Live data from Hacker News

Max/MSP: A visual programming language for music and multimedia

en.wikipedia.org

1–10 of 68 posts

Re: Max/MSP: A visual programming language for music and multimedia

#5
post #4

I've used PureData a bit and found the UI rather minimalist. VCV Rack has a UI that's considerably more fun, but from a programming perspective, most modules are quirky rather than orthogonal and general-purpose. How does Max compare?

VCV Rack is firmly in the Eurorack tradition, which has an enormous amount of deliberate quirkiness to inspire experimentation and new sounds. Max is pretty a graphical programming language with a focus on signal processing, but a scope that goes considerably beyond that.

Re: Max/MSP: A visual programming language for music and multimedia

#6
If anyone's interested - I'm working on ossia score (https://ossia.io ; https://github.com/OSSIA/score) which is a bit like Max & PD, but the dataflow is integrated directly in the timeline which allows for better expressibility of evolution of time in the artwork.

Re: Max/MSP: A visual programming language for music and multimedia

#8
post #4

I've used PureData a bit and found the UI rather minimalist. VCV Rack has a UI that's considerably more fun, but from a programming perspective, most modules are quirky rather than orthogonal and general-purpose. How does Max compare?

Max and ~pd are roughly equivalent from a programming perspective. They have different ecosystems though, with a lot of overlap, but also with a bunch of differences.

Re: Max/MSP: A visual programming language for music and multimedia

#10

Opensource alternative Pure Data is also worth mentioning: https://puredata.info/

Seconding this: PureData is very good - used it throughout my second and third years of university to create soundscapes and scores. A little DSP knowledge is required to get really good, but very rewarding once you get the hang of it.

Designing Sound by Andy Farnell is a great book to learn about ~PD and sound design in general: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Designing-Sound-Press-Andy-Farnell/...

Post reply on HN