about how they started their idea, features on getting started, new stories by bloggers, etc. The TOPIC is blogging, not the posts that they've written. Remember that and you have your focus.

3) It's simply not a topic covered by any major magazine

The bad -

1) Magazines are indeed dying. Ad revenues are down and continue to drop.

2) It's ironic to cover such a new media with such an old one and the irony will hit people as they read it.

3) You're going to need a good deal of money to start this up and do circulation.

Re: Ask YC: A Magazine That Publishes Blogs. Startup Potential?

#18

Actually, despite its, uh, antiquity, I like this idea. Let me explain. 1) Why does everyone think that they'll have trouble from blogs for republishing? It's huge extra exposure - I feel that you'll get tons of people interested. 2) Go away from publishing blog posts to stories about the bloggers (egos), about how they started their idea, features on getting started, new stories by bloggers, etc. The TOPIC is bloggi…

Very good points. Yes it does seem to be pretty expensive to print up the physical magazines.

I'm liking the idea of getting it in an area where the readers may not have access to the internet (specifically plane rides). If I know I'm going to be on the plane for 4 hours and I can't use my laptop for the internet, what better way to calm the panic than by having a magazine full of 10-15 or so blogs that I can read?

Re: Ask YC: A Magazine That Publishes Blogs. Startup Potential?

#20
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I doubt it, but it's a cool enough idea that I'd like to see someone try.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Now Based on this sample of one, your doubts are justified: These guys went out of business in a bit less than 1 year. Of course, there's a lot of ways to run a paper or magazine, so maybe a different approach would have worked better. I never found Boston NOW especially interesting... it was mostly wire-service filler with a sprinkling of no-name bloggers.

:) That's really funny.
Post reply on HN