There's this story about the two shoe salesmen. The first one visited this hot climate country, and nobody was wearing any shoes. He got really depressed, said "Nobody is wearing any shoes here, goodbye" and left hurriedly with the next train. The other guy smiles arriving while looking excitedly around, and then exclaims: "Wow! Everyone is a potential customer. Nobody has even one shoe. I must set up shop immediatel…
Great metaphor, I think it's implying that bad designs could be a potential opportunity if viewed from the right perspective. If you see a bad design, that you know could be better then don't be sad, you have a business opportunity!
Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
41–50 of 64 posts
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#42If the world around you is making you angry and depressed (regardless of reasons), then perhaps consider professional help for your mental health.
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#43There's this story about the two shoe salesmen. The first one visited this hot climate country, and nobody was wearing any shoes. He got really depressed, said "Nobody is wearing any shoes here, goodbye" and left hurriedly with the next train. The other guy smiles arriving while looking excitedly around, and then exclaims: "Wow! Everyone is a potential customer. Nobody has even one shoe. I must set up shop immediatel…
I'm not sure about this parable; it reminds me of Chesterton's fence. Our optimistic salesman may be completely ignoring the fact that no one is wearing shoes because no one needs or wants to .
Now I have a name for the tendency of bad supervisors that show up and announce "Things are going to change around here!" before they have any idea why things are the way they are.
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#44I had listed examples, ranging from NYC subway gripes, double doors where one door is locked and the handles are ambiguous, cell phone gripes, google maps, windows, etc, but there is no space for it in this post. You can add a complete list as a comment. Please?!
- Dialogs that display truncated information, but aren't resizable (looking at you, Windows).
- File Open/Save dialogs that always open to the same default location, requiring the user to keep navigating to the same directory over and over.
- Information displayed in non-selectable (thus, un-copy-paste-able) form. Generally this is seen more in desktop and mobile apps vs. the web.
- Anything that changes what I type without my explicit OK. This includes IDEs with predictive completion, MS Word's on-by-default correction, and mobile devices that auto-capitalize email addresses and automatically add a space after a period...
- "Secret Question" drop-downs where none of the questions remotely apply to me
- Required fields that shouldn't be, e.g. "Company Name"
- Short length limits for site passwords. If you're limiting passwords to (let's say) twelve characters, that strongly suggests that you're storing the password in plain text on your servers (you should be storing a hash).
- Excluded punctuation characters for site passwords. This suggests that developer(s) decided "rather than expend the one-time effort to properly sanitize/escape our inputs, we thought we'd just dump the responsibility to exclude our arbitrary list of characters on the users for all time"
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#45There's this story about the two shoe salesmen. The first one visited this hot climate country, and nobody was wearing any shoes. He got really depressed, said "Nobody is wearing any shoes here, goodbye" and left hurriedly with the next train. The other guy smiles arriving while looking excitedly around, and then exclaims: "Wow! Everyone is a potential customer. Nobody has even one shoe. I must set up shop immediatel…
I'm not sure about this parable; it reminds me of Chesterton's fence. Our optimistic salesman may be completely ignoring the fact that no one is wearing shoes because no one needs or wants to .
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#46There's this story about the two shoe salesmen. The first one visited this hot climate country, and nobody was wearing any shoes. He got really depressed, said "Nobody is wearing any shoes here, goodbye" and left hurriedly with the next train. The other guy smiles arriving while looking excitedly around, and then exclaims: "Wow! Everyone is a potential customer. Nobody has even one shoe. I must set up shop immediatel…
I'm not sure about this parable; it reminds me of Chesterton's fence. Our optimistic salesman may be completely ignoring the fact that no one is wearing shoes because no one needs or wants to .
Isn't that perspective represented by the first salesman? Both are seeing the same limited data and drawing a conclusion about business potential. The second salesman may be wrong, but their optimistic view is still a possible one.
Especially since we know shoes can be plenty useful in hot climates and are 99 percent about fashion anyway.
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#47Go on a very long hike in a forested nature preserve.
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#48It can be your environment, some places are designed by people who don't care. Some places even are adversarial.
It can be you, either from lack of something (sleep, magnesium, ...). It can be you missing some understanding. Or you just don't getting that most people either don't have your attention to details, don't care, or don't want to do anything to improve their environment. It can be you not being the intended audience. It can be you not putting yourself into the intended usage.
But either way, you can choose to accept it or change it and be proactive about it and don't whine as it reinforce learned helplessness. Pick your battles. The environment is dynamic. For example try littering and see what happens. Or you can make some improvements to it. Or you can point and shame on the internet.
Giving feedback in the real world is quite easy. You can carry a pen and a stack of stickers, or a spray paint can to mark things. For example you see ambiguous handles just mark one red sticker/dot on the handle which is closed and a green dot on the handle which is open, (or do the opposite and set-up a live twitch :) )
You can write letters to the mayor. You can also notice the positive small details left by people who care, and reward them.
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#49You should first treat those bad UXs as childplays:
- Some of them might be working back then
- Some of them were patched so to accomplish other thing but accidentally render them unusable
- Some of them might be a result of rushed work due to pressure from higher ups
- Some of them are simply lost in translation due to time
Being angry and depressed is frustrating but you should redirect those energy to something more worthwhile.
If you really want to contribute, broadcast your intent. Get close to someone having authority to those stuffs with bad UX, use subtle social approach to get things done, consult to people who could yields better UX becaus there must be a better person doing it™.
As a child I used to be angry if my personal drinking bottle isn't put on the table from an exact distance between two sides of the table.
I use that energy to develop instinct to design a well-architectured software, maximizing development speed and customer satisfaction at the same time.
Re: Ask HN: Bad user experience angers and depresses me – what can I do about it?
#50BTW, SAP is hiring!
'hope that made you smile :)