Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: A Firefox extension to add latency to distracting webpages

addons.mozilla.org

11–20 of 52 posts

Re: Show HN: A Firefox extension to add latency to distracting webpages

#11
post #7

Easily disabled if you find it annoying. And if you're self disciplined enough to not turn it off, surely you're self disciplined enough to curb your browsing habits?

Not really. This sort of thing is really helpful. It's not that I am not disciplined, but rather that I need a reminder to keep myself disciplined when I surf on the web.

A small reminder.. it's easy to end up in scrolling mode.

Re: Show HN: A Firefox extension to add latency to distracting webpages

#14
Looks like an interesting extension, but unfortunately I would never install it given that "this add-on can access data for all your websites". As far as I am aware, this means it can read and record all data in all websites I visit (including emails, banks, etc) and record everything I type anywhere (including usernames and passwords).

Even if the extension's source code is available on GitHub, there is no guarantee that the code hosted at addons.mozilla.org corresponds to the same one found on GitHub; and even if I (or someone else) could verify that the code is indeed the same, and that there is nothing malicious in it right now, there is no guarantee this will still be the case in future (silent) updates.

To be clear, this is more of a criticism to Mozilla Firefox's security model, not to this particular extension.

Re: Show HN: A Firefox extension to add latency to distracting webpages

#15
post #14

Looks like an interesting extension, but unfortunately I would never install it given that "this add-on can access data for all your websites". As far as I am aware, this means it can read and record all data in all websites I visit (including emails, banks, etc) and record everything I type anywhere (including usernames and passwords). Even if the extension's source code is available on GitHub, there is no guarantee…

FTFY: To be clear, this is more a criticism of _every browser's_ security model,...

I do agree with you though. What is surprising is that technically, this should be fairly easy to solve:

- own the CI system (to make sure the sources match the built versions)

- make sources (the ones that went into build) clearly visible

- disable silent updates

Re: Show HN: A Firefox extension to add latency to distracting webpages

#16
post #14

Looks like an interesting extension, but unfortunately I would never install it given that "this add-on can access data for all your websites". As far as I am aware, this means it can read and record all data in all websites I visit (including emails, banks, etc) and record everything I type anywhere (including usernames and passwords). Even if the extension's source code is available on GitHub, there is no guarantee…

An alternative would be to throttle your network speed to like 2g with your dev tools, although this will obviously effect, say, YouTube more than HN

Re: Show HN: A Firefox extension to add latency to distracting webpages

#17
post #14

Looks like an interesting extension, but unfortunately I would never install it given that "this add-on can access data for all your websites". As far as I am aware, this means it can read and record all data in all websites I visit (including emails, banks, etc) and record everything I type anywhere (including usernames and passwords). Even if the extension's source code is available on GitHub, there is no guarantee…

+1000 times this

Extensions should be built in Mozilla's servers.

Re: Show HN: A Firefox extension to add latency to distracting webpages

#19
post #14

Looks like an interesting extension, but unfortunately I would never install it given that "this add-on can access data for all your websites". As far as I am aware, this means it can read and record all data in all websites I visit (including emails, banks, etc) and record everything I type anywhere (including usernames and passwords). Even if the extension's source code is available on GitHub, there is no guarantee…

You are incorrect. You can inspect extensions that you download to compare the source code to the github release, or even audit the specific source you have have downloaded. Please don't spread FUD.

Re: Show HN: A Firefox extension to add latency to distracting webpages

#20
post #7

Easily disabled if you find it annoying. And if you're self disciplined enough to not turn it off, surely you're self disciplined enough to curb your browsing habits?

In my /etc/hosts file, I redirect distracting websites to 0.0.0.0 to block them. There's nothing stopping me from enabling a website beyond the effort to type in sudo vim /etc/hosts, but yet I now spend a lot less time on those websites. Human psychology is funny that way.
Post reply on HN