Live data from Hacker News

Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

tech.economictimes.indiatimes.com

21–30 of 40 posts

Re: Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

#21
post #14
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about finding workers and payroll costs?

A lot of India based SaaS companies register in Singapore or USA while keeping their entire dev team (and sometimes even the rest of it: sales, marketing, support, etc) in India. The incentives being ease of international transactions, capital / debt availability, simpler tax policies.

You'd still need to file taxes in India right?

Re: Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

#23
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For us, its Singapore, low taxation rates, what we understand is low compliance and supports online operations. Proximity to India (5 hours by flight) makes it an ideal destination. Factors Preventing - Nobody in my circle has this setup, making me worried about unknown challenges - Double Taxation issue. I am not clear what will be taxation liability, I have talked to multiple CAs and they all say multiple things -…

What about finding workers and payroll costs?

All major costs (payroll, devs, marketing etc.) are in India. The only cost is accounting/compliance which is again it seems is lesser compared to India.

We need to file taxes in India for operations done in India, yeah so that actually means that we are increasing the overhead of compliance (adding Singapore compliance). Benefits are better funding opportunities, lesser taxation and financial tools to work for your startup.

Re: Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

#24
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A lot of India based SaaS companies register in Singapore or USA while keeping their entire dev team (and sometimes even the rest of it: sales, marketing, support, etc) in India. The incentives being ease of international transactions, capital / debt availability, simpler tax policies.

You'd still need to file taxes in India right?

The company in India only has a fraction of the total revenues and barely any profits, reducing the tax liabilities significantly.

Re: Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

#25

India is becoming a popular destination for foreigners to chase their startup dreams[1]. Same source. [1] https://tech.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/startups/indi...

Most of those startups (like Saavn for example) are also registered and owned abroad (not only in India).

Re: Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

#26
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

India is predicted to be #3 by 2050, almost equaling the US: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/02/the-wor...

It can be a large economy, in part because there are 1.3bn inhabitants, but my point is that people consume services provided by Indian companies largely because they are cheap.

This does not seem true. Indian service sector is very good at its job barring a few bad apples. For example, FinTech industry has done a remarkable job of easing payments. Compare that to Germany where the service sector is just awful. Of course, German competency in manufacturing is far ahead of India right now. It would be great to see both countries fixing up their weak areas in the future.

Re: Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

#27
post #3

What would be their primary destination of choice, and what are the major factors preventing them from moving?

For us, its Singapore, low taxation rates, what we understand is low compliance and supports online operations. Proximity to India (5 hours by flight) makes it an ideal destination. Factors Preventing - Nobody in my circle has this setup, making me worried about unknown challenges - Double Taxation issue. I am not clear what will be taxation liability, I have talked to multiple CAs and they all say multiple things -…

So I would assume you would do development in India while HQ-ing the company in Singapore ? Because I think without having business revenue in Singapore, employee costs can be quite high.

Re: Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

#28
post #9

What exactly "startup-friendly tax regime" does Singapore have and India doesn't?

I think Singapore does not apply capital gains tax for one. Has a simple corporate tax slab of %17 unlike India.

Another plus point is being able to keep profits in SGD as opposed to INR (which depreciates by 5% per year).

Re: Nearly a third of Indian startup founders surveyed are considering moving abroad

#30
post #7

What exactly "startup-friendly tax regime" does Singapore have and India doesn't?

https://inc42.com/features/the-curse-of-angel-tax-travelkhan... In addition to incidents like these, corruption is widespread in India. Exports qualify for GST exemption or refund, but in practice refunds are hard to get (at least without a 5% or more bribe).

5% of how much, though? how much more than 5%?
Post reply on HN