Live data from Hacker News

An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

blog.pragmaticengineer.com

31–40 of 64 posts

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#31

Regarding all these alternative ways of organizing, what's wrong with a leader taking responsibility, delegating it where feasible, and selecting for team members to whom they can delegate responsibility with confidence? Taking direction or orders from a manager is only ever stressful if that manager doesn't take accountability for their decisions and directions. I'm not sure the solution to that is a new framework w…

>Team members don't need to be "heard," or need sympathy from managers, they need confidence that their leadership understands the environment they work in, takes responsibility for decisions, and gives them direction based shared competence. This is 100% the worst advice. It's a sign that you are a bad leader. There are two components of leadership. Managing up and managing down. In order to gain a leadership positi…

Can appreciate the reaction, but management and leadership aren't therapy.

There is only one component of leadership, and it is the definition: it is the effect of being followed. You can't fake it because it is an effect, not a result. It only happens with willingness in others that is the result of trust, earned through establishing legitimate authority.

Management is literally the effect of compromise between competing factors, with feedback into influencing those factors, and %80 of your effort spent on maintaining the ability to influence them.

In this sense, the difference between management and leadership is like that of a thermostat and the weather.

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#32

Regarding all these alternative ways of organizing, what's wrong with a leader taking responsibility, delegating it where feasible, and selecting for team members to whom they can delegate responsibility with confidence? Taking direction or orders from a manager is only ever stressful if that manager doesn't take accountability for their decisions and directions. I'm not sure the solution to that is a new framework w…

I would prefer less responsibility taken by now. Managers assigning all the work to themselves (im the only one competent) and then getting nothing done is the most widespread phenomena i currently see.

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#33

My first dev job saw this fad come through the department one season. It went from "Here's your feature for this week, please implement it" to "Here's your feature for this week, you're the leader for development on this! Please implement it.". I understand that middle management has basically nothing to actually do, so it invents shit like this, but it pisses us off that actually do something to have this weird chan…

Well if you're team lead now, then that comes with a title & pay bump right? If not, then management is just passing added responsibility to you without any additional risk to themselves.

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#35
Reading this article I was reminded of the book It's Your Ship, the motto used by one navy captain to empower the crew to turn around a poorly performing ship. Then I see that part of the inspiration for this post was... a book about a different navy ship.

I often think back to It's Your Ship, I'd highly recommend it.

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#36
post #19

The places I’ve worked at where “everyone is a leader” ends up with 1 person feeling adamant about something. And everyone else disagreeing, but then saying: sure whatever, we will do it that way. Nobody wants to have conflict and nobody is in charge. Leads to a lot of very bad decisions imo.

Completely agree. And the product or project is typically super chaotic.

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#37
I've switched to saying "I'd vote for XYZ".

The most empowering form of leadership is pure democracy. I'm a bit dismayed that for all of our brilliant insights and expertise, we're so quick to replicate authoritarian power structures in our careers. There are some talks by Richard Wolff on YouTube about democracy in the workplace and I'd urge everyone here to watch them.

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#38
In my experience, high-performing teams arise when every member has expertise that is acknowledged and respected by the rest of the group. As soon as you add skill+experience redundancy, performance will be hindered by jockeying to "be better than the others." If there is little growth opportunity in this skill area, it will have a much greater effect on performance as internal politics take over.

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#39
> where everyone can be a leader - and everyone would act as an owner

I suspect these are different things.

Everybody can have a sense of ownership? Sure (e.g. common goals, employee owned companies, options, etc).

If everybody is leading (at the same time), nobody is. It's good if anyone can assume leadership at any given moment, though.

Tacit leaders are more important (and respected) than explicit ones. Appointing a leader rarely works.

Re: An Engineering Team Where Everyone Is a Leader

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How about the counterargument that 10 heads are better than 1?

I'm reminded of a quote from The Office: > Look, it doesn't take a genius to know that any organization thrives when it has two leaders. Go ahead, name a country that doesn't have two presidents. A boat that set sail without two captains. Where would Catholicism be...without the Popes. Notice that throughout the article, the author is still in charge of the overall strategy, granting each lead their authority, requir…

"name a country that doesn't have two presidents". A lot of countries are run by a government with a cabinet of ministers. There's a lot of negotiation. Many decisions are collective. In fact many governments are an example of what the article is taking about.

The Catholic Church is an authoritarian organisation and that structure has caused it some extreme problems leading to its demise in many parts of the world.

That said, it is a good joke.

Post reply on HN