Live data from Hacker News

List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

jongales.com

11–20 of 49 posts

Re: List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

#11
post #8
post #6

What is wrong with Livestrong.com? Isn't that for bike races and raising money for cancer?

You'd think, but it's actually a Demand Media content farm. Livestrong.org is what you're probably thinking of (Lance's foundation website). http://www.demandstudios.com/health-writing-jobs.html

I recall reading that Armstrong's an investor in the content farm in question, to boot.

(Give a bit of a new twist to all those yellow wrist bands, doesn't it?)

Re: List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

#12
post #5
post #3

I assume that when you block a site, Google are sent the search term as well as the site you blocked. Assuming that this is the case, it isn't very helpful to search for 'mahalo.com' and then block mahalo.com. What do you think should rank higher than mahalo.com for the term mahalo.com? A better approach would be to install the extension and continue as normal, and then next time you search for "convert int to string…

No, Google is only sent that you're blocking the domain. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2218528

But it's only clickable from a search page on Google. Can't they correlate the data pretty easily?

Re: List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

#14
post #5
post #3

I assume that when you block a site, Google are sent the search term as well as the site you blocked. Assuming that this is the case, it isn't very helpful to search for 'mahalo.com' and then block mahalo.com. What do you think should rank higher than mahalo.com for the term mahalo.com? A better approach would be to install the extension and continue as normal, and then next time you search for "convert int to string…

No, Google is only sent that you're blocking the domain. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2218528

That's just the query string - is the HTTP referrer removed from the header?

Re: List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

#15
post #12
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, Google is only sent that you're blocking the domain. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2218528

But it's only clickable from a search page on Google. Can't they correlate the data pretty easily?

Sure, but considering that's the only way to add to the block list I cannot imagine they didn't foresee exactly what we're doing. I'd wager "Let me go find all the sites I hate the most and block them!" is the natural reaction to being given a block list feature.

Re: List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

#16
i think there are some unintended consequences with blacklist list-sharing:

1) if google ever starts using this data as a signal in their search algorithm, do you really think demand media is going to give up, or do you think they are going to start moving their content on the 500k+ domains they own, effectively making it impossible to deal with the problem.

2) list-sharing seems to be starting an arms race where spammy sites start pushing their own lists that include all of their competitor's sites but not their own. (i am not accusing the OP of doing this, but i think its best for each user to choose individually.

if these sites really have such egregiously bad content, then users should very quickly be able to decide for themselves when a site should be blacklisted.

Re: List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

#17
post #13

I find it ironic that this list includes adsense ads with three things totally irreverent to the content.

there is no such a thing as "right" or "wrong" answer in contextual targeting, at least not anymore. Other targeting strategies kick in; even if the text of the page is accurately categorized, you could still be hit with ads targeted at you by profile, or someone is doing category runs (GroupOn ads supersede all others for me) or the site is under review or its content unanalyzed (charity hell), or you're in an experiment, etc.

Re: List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

#18

i think there are some unintended consequences with blacklist list-sharing: 1) if google ever starts using this data as a signal in their search algorithm, do you really think demand media is going to give up, or do you think they are going to start moving their content on the 500k+ domains they own, effectively making it impossible to deal with the problem. 2) list-sharing seems to be starting an arms race where spa…

furthermore, demand media will likely react to any negative implications of this by continuing its partnerships with large existing sites. for example, demand media already creates content for USA today http://www.demandmedia.com/blog/powering-travel-tips-for-usa...

if needed, i am sure demand can cut deals with sites that you probably wouldn't want to blacklist. in the end, search engines are going to have to figure out how to send users to good pages, on a page by page basis.

Re: List of content farms to block with Google Personal Blocklist

#19

i think there are some unintended consequences with blacklist list-sharing: 1) if google ever starts using this data as a signal in their search algorithm, do you really think demand media is going to give up, or do you think they are going to start moving their content on the 500k+ domains they own, effectively making it impossible to deal with the problem. 2) list-sharing seems to be starting an arms race where spa…

This will give Google great data on how to detect content farm content, so it will be easier to penalize on long tail domains or syndication deals.

I shared my domains simply to save people time. If you disagree with one of the results, by all means don't add it to your block list. Adblock lists have been similarly helpful--I make some customizations but I don't have to start from scratch.

Post reply on HN