Live data from Hacker News

Obama-Endorsed VC Program Promises 6,000 New Startups

hothardware.com

1–10 of 66 posts

Re: Obama-Endorsed VC Program Promises 6,000 New Startups

#5
So policymakers have wrecked traditional capital markets through regulations on raising capital, interest rate distortions, twisted tax policy, patent law abuse, and anti-hiring labor policy, and now they are going to "fix" VC markets for us. Thanks.

The feds can't even protect the border or catch Osama bin Laden and now they want to run some fascist incubator to give the political class even greater control over our society.

This is the first step of course. As the program grows, Congress will start creating demands like set-asides for racial groups or veterans, and it will just so happen that a phone call from a politician will seal the deal.

Re: Obama-Endorsed VC Program Promises 6,000 New Startups

#6

So policymakers have wrecked traditional capital markets through regulations on raising capital, interest rate distortions, twisted tax policy, patent law abuse, and anti-hiring labor policy, and now they are going to "fix" VC markets for us. Thanks. The feds can't even protect the border or catch Osama bin Laden and now they want to run some fascist incubator to give the political class even greater control over our…

... now they want to run some fascist incubator ...

Are you seriously calling this fascism?

Re: Obama-Endorsed VC Program Promises 6,000 New Startups

#7
post #6

So policymakers have wrecked traditional capital markets through regulations on raising capital, interest rate distortions, twisted tax policy, patent law abuse, and anti-hiring labor policy, and now they are going to "fix" VC markets for us. Thanks. The feds can't even protect the border or catch Osama bin Laden and now they want to run some fascist incubator to give the political class even greater control over our…

... now they want to run some fascist incubator ... Are you seriously calling this fascism?

From Wikipedia:

"An inherent aspect of fascist economies was economic dirigisme, meaning an economy where the government exerts strong directive influence, and effectively controls production and allocation of resources. In general, apart from the nationalizations of some industries, fascist economies were based on private property and private initiative, but these were contingent upon service to the state."

Re: Obama-Endorsed VC Program Promises 6,000 New Startups

#8
post #6

So policymakers have wrecked traditional capital markets through regulations on raising capital, interest rate distortions, twisted tax policy, patent law abuse, and anti-hiring labor policy, and now they are going to "fix" VC markets for us. Thanks. The feds can't even protect the border or catch Osama bin Laden and now they want to run some fascist incubator to give the political class even greater control over our…

... now they want to run some fascist incubator ... Are you seriously calling this fascism?

Let's call if corporatism. It means the same thing but people will whine less about the semantics.

Re: Obama-Endorsed VC Program Promises 6,000 New Startups

#9

So policymakers have wrecked traditional capital markets through regulations on raising capital, interest rate distortions, twisted tax policy, patent law abuse, and anti-hiring labor policy, and now they are going to "fix" VC markets for us. Thanks. The feds can't even protect the border or catch Osama bin Laden and now they want to run some fascist incubator to give the political class even greater control over our…

When this was first announced a couple weeks ago, I read the "fact sheet" posted. In it they talked about an emphasis on putting the money into "disadvantaged areas" and "focusing on innovative technologies like clean energy". So, your concern about investments being made more based on political pull than on merit is well founded.

Over 50 years ago an environment of heavy government regulation and anti-competitive legislation (as you describe in the first part of your post) was posited by Ayn Rand in Atlas Shrugged. The argument being that it is in politicians interest to make business hard so that businesses are beholden to politicians. She called it the "aristocracy of pull".

I like to point out that taking $2B out of the economy will prevent the creation of- in my estimation- 4,000,000 jobs over the next 10 years. The money must come from taxes or inflation, and that lowers the bottom line at the end of the year when business owners large and small are deciding whether to expand or not. The lack of expansion in the first year means the businesses lose out on the profits that would have come from it on the second year, and like compound growth the missed opportunity compounds as well.

Better to let people allocate their own resources and capital. Central planning doesn't work, and inevitably leads to the aristocracy of pull.

Re: Obama-Endorsed VC Program Promises 6,000 New Startups

#10
post #4
post #2

Yeah, with the government involved, there won't be any false incentives...

So you think the government might use their power to affect who gets the money and to try to buy influence and votes? Preposterous!

Not only that, but he implies that, if they're successful, this incentivizes making things worse for regular businesses so that they are more beholden to their "representatives".

Absurd, I know!

Post reply on HN